Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Simon Willison

Apparently there are people out there who think it's inappropriate to use Mastodon to talk about books you've written or promote projects you've worked on because it's marketing and self-promotion?

I am not one of those people. I implore you to write about the work you have done and the things you have made - I want to hear about that stuff!

255 comments
sayrer

@simon always made up rules from rich kids. link me your products as long as I am not required to buy them.

Alex White

@simon Thank you for saying that - I love to read about other peoples work, and I like to talk about my work because I hope other people will enjoy that too!

Without marketing and self-promotion, people won’t hear about interesting things!

PJ Coffey

@PlaneSailingGames @simon Ah a good thread, I've found someone else to follow. 😀

Kingsley Uyi Idehen

@simon,

Folks have to understand that rules lie in the hands of a server- moderator, and that's it.

The great thing about the #Fediverse is that:

if you can't find a server and moderator combo that works for you, simply setup your own server with your own rules 😀

Cap Lee

@kidehen @simon i would love to get feedback on some of my education blogs. is this the right place?

Appagal Crochet

@kidehen @simon How limiting... It makes artists feel unwelcome. Our art is part of us... something we want to share. It is as natural to our human form as the shape of our hands or the hair on our heads. Even if people are not interested in my free pattern site I still enjoy the sharing of my work. It can also be denying someone else a grin.

youtube.com/playlist?list=PLuP

A crochet version of Frosty with an orange/red scarf, pipe, and a grey flat top hat. This version is after magic with arms/legs.

@kidehen @simon How limiting... It makes artists feel unwelcome. Our art is part of us... something we want to share. It is as natural to our human form as the shape of our hands or the hair on our heads. Even if people are not interested in my free pattern site I still enjoy the sharing of my work. It can also be denying someone else a grin.

PJ Coffey

@AppalachianCrochet @kidehen @simon I would love to boost your happy snowman! But I can't as it has no alt text. 😞

Dave

@AppalachianCrochet @kidehen @simon hadn’t Heard that yet wait till I start promoting my outdoor nature photography they will really hate it lol

Elizabeth

@AppalachianCrochet I'm definitely interested! Where can we find your site? #crochet #snowman

Jasper Jenkins👵✡️♌️🇺🇲🇺🇦

@AppalachianCrochet @kidehen @simon I have no clue what alt text is. Do you just type those words before you post something 🤔

Appagal Crochet

@JasperJenkins @kidehen @simon Alt text is describing the picture for those who cannot see well but use the forum. I struggle when it comes to describing my own crochet items... it never reads well.

So when you post a pic try to leave a description of what is in the picture allowing them to create the picture in their mind.

Geraldine

@simon I'm precisely in the same boat! I want to hear about what people are working on???

PJ Coffey

@everywhereist @simon well since you ask I'm working on a book which I crowdfunded in November. It's using an upgraded pen and paper gaming system to create conceptual tools to incorporate the concept of vehicles into a fantasy RPG.

It's quite niche but I like it. My previous work is about bringing nature vs nurture to a setting (see profile). It's because in D&D you can't make a character from Pratchett's "Guards! Guards!" But now you can.

💚🌲💙⭐⭐Romulus / Keith 🌹🍺✌⚽

@simon I'm hearing about it but I'm not seeing it. Then again I am not one of the affected people.

If you're #hawking your #own #creations I think that's legit. It's not like people are in here selling #Amway and shit.

Daniel Wurzbacher

@simon I would love nothing more than to be made aware of a new #author / #artist / #startup I can feel good about spending money with. Bring on the self-promotion!

Osha Davidson ☑

@simon I agree — it’s one of the reasons I’m here. I’m a freelance journalist writing about #ClimateChange in the #Southwest. I’m always looking for new sources for stories whether that’s from scientist/researchers, community organizers, or folks working in government on policy issues. If that describes you, hit me up!

Bradley_JF

@simon Just ignore people like that. If they don't want to see it, they have tools to customize their feed.

Hans Konings - kamasys HQ

@simon Read about my fascination with the Catalan way of telling what time it is, including a working Flash (!) animation of a Catalan clock:

kamasys.nl/archivo/2021/10/15/

(Google Translate or Deepl your good friend)

Shannon Clark

@simon please do. I’ve already bought a few books from people here on Mastodon. And expect I’ll buy many more.

PJ Coffey

@Rycaut @simon well assuming you don't want dnd books...

Cutting edge trans robot Sci fi can be found with #KiraLeigh and his #ConstelisVoss stuff.

It's potentially niche but you could be reading it before it becomes famous. 😀

Shannon Clark

@Homebrewandhacking @simon I’ve been a GM since the red box era, skipped 3.0/3.5 because I was running other systems (played and ran a lot of World of Darkness games, was a serious MtG player in the pre-pro tour era), am a 4 star PFS GM for Pathfinder and now also play and run 5e and collect ttrpg books (have more than I’ll ever have a group to run thru). So dnd book suggestions quite welcome though I’m likely to already have many

PJ Coffey

@Rycaut @simon

Well the stuff I write is for #LevelUpA5e which is a fork of D&D that provides better GM support and removes racism/ablism. A key to that is separating species and culture into distinct _mechanical_ components (a5e.tools/rules/origin) which my books take and guide in how to do for your own Creations using a point based (relative) system.

It's not for everyone. But tell your friends? 😀 maybe they'll want it?

drivethrurpg.com/m/browser/pub

@Rycaut @simon

Well the stuff I write is for #LevelUpA5e which is a fork of D&D that provides better GM support and removes racism/ablism. A key to that is separating species and culture into distinct _mechanical_ components (a5e.tools/rules/origin) which my books take and guide in how to do for your own Creations using a point based (relative) system.

NanaKim

@simon That should be welcomed, not considered inappropriate. I've never done anything worth noting, but if I had, I would be promoting it.

Stefan Edward Jones

@simon I put promos behind a CW, just in case, but I don't hesitate to plug my stuff. When I remember to!

PJ Coffey

@StefanEJones @simon ah yes, I suspected I'd see that server. 😀

What stuff do you make? What's it about? How do you play?

I'd like to know more!

Callie Laren

@simon I haven't written any books yet. Working on one but far from finished. I wish I still had the physics paper I wrote in 2002, but the physical copies got lost in a move and the digital copies probably got scrambled somewhere or the hard drives died.

When I do finish this book, I'll proudly promote it. Until then everyone will have to make do with bowling scores, selfies, and occasional bad jokes about the trans experience in Texas.

Astrobach :breadified:

@simon Are there? It's one thing if that's ALL you do, but it's basically just saying "I'll only accept stuff I find through corporate marketing" otherwise.

This is the generation of indie publishing and marketing. Great stuff to be found.

DopeGhoti

@simon
IMO if you (the general "you", not you specifically) are plugging your own neat things you've created, good! Plug on and if I dig, I'll Boost!

But if you're getting paid to promote stuff because you have a wide following, I'll block and move on.

#SelfPromotion and #Advertising are different things, though there is an overlap to be conscious of.

PJ Coffey

@DopeGhoti @simon that is clearly not the topic of conversation. You dislike those who can be described as a #PaidShill and rightly so!

:gentoo: dumass incarnate

@simon I got the impression that marketing was a feature of social media? Strange that there would be people against that...

PJ Coffey

@c30 @simon How else would you hear about _marginalised_ creators who, by definition, aren't going to be picked up by big companies? 🤔 or people who do niche things you never knew you needed?

Biggles

@simon

Post what you find interesting or useful, including your own work. People are free to block. You won't miss them.

Jennifer Reitman

@simon if people (especially writers/journalists) didn't promote their work, we wouldn't have half the contributor base we do at @damemagazine. It's how we find new writers!

Karsten Johansson

@simon I follow some people solely because they post the stuff they are doing with Raspberry Pi and Arduino.

And I know someone on @onfosec.exchange who wrote a book, I think hasn't mentioned it on Mastodon, but maybe once in a while totally should. It's a niche book of interest only to those "in the biz", and there are a lot of people who would probably want to know about it.

And I'm not against people who review things by actually building something with the product. It's easy enough to differentiate a good review and demo from an all-out sponsored advertisement.

There is a difference between sharing your productive self, and hawking on behalf of a trillion dollar organization.

@simon I follow some people solely because they post the stuff they are doing with Raspberry Pi and Arduino.

And I know someone on @onfosec.exchange who wrote a book, I think hasn't mentioned it on Mastodon, but maybe once in a while totally should. It's a niche book of interest only to those "in the biz", and there are a lot of people who would probably want to know about it.

PJ Coffey

@ksaj @simon exactly. This is the place to get niche things that you can NOT get elsewhere.

No one wants a #PaidShill to be pretending to be enthusiastic about stuff. Unpaid shills! All the way!

Basti

@simon I bought already 2 new ebooks because the authors promotet their work here and had good reviews. I'm all for it as long as people use the right hashtags and don't constantly spam it 🙂

PJ Coffey

@Wabu @simon it's a fine line between spam and self promotion isn't it?

A friend of mine @begaydocrimes does cool books about trans robots. Want to know more? 😀 #ConstelisVoss

Basti

@Homebrewandhacking @simon @begaydocrimes Thanks that sounds interesting. Will definitely look at it 🙂

Fahim Farook

@simon Thank you for saying this 🙂 I have had no issue about talking about the software I work on, but books, I’ve always felt as if it was too much self-promotion …

Maybe this is self-evident, but you made me realize that I can talk about the stuff I write and still not be actually marketing … So thank you again for leading me to that realisation 🙂

Joe Siegler

@simon what is the logic? Why would that be considered wrong?

Adam Hall 🇳🇿🇺🇸 :birdsite:

@simon @davidvasandani please do! No gatekeeping here, I want to hear about your projects, and hey if it’s good we can support it!

The fediverse is for everyone.

PJ Coffey

@Adman @simon @davidvasandani Well when you wake up you should revisit this thread and check out the creators who replied (not just me. Statistically you're unlikely to want my stuff but if you have a friend who might... maybe let them know? 😀 )

Ryan Legg

@simon @glennf yes! Promote your stuff - be proud of your work

sparseMatrix ✅✅✅ 📻

@simon
It’s about all I ever talk about, but I’m not really doing much by way of promoting 😉

sparseMatrix ✅✅✅ 📻

@Homebrewandhacking @simon

Hmmm, let’s see!

I do art of any kind, from block prints through woodworking, on to painting in any media, and generally its software when I’m talking about real $$$ as I am a free lance python programmer (full stack). Currently I am involved with crypto bro who scored big, who is paying me to develop a social media piece that ultimately will be both open source and #federated.

How’d I do?
😎

PJ Coffey

@sparseMatrix @simon there are regrettable and environmentally damaging things mentioned which really gives me pause.

I've seen the # fedijobs used for skilled computational work.

As to the art, that's really, I feel, the focus of the thread. Artists self promoting because that's their actual living where they've moved from a potential 130 mn audience to 0.8-8 mn depending on how you count.

The Vinyl Ape ☑️

@simon if anybody ever tells you it’s inappropriate to talk about things you’ve created or worked on, you :
A. Tell them to FUCK OFF
B. Tell them it’s time to shave off their neck beards, move out of their parents’ basement, and create or work on something themselves
C. See A and B
Happy holidays. 🌲

PJ Coffey

@TheVinylApe @simon not the best look for a creator in a public space. Sounds satisfying though. Punk AF but doesn't pay the bills.

The Vinyl Ape ☑️

@Homebrewandhacking @simon that’s a good point. Luckily for me, all my bills are paid. I just can’t stand those kind of people. They’re mostly unhappy and miserable with their own lives, so they’re intent on making everybody else feel like shit. I don’t like that. I’ve never stood for it, nor will I ever.

PJ Coffey

@TheVinylApe @simon thanks! 😀

If you want to really stick it to them? Put them on _mute_ and then say nice things and boost the artists getting flack.

ABBA. Always Be Boosting Artists.

(Artists meaning creative people not just a scandi group. 😉 )

Tim Ellis 🦝

@simon OK, since this appeared on my timeline, I'll share the very silly podcast about parallel dimensions that I've been publishing weekly for almost five years: Dispatches from the Multiverse. I hope someone will enjoy it! dispatches.fm/

Barbara H Rosenwein

@simon
Thank you! I agree. We don't write books just to market them. We write them because (we hope) we have something to say that others may profit (morally, intellectually, via self knowledge) from

Rustled Teapot

@simon I keep seeing people complaining about this but never see the actual posts. Do we need a hashtag for calling out this behavior?

#MastadonIsForThis or something maybe?

DarylDevore

@simon Thank you - from all the writers, singers, painters etc. I've been scared to post anything about my books.

DarylDevore

@Homebrewandhacking @simon Thank you for asking. Currently a medieval fantasy - the 3rd book in a series.

joann a lawler

@simon One of my major reasons for starting to use social media was to learn about new books from authors & reviewers

astroPug

@simon

Agreed! I purposely followed a bunch of authors here, hoping very much to hear about their new books, and other output.

PJ Coffey

@ShannonWebb @simon

That is true actually. Something to consider.

Twitter has 130 million daily users of whom 13 million generate 90% of its content.

Mastodon has... 8 million accounts? How many people generate content? Say 1.6 million due to moderation doubling participation.

If a potential customer base shrinks from 130 to 8 or 13 to 1.6 maybe... you can see that this would induce anxiety on an untested platform. 😀

Parityflux

@simon I like to hear what others are doing. I also like to hear more information than just a posting of a link. Tell me something! Something interesting or noteworthy about the link (book, music, article, film). It’s pretty rare that I follow links if there is nothing but a promotional context.

PJ Coffey

@parityflux @simon well that's bad marketing isn't it? Better marketing would be talking about a really unique book that 100% will _never_ be published in mainstream places because writing about trans robots is not the marketplace gold that you'd hope. But maybe you know someone who would like to read about the work of @begaydocrimes and #ConstelisVoss ? :-?

Lynn Grant

@simon I have no problem with that kind of self-promotion.

andrei

@simon absolutely! people’s work and thoughts is what can make this platform really interesting, so I cannot get those who want to make it inappropriate… do they want just shitposting?

Laura Durnell

@simon Isn't that what else social media is used for?

PJ Coffey

@lauradurnell @simon Fascists never tire of using a platform to do it and Twitter gave them a great way to do it.

See quote retweets and Donald Trump and the sort of publicity money literally cannot buy.

GabeMoralesVR

@simon I sort of get the feeling that people who think self promotion are bad have never created anything in their life

MegNelsonArt

@simon My latest painting. This is study for a larger painting. Local horsewoman wants me do a portrait of her rescued mustang.

MichaelHK

@simon

I built my Mastodon server as a Hong Kongers community-focused server with nearly 100 bots mirroring prominent China + Hong Kong dissidents accounts including @nathanlawkc_mirror @jooeysiiu_mirror #artist @aiww_mirror @badiucao_mirror #journalist @WilliamYang120_mirror @JChengWSJ_mirror #media @bbcchinese_mirror

Darth Oldius

@simon I don't promote my stuff online because it's all for GED students at my college, but I promote the hell out of my friends' stuff.

Chris Anderson

@simon not to mention, compared to other platforms, everyone here seems far more supportive of other people's endeavours

PJ Coffey

@sproosemoose @simon well less trolls and bigots. Art and idealism make good bedfellows. Of the 1,000,000,000 Twitter accounts, 130,000,000 logged in daily and 13,000,000 did 90% of the content.

If a fraction of that 13mn people, say, artists, writers etc left than that would be devastating. 😀

Jonathan Bartels

@simon agreed. Promote away. No one else will. I learned that long ago.

jamie hill 🏴‍☠️

@simon not that we haven't talked about this on the main tl, we have, because we share your view ... but! here, for you personally, since you feel this way, is our new @shannoncurtis album. the sound is 80s-inflected artpop; the topic is reclaiming one's personal peace and power in hard times. the title song was a #1 radio hit in oregon, of all places. we hope you love it. 🖤 songwhip.com/shannoncurtis/goo

Jono Ferguson

@simon I think as long as people aren't being spammy or beggy - then go for it.

I mean, if it is really annoying they'll get unfollowed or blocked by a lot of people.

I get having the general rule so companies don't set up and try and spoil the vibe.

Rebecca Heisman

@simon Thank you! I get weird feelings every time I post here about my forthcoming book but like, I worked really hard on it and I think it's really cool and I want it to be successful? harpercollins.com/products/fli

positron 🖖

@simon absolutely #Mastodon is literally the place you should talk about the work you've done if you want!

There's no algorithm to put it in front of a bunch of people who don't want to see it, and nobody has to follow you.

Toot all about it, and if you make a little money from, it even better.

BillStewart415

@simon Authors, artists, and other creatives promoting their work and discussing each others' work is one of the many things that added value to Twitter, and I'd be disappointed if it didn't happen here.

billy joe bowers - Harris2024

@simon

I keep thinking about the person on here who said that when they joined a long time ago, someone told them "We don't do jokes on Mastodon".

We do what we do.

Mara Rada :verified:

@simon the devil is in the details. My server, for example, has explicit rules against advertising. I agreed to join so I play by those rules.
Plus, there’s a vast difference between subtly mentioning what one does vs. using the platform as a sales megaphone.
For those who just want the sales megaphone, Linkedin may be better. There, everyone talks about what they sell, with little room to discuss anything else.
Here ppl are more nuanced, and we must be mindful of the audience

PJ Coffey

@mararada @simon sure but:

The audience here has gone from 130 million to maybe 8 million. 130 customers to 8. That's a big hit to your cash flow.

mastodon.ie/@Homebrewandhackin

Corrado

@simon You're right, I learned this last year, when you are in love with what you do, you gradually become successful and with the right knowledge about cashflow, you become wealthy, you become successful after realising a worthy ideal.

Eric Beaudry

@simon not one of those either unless you're pushy and trying to convince me to buy something. In which case, I'm might get trigger happy with the mute button.

mem_somerville

@simon I have already bought a book I learned about here, and Santa is bringing it shortly....

Mike Gerdts

@simon and please use appropriate hashtags so it is more discoverable.

#selfPromotion #artists #makers

The Dapper Diner

@simon That's silly. People should 100% promote their art, their podcasts, their projects. Why would people want to make this place feel like a weird gated community with HOA rules?

toxtethogrady

@simon I will shamelessly send you all cartoons. Don't say you weren't warned!

Joseph Meyer

@simon As one with no formal computer science background, aside from an introductory course that used punch cards 42 years ago, I confess to creating some goofy kludges using HTML forms, Perl scripts, SPSS syntax, and a periodically running .BAT file that looked for user submissions and then ran descriptive statistical reports about the variables they chose. 😂

Sexy Ageing

@simon I wrote a book called “My Menopause Memoir” it’s on #amazon and it’s helping people 🙌🏼

Cap Lee

@simon sounds good. I have designed a school within the public school system that doesn't use a standardized test

Mori

@simon Nothing wrong with self promotion. More so than ever on #Masto. I don’t have to listen. There is no algorithm jamming you down my throat. If anything, the fact you are here and letting me know what you have found iterating enough to write about it appreciates.

CarrieB ☕🐱 📚

@simon I've been a writer for well over 35 years now. I recently re-opened my own blog (carriescornerblog.blogspot.com), which I've had since 2005. I publish once per week, and I welcome anyone, and everyone, to share their own views, opinions, blogs and work with me. That's how we all learn, grow and relate to each other. Have a wonderful holiday! :blobcatcoffee: 🎄 ☕

Claire Barnes

@simon "the work you have done and the things you have made" - definitely! The willingness of public health experts and scientists from all different fields to share expertise has been invaluable during the pandemic, and we need safe spaces and channels for communication to continue.

And I personally would be sad if I couldn't talk about the book that I edited, and the resources we've made available in the public domain... h-net.social/@ClaireFromClare/

ominoussage

@simon they're probably thinking of those as something similar to ads and they don't like ads, so i get what they're going for.

Crunchysteve

@simon I agree. Those of us who make things with our hands are hardly capitalist, and free, open-source software doesn't mean the users must never use it to promote what they do and never make money. I'm a political anarchist, but we still live in a capitalist society and regardless of a political system one might live under we are all interesting and we all have to put bread on the table.

Morpheus Being

@simon I make useful things from leather. Supplements my meagre income.

tracklayer

@simon Can I suggest adding a picture of a cat might deter many of the critics.

Йерун

@simon as a bookperson I think its great when ppl plug their books here. I hate to wait for a publisher to promote it...

Adam Gonnerman

@simon #SelfPromo is no problem here. Just some people trying to run the show.

DeFrisselle ☑️

@simon

Been seeing a lot of Hate from peticualr groups this week against creators showing, pubishing, talking about, and most of all trying to sell their wares

Mad Sci ∴

@simon
Yes, the rules of your instance are not the rules of the fediverse.

Chris Aguinaldo

@simon I edit a #Hawaii building management magazine and somehow find ways to write about #sustainability, helping the #homeless and in an upcoming issue, the importance of supporting the #performing #arts in communities. I started my career as a community #newspaper journalist, telling stories of small town residents and it shows in my current work!

KaraOhki

@simon Yes, I want to see and hear also!

Clockwork ☃️✒️

@simon

Diving right in!

I'm working on a fantasy set in Neolithic, where a superior limbless race keeps humans from developing culture. By mistake, a teen with memory impairment comes up with a proto-writing technique, and as it spreads humans start using it as a tool of self-determination.

There’s also archaeology and different attempts at democracy being built along the way!

addie

@simon @RareBookLibAntw my favorite thing about this app is seeing all the cool stuff people make

Rob Hague

@simon @darnell I'm new here, but the notion that there's a single Mastodon community with uniform notions of appropriateness seems counter to the idea of federation. Surely the point is that everyone gets to pick their own subset of instances or users to join? If someone wants a completely non-commercial space, go for it, but there's no need to have one rule for all everyone.

Darnell Clayton :verified:

@robhague @simon That is true. Every #Mastodon instance has their own specific rules that we ultimately must abide by.

If one disagrees with the rules, then I suggest launching their own solo instance (which I highly recommend):

👉🏾 darnell.day/updated-stress-fre

I personally have no issue with people promoting their business or even asking for money (as long as it’s not via Private message, Matrix or email).

PJ Coffey

@simon Well! I do something extremely niche. I make conceptual tool kits for people who run #DnD and #LevelUpA5e (forms of #TTRPG) to create (homebrew) their own worlds splitting species and culture and giving them their own mechanical effects (hacking). These dry technical manuals allow very detailed customisation and subtley teach how to do it yourself.

My work is found here: drivethrurpg.com/m/browser/pub

Boosts welcome. 😀

Hans-Helge

@simon some people have strange opinions about what is OK and what isn't on Mastodon

MizzBassie

@simon
How boring would it be if people never talked about what they did or made! Talk about these things, people, they make you who you are!

J. Randall Todd

@simon im blissfully unaware of these puritanical edicts. Toot your horn. If you get too qvc I’ll ‘curate’ accordingly. Congrats on the book!

Adrian Morales

@simon Even without such negative people, it's already super difficult for indie writers and artisans to promote their work, so thank you.

Vlad Temper

@simon
I'm writting (working in the stretch goals of) a solo ttrpg succesfully funded in kickstarter called Bloodstained Hands and I am working with a publisher to release a former ttrpg called No Man Hills ☺️☺️☺️

Martha

@simon
Nor am I. Please do share the things you've created with us.

Ignore the wanna-be Mastodon police!

Cathode Ray Tube

@simon Thank you. I was rather concerned that I would be frowned upon here for telling people that something I’d worked on for two and a half years had been published and that they might be interested in it.

If you’re a creative why wouldn’t you want to show and tell? If you don’t talk about what you’ve written then no one will read it and you’ll be discouraged from doing more.

skry

@simon

Hello, indie media. People should be celebrated for creating something. Communities everywhere support their artisans.

I bet no one is complaining about the quilters or the coders.

I've seen a bunch of photographers, a scale model builder, some painters and crocheters just today. No complainers.

Thomas Gronfeldt

@simon I've seen a few people get backlash, too. Don't get it. As long as you're not shouting into my feed with totally irrelevant info, you should definitely use what platforms you have (Mastodon included) to promote the stuff you've made and are proud of.

Vox Populi

@simon @TheCyborgintheGarden I agree! I WANT to see people’s art, hear people’s music, and read what people have written!

Please promote your work!

Go Up