Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Mike Masnick ✅

Lol. Musk is seeing the exodus, so he's trying to bar the doors as everyone rushes for the exits.

No more linking to other social networks or sharing your username.

Such free speech.

223 comments
Jon Renaut

@mmasnick Tribel and Nostr have to be pumped to be included, I've never heard of them

PPP Grifter

@ebooksyearn @mmasnick tribel is not great imo. It’s the Parler for the other spectrum

Jon Renaut

@PPP_Grifter @mmasnick but Twitter noticed them! They probably got three, maybe 4 new users today!

hybrid havoc

@ebooksyearn Yeah Nostr feels like it's in its infancy. Including that but not Gab or Parler is pretty funny.

Mike Masnick ✅

@ebooksyearn I've been playing around with Nostr. It has maybe 500 users and is extremely barebones (I mentioned it here the other day). But Jack Dorsey is talking about it, so that's how it got included.

Tribel got some buzz at the beginning of the Musk regime as a possible alternative (it sucks).

Robert A. Hill

@mmasnick @ebooksyearn Tribel not only sucks, it’s run by naked grifters.

Keith Ivey

@ebooksyearn @mmasnick So the Twitter terms are themselves in violation of the Twitter terms by promoting those services?

HarpSilver

@ebooksyearn @mmasnick I've heard of Tribal and Post but not Nostr but I'm now curious🤔🤓

Katherine ✨️ she/her

@mmasnick Does he not realise how many "normal users" use and have linktrees?

Dan

@cupcakezealot @mmasnick he'll amend it to allow promoting other websites if you're a blue subscriber, to try and blackmail higher sub rates

Ben Haube 🏳️‍🌈🐧:twit:

@mmasnick LMAO. Good luck #Elmo.

What's the old saying? F around and find out?

Will Smith

@mmasnick the speed run of the failing 90s message board strategies continues.

eathdemon

@will @mmasnick end of a era will miss fallowing everyone on a single platform.

Glenn Fleishman

@mmasnick Your tweets aren't at Twitter, Mike! They're in Joan's house! And Mr. Postini's house!

Social Commentary Bot

@mmasnick Would you say this will become an example of the Streisand effect?

By which I mean would you, specifically, say that into a microphone so we can get a soundbite of it for posterity?

Mike Masnick ✅

@SocialCommentaryBot I don't get to decide these things. The Streisand Effect prevails on its own...

hybrid havoc

@mmasnick serves as a stark reminder that if one is purchasing a social media site, what they are really purchasing is the list of registered users.

Magenta Rocks

@mmasnick

And its not like we can't find people elsewhere without a link in a bird site profile?

Ken White

@mmasnick The cultists rushing to defend this will be gross

monorail times

@Popehat @mmasnick I’ve already seen “it’s free speech, not free advertising” as the talking point lmao

DELETED

@Popehat @mmasnick Wait so "Mastodon" is a no-go, but "Hometown" is fine? 🤔

Jxyzn Sxyzyxn

@Popehat @mmasnick link-ban evaders are almost certainly going to be found nearly exclusively by muskovite tattletales, I assume, also.

CB

@Popehat @mmasnick I've got the picture of Apu jumping in front of the robber just ready to go.

Joseph Simko

@Bethany @Popehat @mmasnick

I can admit I WAS a Musk fanboy as recently as 2019, but I have the grace to admit I was wrong. I do think his rise to stratospheric wealth and power is contributing to his downfall. Nobody can tell him 'NO' anymore.

Dan

@Popehat @mmasnick Defend what? They're too busy listening to the libs who are all screaming right now which is all they ever wanted. Would be way more effective if there was no reaction at all in my opinion.

E.G. Phillips

@tundrafox907 @Popehat @mmasnick this is not a set of people known for their restraint

Dan

@duckswithpants @Popehat @mmasnick no reaction from US. We need to respond to stuff like this with "are you still talking?" energy.

Joseph Simko

@tundrafox907 @Popehat @mmasnick

I kinda identify as a Lib and I'm just laughing. 🤣

Joseph Simko

@emm @mmasnick

Can't piss China and the Nazis off. They're gonna be his only customers.

Blackout The Conspiracy

@mmasnick we all need to give out a collective booing on bird site 🤣

BJC860

@mmasnick I said this over there too, but this self-own is absolutely going to be historic.

Lt.Cpl Хуёвый Пчеловод

@BJC860 @mmasnick I think we may have underestimated the scale of this dumpster fire by more than a few standard deviations...

Lt.Cpl Хуёвый Пчеловод

@mmasnick I wonder whether aknowledging existence of other social media sites is also a permaban...

DELETED

@mmasnick But the important question, is comedy still legal?

kkeller

@lefcadio @mmasnick all of Twitter is now a comedy of errors.

Hammancheez

@lefcadio @mmasnick well given twitter’s become a fucking joke… I guess technically?

Justin Ferrell

@lefcadio @mmasnick it’s literally the only thing left. No links to any other websites, no vague allusions to the idea of a news story. Just the same three consecutive jokes with different kinds of sprinkles on them.

Nyke "Nate Trent" Young

@lefcadio @mmasnick Yes, you can still post, for example, "Elon has control of the situation."

vruz

@mmasnick Blatantly illegal as per GDPR rules in the EU.

I don't see how this can be sustained without a major injunction.

z3z

@mmasnick notably Tiktok isn't on that list 🤔

lroop

@z3z
@mmasnick Elon probably doesn't want to risk the CCP shutting down his factories or refusing to sell him lithium for EV batteries.

Dirk Hohndel

@mmasnick
This is just too funny. The desperation in all this..

Brian Drell 🇺🇦

@dirkhh @mmasnick He’s such a sad, pathetic little person. Being a narcissist sounds exhausting and extremely unsatisfying.

Scott, present & accounted for

@mmasnick Each day brings a new level of cray-cray and hypocrisy.

Magnus Hedemark

@mmasnick link to source? Sorry, I've been seeing some believable but ultimately fake screen captures from the birdsite.

Thad

@mmasnick I guess we've hit the "keyword filters don't work" stage in the moderation learning curve.

...I feel like we should maybe think of another name for that. When it comes to whatever the fuck it is Musk is doing at Twitter, any description with the word "learning" in it is clearly a misnomer.

Chris Foreman

@mmasnick, not that I expect any consistency, of course, but what's the difference between linking to another social site and, um, linking to *anything* else separate from the site?

I do raise this partially because it makes me wonder if that's next - throttling or prohibiting links to (disfavored) news sites. Really, it's time to break away from that place.

James

@mmasnick Does he think this is a bankrun and he can just stop withdrawals?

rjgnyc

@mmasnick I’m now wondering if the “we removed you saying where you posted from” was really a backdoor to prevent any third party API saying you’re posting via another platform (and to go there instead).

JoD

@mmasnick so changing my profile pic to my mastodon screen name is a violation but if I want to use my linked in or I was on some rabid right wing troll farm social platform I’d be fine. What a douche.

KBLeecaster ✅

@jodmentum @mmasnick
I think that people that haven't been banned from the birdsite yet should just post screenshots of their toots there. That should put your handle out in a way that won't be identified easily by the algorithm wouldn't it?

Plus, it would help piss off the trust fund manbaby far-right grifting fake tech boy some more I imagine.

Damion Schubert

@mmasnick Nothing says ‘these are the best numbers Twitter’s ever seen!’ quite like this.

Dan

@ZenOfDesign @mmasnick

I can't wait to see how Musk's Renfields (David and Jason) try to spin this as some sort of top level business thinking.

Like Jason is going to stupidly relate it to "Amazon will never let a Wal Mart link on their website!"

While David will some how say it is breaking anti-trust laws and punishable by 50 years in federal prisons to force Twitter to host a link on its website that goes to a competitor.

Dan

@ZenOfDesign @mmasnick
Oh and him not banning Gab and Parler links? LOL.
He does know where a majority of his current fanbase comes from at least.

permanant record

@mmasnick omg not even allowed to provide the username. What a big baby.

Bethany

@mmasnick twitter locking down. Nobody can escape

eathdemon

@mmasnick well nice while it lasted, everyone I fallow on twitter is scatoring to the wind (a bunch of difrent sites) end of a era.

Sloane Justice-Rose

@mmasnick A capitalist that is used to buying out his competition has no idea what to do when the free market happens is rich

Mark A Lemley

@mmasnick Looks like I’m getting banned after the fact for having Mastodon in my username. So glad I left that hellhole

Norman

@marklemley
@mmasnick yeah I just set up mass delete on my account. Will put it in virtual mothballs until it gets banned

Mike Merritt

@mmasnick So by prohibiting linktr.ee he's going to hurt most people with a network of professional sites?

Arkenor

@mmasnick If they actually enforced that, the place would be empty. It'll only be applied to his enemies.

That might still be a lot of people.

Blanding S Turtle

@mmasnick
Oh this is awesome!

Anyone remember the grass mud horse and other censorship work-arounds? Comedy gold!

The Skeptic's Book of Lists

@mmasnick Is the a real Twitter policy? Given Musk I don't doubt it but... golly.

Rahulg86

@mmasnick now is the time for about.me to reign again!

DELETED

@mmasnick

The final instruction should be, "And finally, have fun!"

Kelley

@mmasnick on the bird, I looked at profiles to see where they were going. Not that I had a big account, but this should fall within his new rules. Easy for them to search terms, but they can’t search images as easily, can they? Birds could write their new locations on their headers, couldn’t they?

StuartT

@mmasnick I changed my username to my mastodon url a while back. I also put my Counter Social link in my profile and a pic with both Mastodon and Post links. I wonder how long my account will last.

benevolent bastard

@mmasnick Soooo, MySpace and Tumblr get a pass? …innnteresting 🤔

abenomicon

@mmasnick the 'paid promotion is okay' loophole in the new policy is interesting because it means they can't plausibly say this is a safety issue -- it's purely anticompetitive

Burningbird

@mmasnick And then there's this when you click a Mastodon link that was created before this Free Speech extravaganza

John Montgomery

@mmasnick You knew it was going to happen. I’m out of there. The water over here is much nicer.

Mike Masin

@mmasnick

I want to burn my twitter user name. That's an excellent way to get my account banned without violating reasonable TOS on any other platform.

Working on it now!

DELETED

@mmasnick I'm not expert in anything but isn't competition the main driver for innovation - at least according to libertarians? If Musk locks out any competition, doesn't that make him a... socialist??? :blobcatscared:

Tanner Spaw

@mmasnick I logged into my account to see if I can speedrun my way into getting banned

Daniel Zenon Klein

@mmasnick @Standplaats_KRK yeah what does this have to mean for twitters user numbers

Octopus

@mmasnick That complicates the concept of social media 🤔

Tom

@mmasnick What step of the social media speedrun is literally banning the name of every other social media network?

Don Ray

@mmasnick
It seemed to work to put a screenshot of my Mastodon profile as my pinned Tweet. People on Twitter can’t just click a link, but they can see where to go.

(Flawed) Anarchist ⚑

@mmasnick Elmo is getting desperate. Have you seen him going to Qatar for investment along with Trump's son in law?

Since Twitter was all about access (atleast in the past), he is now attempting to sell that access to dictators around the world. Won't be long before he starts monetising all the past data (dms, chats & interactions) within twitter about political enemies (opposition party members, activists, journalists, civil society organizations, …) of elite in various countries.

Many of these dictators, their henchmen & spooks would be more than happy to pay $ to influence & also know who their enemies are & what they discussed/currently discussing on twitter.

Since Elmo cannot not be a dictator & can't control himself, he is accelerating the damage as much as he can.

Like someone else put aptly: Twitter is a town square with draw bridges.

@mmasnick Elmo is getting desperate. Have you seen him going to Qatar for investment along with Trump's son in law?

Since Twitter was all about access (atleast in the past), he is now attempting to sell that access to dictators around the world. Won't be long before he starts monetising all the past data (dms, chats & interactions) within twitter about political enemies (opposition party members, activists, journalists, civil society organizations, …) of elite in various countries.

MediaBaron

@mmasnick #ElonPutz is not barring the doors. He’s boarding up the windows so those still in the building can’t see who’s leaving and where they’re going to. He doesn’t like sunshine. Folks can’t see that the grass is greener outside.

Em

@mmasnick isn’t it funny how right wing sites like Gab, Parler and Gettr aren’t included?

Orla

@mmasnick The free speech absolutist is actually a speech control freak.

Jelcoco

@mmasnick Very curious about the numbers going around at Twitter right now. No doubt the platform has had it’s most active period with all this drama. At the same time lots of people are leaving.

Aaron MacNeil

@mmasnick I noticed this today as I was trying to add my Mastodon handle to my Twitter bio and it kept telling me I was linking to malware. 😂 RIP bird app.

Cysio :verified_gay:​

@mmasnick he bans linktree but not your own website, so I just gotta post up the link to my Mastodon on my website that's linked on Twitter

Monica Rooney

@mmasnick @TabathaSouthey my server is very slow right now so I think people are fleeing

Claire Lovell

@mmasnick lol I found out this from this tweet and just deleted it from my Twitter profile before I get banned. So dumb.

James

@mmasnick Onlyflan seems conspicuously absent.

Joachim Ziebs

@mmasnick @taylorlorenz I‘ve put my username into the location field. Let‘s see how long it will take to ban me.

That said, to check this I had to log in again and was shocked by the number of ads delivered to me. Definitely more than ever before.

accela

@mmasnick that second rule about link aggregators is the one that pisses me off. Many sex workers using that way to promote their work on different platforms.
Now they going to be in danger of getting suspended?

Dr. Guillermo Power :verified:

@mmasnick this isn’t locking us in, this is pushing us out! We don’t have to stay if he’s making the place hostile.

Jake

@mmasnick Me. All morning. Watching this insanity unfold.

vatsan

@mmasnick Sounds like LinkedIn is a friend of Twitter. Or maybe someone just forgot that it exists 🤷

herrMartin

@mmasnick lately we forget how shitty meta is. The same is on Instagram with a lot of "forbidden" site. But unlike on Twitter you won't get a notice only your account gets shadow banned.

BlackstoneXL

@mmasnick wrong - Twitter user engagement is up - the world doesn’t revolve around 20 something Palo Alto left wing activists

Michele :ablobderpy:

@mmasnick
So is he going to suspend Facebook’s Twitter account then?

kittycatsrule

@mmasnick I just keep tweeting yesterday's wapo article about how to get started on mastodon. I'll continue to do that til my account is closed.

John Slyfield

@mmasnick I'm still waiting for Mark Zuckerberg to ban me from facebook for sharing my Mastadon links. Oh wait, he doesn't have to.

Ryan McShane, Ph.D.

@mmasnick @enbrown

It doesn't look like an outright block to *all* Mastodon links. Here's what I get from my 11/7/22 tweet directing my Twitter followers to my Mastodon account (by link). I was able to follow the link to my profile in the Twitter browser after this.

Perhaps it's a prospective policy change that doesn't affect old tweets and activity?

Anne Ursu

@mmasnick @taylorlorenz from an anti-trust perspective, is this…okay?

Lesgreenhalgh

@mmasnick the obfuscation this will generate will be hilarious "I'm off to join the friends of John"

Go Up