If your EVs aren't selling maybe that's because you're making giant fucking trucks and SUVs and hyper-expensive luxury sedans and the kind of people who want EVs mostly just want a compact car for getting to work and running errands.
Just sayin'.
Dana Fried
If your EVs aren't selling maybe that's because you're making giant fucking trucks and SUVs and hyper-expensive luxury sedans and the kind of people who want EVs mostly just want a compact car for getting to work and running errands. Just sayin'. 183 comments
Kevin Collas-Arundell
@tess every ev rebate\grant program should be limited to compact normal shaped cars (SUVs banned entirely) or (preferably) ebikes
😀🚲
@coregaze @kca @tess ENOUGH people can ride bikes that 90% of us don't need to be driving cars for short trips. Not everyone can drive a car. But even if they could, mandating cars as the ONLY transportation option cannot work because #GeometryHatesCars. There are bikes for people with special needs, extra cargo, passengers, #eBikes, #AdaptiveBikes, #CargoBikes that could replace over half of car trips if SOME minuscule fraction of cars (& mostly just the bad drivers) would get out of the way
⚳ rapid unscheduled assembly ⚳
@enobacon @kca @tess Don't get me wrong, I own an electric bike _and_ an electric motorcycle, but my partner can't ride either of those alone due to physical limitations, and for some purposes the car is just better. I should point out that the car is a nice little reasonably sized Chevy Bolt and not some oversized freaking monster truck.
😀🚲
@coregaze @kca @tess there are many kinds of adaptive bikes which can help people with physical limitations personally experience the benefits of e-bike rebates & bike infrastructure, via cycle. But even for people who really need a car, getting the vast majority of people onto bikes for SOME trips is going to be a net mobility win for not being stuck in traffic, less parking pressure, affordable housing, pretty much every metric that makes cities work. Not everyone can drive. #CarsRuinCities
johne
@tess Mini’s best selling model is an electric car with relatively short range. Another parent at my kiddo’s school loves his. https://www.motoringfile.com/2024/01/17/the-electric-mini-cooper-se-was-the-best-selling-mini-in-2023/
😀🚲
@tess The affordable, efficient, small #EV most people want is an #eBike and/or #cargoBikes which use 1/100th the amount of #lithium and other #carbon-intensive resources, costs less to own two #eBikes than one year of car expenses, don't have to give up your old gas car yet, no worries for #parking or grid-scale crisis about charging infrastructure. All we need are #transportation Engineers who don't fruitlessly waste every inch of city streets on cars, and some transit priority lanes instead.
R. Nicole
@mcc @tess I looked into them myself. The biggest issues:
R. Nicole
@solarpunkgnome This is in regard to the LSEV's sold in China. Even the Wuling cars which have a top speed of 60 mph are not comfortable above 30 - 40 mph as they become harder to steer and you feel every single bump on the road. This is according to my neighbors who are from Jiangsu Province. Apparently going above 30 mph, you end up fighting the cars' desire to go in a straight line. And with such small wheels, you feel every pothole, all the more so given the poorly padded seats.
R. Nicole
@solarpunkgnome This comment above was not concerning EV's available here in the US. It was specifically in response to the question posed about availability and use of LSEV's only sold in China. Personally, I ride my bike 90% of the year or walk. If I do use my vehicle it is for long drives to TN to visit family once or twice a year. Current miles driven the past 9 months... 1,892.4 miles. I have to crank it once a month and drive around the neighborhood just to keep life in the battery. 😂
0x575446
@appagalcrochet I have a car that I only drive for about half of the year. I picked up a PWM Solar Charge Controller and a 30W panel for under $100 and store it hooked up to that. Fires right up no matter how long I leave it.
Ben Ford :grinchsmile:
@appagalcrochet @mcc @tess you should read the toot that started this thread again 😝
Ben Ford :grinchsmile:
@appagalcrochet @mcc @tess because every point you made ignored the premise of the conversation.
R. Nicole
@binford2k I answered a specific post/question within the thread. If that bothers you, too bad. Backpfiefengesicht is a personal issue I cannot/will not assist you with, good day.
Dana Fried
@mym if you can afford a new car, then $30K isn't bad. We've bought two used PHEVs for well under $20K. And competition from China will be driving prices even lower in the next few years. Cars are just expensive right now 🤷🏻♀️ But saying that EVs have failed when all but a couple of companies are now only selling larger, more expensive EVs is silly. They all bet wrong.
Xandra Granade 🏳️⚧️
Kelsey Jordahl
@tess @mym EV sales haven't even slowed down! They just didn't grow as fast as predicted. Still a record sales year in the US in 2023:
Ben Ford :grinchsmile:
Pete Wright
@tess remembering when Elmo said he’d initially target rich people with teslas to help fund a more affordable version and that was just a lie since he decided he’d make more money turning it into a lifestyle brand 😅
josh buermann
Absolutely impossible to get a small anything, let alone a plugin-in hybrid that's good for getting around town off the plug but can still take you out of town without hour long pitstops at charging stations. "Let's hawk electric monster trucks to coal rollers" was apparently the plan? It's not like the administration is unaware that the NHTSA could bring the size of the fleet down by extending safety to include pedestrians, since they're taking a half-assed swing at it.
josh buermann
That's right. Any time there's been a model I want it might as well be vaporware for all the free market can deliver.
mike805
@buermann I downloaded and read the manual for the Prius Prime. It has all sorts of neat features including AC power onboard. Plus some creepy ones. The worst of which is the navigation and infotainment is all cloud based with a built in cellular modem you cannot turn off. And the navigation expires unless you pay for it.
josh buermann
I try to avoid using cars' consoles as much as possible since I find them even more distracting than my phone, so once I connect that to the car's bluetooth audio I basically never touch the console again. That still sounds a little too basic-car-as-service-that-will-soon-have-advertisements-even-though-you're-paying-to-use-the-thing-you-bought to me. I may never buy a car again, at the rate it's going.
ClickyMcTicker
@buermann @tess Superchargers give approximately 200 miles of range in 15 minutes. Do you never stretch your legs on long road trips? Range is a vastly overrated and overhyped feature for the majority of people. If you don’t spend your entire day in a car, and you have somewhere convenient to charge it, an EV is good for you. If you do spend your entire day in a car, get a gas vehicle. If you do it twice a year, rent a gas car and come out ahead anyways.
Dan W
@buermann people in sub-compact EVs still have to share the road with Dickheads in Dodge Rams. If everyone drove lightweight, low speed vehicles, (with less potential energy) collisions would be less spectacular and safety standards would be less onerous, which create a positive feedback loop of compact vehicles.
Jean-Baptiste "JBQ" Quéru
@jbaggs @tess I suspect it's a side effect of fuel economy targets, electrifying a small number of large vehicles makes it easier to hit average fuel economy targets than doing small cars. I used to drive a FIAT 500e, which I got for less than $10k used, it was very much awesome. My local dealer has a Dacia Spring in the showroom, it's oddly tempting.
naturaldynamics
@tess well, GM does make a sensible sized Bolt that is not a bad car, after a long drawn out battery problem that saw most bolts with new batteries installed under warranty!
Dana Fried
@natureshelperokanaganhighlands oh wow, I'm glad they un-canceled the Bolt! That was probably going to be my next car if my Volt ever died
George Liquor :verified:
@tess This this one thousand times this Not everyone wants to drive a goddamn tank around town !
ClickyMcTicker
@NoRomBasic @tess What a terrible truck. Try the Toyota Hilux Champ instead: Actually works as a truck, for a fifth of the price.
Jerry507
@tess I don't agree with there being that many "giant" SUVs. They're all compact SUVs which are the single most popular form factor today. Your core point about not having enough sedans does hold, but a lot of these companies sell exactly one EV and it's not surprising they picked the biggest market form factor.
Mastodon Migration
Also, it's nice to buy cars that are engineered well. Where the wheels don't fall off and that have a real dashboard instead of an iPad.
Peter Henry
@tess So true - my VW GTE eats tires. They insist timing chain $1k is replaced after 3 years and the Infotainment system sucks - App won't work on Android and 25% of the battery cells have died. Dynamic Chassis Control $1k extra is invisible - other than that I love it. Roll on cheapie from Chinese BYD that will glide of speed bumps without breaking my back and I will buy it.
Mark Heftler
@tess My Mach-E feels positively petite compared to most things on the road, it's wild.
Pseudonymous Bear
Something small enough to park while still having a little cargo space is what most people want EV or not. There's a reason why kei trucks have become so popular with farmers.
The House Of Sports Misery
@tess yes and there are other underlying factors as well. Take Texas where a new EV registration now runs you 400 bucks. Then it's 200 a year after that. A typical registration here is under 100 dollars per year.
Dana Fried
@RVLara23 that's not uncommon; because roads are typically maintained out of gas taxes and EVs do just as much damage to infrastructure as gas-powered vehicles. (I mean, Texas is probably doing it to be shitty, but WA does the same thing.)
The House Of Sports Misery
@tess Interesting - hadn't heard of it in other states although I guess I'm not surprised. At any rate - surely that added cost is also a factor. And without a doubt Texas is doing it to be shitty.
Alex White-Robinson
Alex White-Robinson
Deborah
@tess they need to look at what is happening in parts of Europe (where a number of smaller EV's are now on the market). https://www.connexionfrance.com/article/Practical/Transport/Here-is-the-list-of-electric-cars-eligible-for-aid-in-France-in-2024
CubeOfCheese
@tess that's why the chevy bolt is in such high demand. It's one of the few affordable-ish EVs that's not giant AND has a good range
Tofu Golem
@tess The infrastructure for gas automobiles didn't just appear of of nowhere. The auto industry pushed for laws, and the development of infrastructure happened over decades. And we know from countries that have higher adoption rates that we need more infrastructure. For example, those apartment landlords aren't going to put charging stations in their parking lots unless you pass laws that force them to.
Lee 🌏
@tess
Peter Butler
@tess It would be easy to incentivize smaller EVs by putting a size restriction on the $7,500 federal tax credit. There already are a buttload of restrictions There’s a MSRP limit of $55K for cars, but it goes up to $80K for SUVs and minivans :NekoSad: https://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/the-2024-ev-tax-credit-big-rebate-small-list/
Stay-At-Home Solarparent
@peterbutler @tess
Mike J👹🐀 🤘🏻
@tess Ford claims that they've learned and will be making smaller EVs. If they don't, BYD will.
nbaileydev
@tess I think VinFast is trying to revive the Geo Tracker/Suzuki Samurai in EV form for under $20k: https://arstechnica.com/cars/2024/01/this-tiny-ev-crossover-from-vinfast-will-go-on-sale-in-the-us/
Lucent Maven Katanova
@tess currently, chevy has all dealership on a Stop Sale order for EVs because of recent battery failures in new vehicles. EV sales are down partly because the dealers aren't allowed to sell them. edited: new-sale EVs are overkill for most people's needs. Adding another piece of the puzzle for information.
Grumble
@tess The goal of companies is not to supply what customers want or need - the goal is to make a profit. The goal of car executives is to make a killing on their stock options, which means making a profit in the way that Wall Street likes most. These days, Wall Street likes high profit margins. So... the current crop of car executives would rather make a great profit on expensive impractical trucks than make a tiny profit on cheap basic small cars.
sun_addict
@tess Where I live almost every model of EV has a wait list of one year, many gaz powered car have a wait list too and used car's prices have skyrocketed because of it.
~
@tess I talk the talk and drive the drive - saved ALOT.. still pricey a f in FL.. thanks to fash. foreign n domestic. /// you are not supposed to use your AC while pumping gas right? EV you can while charging oh yes.
Baloo Uriza
@tess And I'm in the market for a big fucking truck, but not the kind they're selling. Except I'm not looking for a city rig, I'm looking for a camper/rancher special: Doesn't matter how fast it gets there, it matters that it can stop and that it can carry a large volume of something heavy, like a slide-in camper, or a lot of camping gear. I'm outdoorsy and would go backpacking from a trailhead I got to in a chevy sprint. my husband is not. Truck bed camping is the compromise.
Baloo Uriza
Also not available yet, since the camper/rancher special is now the largest van that will fit in a full size (22'x7') parking space, is... the largest van that will fit in a full size parking space, but EV, which is weird since that'd a battery van would also be perfect for tradesmen who are mostly parked anyway, working out of the van, but also perfect for tour camping since it's not going to go offroad and is going to be used where RV or boat hookups are either available or real nearby...
Seasonal Stompy Robot
@tess
Permacultureandpolitics
@tess I live in the country and want an EV pickup, but I dont need a behemoth. Something the size of a Subaru Brat with AWD would be great.
Dr. Brad Rosenheim
@Permacultureandpolitics @tess Check out the Telo, which is only a concept right now. But I think it is the *right* concept.
Daniel Escasa
@tess True. However, I can rattle off a few right-sized EVs that didn't quite make it, or outright flopped. One of my favorites is (was?) the Evovelo (http://www.evovelo.com), which just announced the end of the project, and are looking for another group to take over. There's also the PEBL (https://www.better.bike/models), which are kinda steep. Dunno how they're doing. They're supposedly an upgrade over the ELF (https://https://organictransit.com/). We don't hear much of them in the mainstream press
the Amygdalai Lama
@tess
Eggler
@tess As someone who works in a hospital parking garage, I see so many people in big trucks worrying if they'll even be able to drive in. We have a 7 foot clearance and some people just can't get in. At that point, they either have to valet or hope they can find a spot in the parking lot. And most of these people are elderly, so far from ideal. Haven't seen any oversized EVs yet, just Tesla's, but compact cars just seem like the better idea in general.
mauimom
@tess Our farmers use their TeslaX for towing the trailer they use daily to pick up upcycled produce for the animals Not everyone is looking for or feels safe in a small EV
Greg Stolze
@tess
Zemri (They/Them) :v_agender:
@tess yes. Give me the equivalent of an ebike that will keep me warm in the winter, that's all I need for 99% of my driving.
Joanna Holman
@tess Absolutely. As someone who is not often driving much more than an hour a week, I feel torn. I support the idea of EVs but for what one costs the upgrade currently makes absolutely no financial sense for me.
M. Fioretti
@tess True. For a sketch of how those compact EVs may be and why, please see these thoughts of mine: https://mfioretti.substack.com/p/how-cars-are-dying-why-and-what-comes Feeback very welcome, of course.
MaybeMyMonkeys
@tess it is easier to add a ton of batteries to a big vehicle than a small vehicle. I am waiting for an EV in the size of a Honda Civic with a 60 mile range. It doesn’t have to circumnavigate the globe on one charge.
Pusher Of Pixels
@tess yep. my 'favorite' article was about the multitude of issues with a new EV a purchasing reviewer had. The "The brake system has lost connection with the radio" just boggles the mind in excess complexity absolutely not needed for a car. Closely followed by the driver's window switch having lost connection to the car network. EV Corollas, Fits n Civics will sell like hot cakes...yet they build $60K 'family' sedan/suvs instead.
The Janx Devil
@tess They’re making ones that aren’t luxury sedans and giant fucking trucks. They’re just not making them for the U.S. market. The rest of the world gets them, but we can’t buy them, not at any price, here because they’re not FMVSS certified.
Gene Cowan 🏳️🌈
@tess @lisamelton Was just looking at current EVs — the irony is that those big ones still don’t actually have the benefits of size, such as room for a big family or cargo space. 🤦🏻♂️
Larry H
@ tess
Ben S.
@tess THANK YOU! I keep shouting the same thing. I 100% resent the existence of Tesla at this point because their continued success/attention discourages other automakers from moving beyond the high-profit-margin luxury space. I do think making *regular-looking* EV trucks that can also power construction tools / camping gear would help adoption, but only because the US is obsessed with trucks overall.
Mikko Karvonen
@tess This. I’m very much in the market, but not interested in big cars. Renault Zoë, VW ID.3, and new Citroen e C3 are pretty much the only ones that feel relevant. And even from that list ID.3 is overdone and thus too pricey for my needs.
Simon W 🙄 🆙 ⚛️ 🇬🇧 🇺🇸
@tess r'amen! I'm so annoyed that VW decided the perfectly sized ID-3 is not sold in the US. I really don't need anything bigger, more expensive, and less efficient. Somehow the US car industry is convinced only big cars will sell here - but this is the same industry that in the early 2000s said electric cars would never sell here, took back all the EV1 cars and crushed them. |
Also, like, a lot of people who want EVs live in cities and denser environments where it's expensive to live and a pain in the ass to park and maybe your $100K electric monster truck doesn't fit with their lifestyle.
Stop trying to make EVs that appeal to the kind of people who would rather be rolling coal in a modified F450.