Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Sohan Murthy

Americans: please give us an affordable, practical, small EV with decent range

American car companies: here’s a $70,000 EV truck that weighs 6 tons lol

<zero EV trucks are sold>

American car companies: wow americans aren’t ready for EVs

106 comments
christa

@sohan give me tiny electric truck plz. via car share! I just want to haul some dirt or wood and not burn 50 gallons of gas and risk running over a child because I don’t see them

Sohan Murthy

@christa a cargo e-bike could fit the bill! Also, I occasionally daydream of bidding on one of these keitora and importing from japan. they're so cute! (and probably have more usable bed space than a Ford F-150 Supercrew)

christa

@sohan I also dream of this. I also wish there were easily rentable cargo e-bikes!

MO Sugerman

@sohan @christa I regularly see three vehicles that look very much parked in a town near me (Palouse, WA). There must be a US-based supplier.

Mastodon Migration

@christa @sohan

Exactly. A small E-truck is the perfect use case for an EV. It doesn't need huge range, because it doesn't need to go very far.

Badger AF (he/him)

@knowattitude @mastodonmigration @christa @sohan I've started following this channel on YouTube that talks about these. Hopefully, they'll be on more solid ground than Kanoo.

youtube.com/watch?v=96tM-_LF0m

timtilberg

@Badger_AF @knowattitude @mastodonmigration @christa @sohan

Cool vid. Interesting. I’ve been a huge fan of my 08 rav4, but it gave up the ghost last week. I was excited to get into a new rav4 hybrid. In general I’m happy enough, but it feels _massive_ in comparison to my 08. It feels like a proper truck, where my old vehicle felt more like a utility car. Just looking at the front end of it, and it’s a massive wall of metal. I could see the corners in my old car. Not this one, at all.

timtilberg

@Badger_AF @knowattitude @mastodonmigration @christa @sohan It’s all anecdotal though. I guess it has very similar dimensions, so the content in the video doesn’t apply. But the cut and feel is just so much different. Truck truck truck! Ew.

Colinaut

@knowattitude @mastodonmigration @christa @sohan I’d prefer they ditch the back seats and expand that truck bed as it’s too small to be useful for much.

Mastodon Migration

@colinaut @knowattitude @christa @sohan

Agreed. And lower the price tag. Much. Say $25,000. Small cab, good sized bed. About 4x8 so you could lay plywood flat, (or 4x6, but you could put the tailgate down). Powerful enough engine to tow a trailer, but not too much. Range could be < 150 miles. Maybe extra battery modules you could put in the bed.

Mycotropic

@colinaut @knowattitude @mastodonmigration @christa @sohan

I think the point is that it's modular, it's either a van or you remove the back one or two rows, open to the air, and it's a two seater truck. I think anyway!

Pusher Of Pixels

@knowattitude @mastodonmigration @christa @sohan

love the idea but base price of $49,999...not exactly small *and* affordable

that and a serious lack of front crumple zones that aren't your knees is seemingly problematic to getting road cert no?

Fluffy Kitty Cat

@mastodonmigration @christa @sohan also an electric motor is good for torque it it'll haul good

Giliell

@christa @sohan What is the American thing about trucks? Most people aren't in landscaping or something where they constantly need it. We have a small trailer that we use when we need to haul stuff and don't have to constantly drive it around empty.

Jim Vernon

@Giliell @christa @sohan I have a spot for a car, but I don't have a spot for a trailer. A small pickup, as a passenger car with a bed, makes sense.

Giliell

@jimvernon @christa @sohan I'm not buying it. Our trailer is quite small and you can actually store it upright so it needs less space than a couch table.

Jim Vernon

@christa @sohan Ford, make an electric Maverick. Thanks.

Eric Lawton

@christa

There's a lot of trucks in rural Canadian parking lots that have been jacked up an extra 30 cm, to make sure those kids' heads are right in the middle of the grille.

Maybe a very few are needed for specific jobs, but the rest are for "fun"; destroying the countryside on off-road trails.

@sohan

Mark Anderson

@sohan Living in rural Washington state, we need an EV truck that can haul a trailer and come in somewhere around $50K. We do not need whatever Tesla is trying to jam in our charging station.

Stefan

@sohan I agree so much. it's really depressing.

Conley Edwards

@sohan The Leaf has been out for almost 15 years now, basically what you're describing - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nissan_L

Eugene

@Conleyedwards @sohan the air cooled battery and terrible warranty was a mistake. But yes.

lorddimwit: not a typewriter

@evil1 @Conleyedwards @sohan

We looked at the Leaf. The steering felt super loose, it can only do one high-speed charge a day due to temperature concerns, and it used a charging plug that was rare in the US and becoming rarer. It’s a shame, because I would’ve enjoyed having it.

(I realize the “one high speed charge a day” thing is almost certainly enough, but the unusual plug was a legit problem.)

tuban_muzuru

@sohan

uh... we just got a brand new Chrysler Pacifica hybrid. We love it. All-electric isn't for us, but hybrid is. Hybrid EV will be where things are going for a decade I guess, until the charging infrastructure is in place.

deutrino

@tuban_muzuru I've heard there's a DIY / hacker kinda scene around the Chrysler Pacifica hybrid?? or maybe it was an EV model? @sohan

tuban_muzuru

@deutrino @sohan

This is our second Pacifica. The first one had issues with some predicate logic: if you turned it off somewhere the connectivity was dodgy, the entertainment/map system wouldn't reset - and we had to pull and reset the appropriate fuse to get it working again.

Chrysler's side worked great. Whoever engineered that entertainment interface should be beaten with a big stick.

The current Pacifica is a joy.

deutrino

@tuban_muzuru good to know! I'm highly interested in vehicles that contain a large battery and are big enough to chill out and work remotely in. wish I could remember the details but hearing there's an online DIY community around a vehicle like the Pacifica makes it interesting.

tuban_muzuru

@deutrino

We work remotely quite a bit - I go here and there, flying my drone and taking pictures - taking meetings, checking email. Bigbig luggage capacity.

The Pacifica has 12 USB ports and 120 volts at about 150 watts. We use our phone hotspots, though you can get it through the vehicle...

But for coding, I'd get a hotel room.

Mike Fraser :Jets: :flag:

@sohan Not entirely accurate. Chevy spent a lot of time, money, and research on electric vehicles, starting in rhe early 00s. The Chevy Volt was the result. An amazing piece of engineering and a step forward in electric drive trains. After the Volt, the Chevy Bolt ticked all the boxes of a small, affordable, long-range electric car. After massive investments, both cars had flat sales. The next logical step was a pivot to electric trucks and suvs. Chevy literally bet the co. on electrics.

Eugene

@mike @sohan and they managed to cancel both just as government subsidies were going to make them affordable. GM has always had amazing engineers and terrible management decisions.

Mike Fraser :Jets: :flag:

@evil1 @sohan Bolt was always pretty affordable and qualified for subsidies in Canada.

Tom Harrington

@mike @sohan dealers were charging over sticker price for Bolts because supply didn’t keep up with demand. Sales could have been higher if they made more.

caffeinatedgeek :Jets:

@atomicbird @mike @sohan the issue isn’t demand, it’s profit margin. Auto makers currently make more money selling ICE SUV and Trucks.

Jiub

@mike @sohan that's actually outdated information for the Bolt. it's been selling so well that GM decided to continue selling it instead of cancelling it.

goodcarbadcar.net/chevrolet-bo

in 2023 the Bolt EV and Bolt EUV actually sold more than any other EV in the US besides the Tesla Model 3/Y

electrek.co/2024/01/10/best-se

the conventional wisdom is that people want massive SUVs, but this shows that there's a market for small, cheap, simple EVs.

@mike @sohan that's actually outdated information for the Bolt. it's been selling so well that GM decided to continue selling it instead of cancelling it.

goodcarbadcar.net/chevrolet-bo

in 2023 the Bolt EV and Bolt EUV actually sold more than any other EV in the US besides the Tesla Model 3/Y

Mark Shane Hayden

@sohan

Car companies:

We tried making them reach 100km/h in 2 seconds...

We tried making them use complex mobile apps to do things like open their doors and recharge...

We gave them Advanced Telemetry that collects GIGABYTES of their usage data every month so that we can teach Auto Pilot to drive badly on their behalf and also Optimize their Marketing Experience...

We tried adding quirky features such as light shows when they turn on, replacing the entire dashboard of controls with a giant touchscreen tablet, ice boxes in the frunk, 240V power plugs so they can use their welders on the go and even a Virtual Whoopie Cushion...

...and we even tried to make a giant steel pyramid on wheels...what a statement!

We gave them all of that value for a mere $99,999! How could anyone refuse!?

Clearly society is not ready to accept EVs yet.

@sohan

Car companies:

We tried making them reach 100km/h in 2 seconds...

We tried making them use complex mobile apps to do things like open their doors and recharge...

We gave them Advanced Telemetry that collects GIGABYTES of their usage data every month so that we can teach Auto Pilot to drive badly on their behalf and also Optimize their Marketing Experience...

Robin Capper

@msh @sohan all that and some can't put a speedometer in the driver's direct line of sight...

Magister Endomain

@sohan "Sorry, the Chevy Bolt actually outsold the Tesla Model 3 but... It's an outdated (read: not truck) design that Americans just don't like, so we're discontinuing the model."

generationX

@sohan replace American with German and it is true as well. They only sell EV with all features no barebone car. Do you need a electric window lift or electrically hight adjustment for a seat? Cars could be more affordable and reliable without all that electric failure prone stuff. And better for environment as well...

DELETED

@sohan Clever Americans: Please give us walk friendly communities and affordable mass transit....

OddOpinions5

@sohan
maybe these don't fit your definition of "affordable" or "practical" but they are certainly much cheaper, smaller ev

and they are not selling

seems to contradict your thesis ?

George Liquor :verified:

@sohan I am so goddamn sick of the car companies trying to force suburban goddamn tanks on us !

Give me a new iQ that's all electric and I'm golden !

Ken Kinder :clubtwit:

@sohan Mustang Mach E — small EV, great car, and selling well AFAIK.

SofaFernsehFan

@sohan
EV started with something like this in the 1990s.

I don't understand why they started to electrify cars later on.

John Wells

@sohan For real! If Honda started selling an electric version of the Fit/Jazz in the US I’d have a reservation put in immediately if not sooner.

I want something that can fit in my garage with plenty of room to spare and that list is depressingly short and composed mostly of discontinued models.

ROTOPE~1 :yell:

@johnwells @sohan right now I'd settle for a gas Fit. It's really cool that they killed that line.

Darwin Woodka

@sohan BUT YOU WANT THIS HUGE ASS SUV DON'T YOU

Frances Larina

@sohan

Yes but also can we maybe put pressure on Democrats to repeal the Obama Administration's mpg rules that rewarded American carmakers for only selling larger and larger vehicles, mostly "trucks" (the definition was greatly loosened) for the last decade and a half?

Two Teks in a trench coat

@Frances_Larina @sohan Better, include those ludicrous land yachts in the MPG rules.

Walt :ani_clubtwit:🚀

@sohan

Basically I want a low cost simple (computer screen free) EV with no automatic computer controlled features.

A simple cheap car with NO software to constantly update.

My only option right now is to build my own out of an old car.

🤖

Scott Hall

@sohan yes this! Leased a Fiat 500e for a few years. Total cost of ownership was less than the gas alone I was putting in my previous vehicle.

Phil Landmeier

@sohan Don't worry. The Chinese will fill that need before long and US automakers will miss the boat again. The Arizona desert will be filled with unsold 6 ton SUVs.

DaveOfTheNui

@mmalc @sohan That Aptera, has been in the pipeline for bloody years!
It's just vaporware at this point sadly.

Borja Delgado

@sohan It works more or less the same for the rest of the world. I think in Europe there is only one EV under €25k (Chinese BTW)

Sk@tterBr@iNz

@sohan if only there was a billionaire EV evangelist with manufacturing capacity who could focus on business and stay away from social media. If only.

Patty Kimura

@sohan We are an impatient people. Toyota opened its first dealership in the the US in 1950. The Crown had technical issues. By the 1980s Toyotas were growing in market share as a smaller, more efficient affordable car, derisively and racistly called "rice burners", still, back then. My dad saw an emerging counterintuitive market for Toyotas in the 1950s when traveling in SoCal he saw that first Toyota, when big V8 cars were the standard. He inked a deal with Toyota in 1958 as the exclusive importer to Hawai'i and areas of SoCal and the Pacific. He died in 1980. Today that company is the 30th largest auto dealer in the US and largest Toyota dealer in Australia. It's way too early to write off EVs.

@sohan We are an impatient people. Toyota opened its first dealership in the the US in 1950. The Crown had technical issues. By the 1980s Toyotas were growing in market share as a smaller, more efficient affordable car, derisively and racistly called "rice burners", still, back then. My dad saw an emerging counterintuitive market for Toyotas in the 1950s when traveling in SoCal he saw that first Toyota, when big V8 cars were the standard. He inked a deal with Toyota in 1958 as the exclusive importer...

ℍ𝕠𝕨

@sohan I dream with a vehicle like this: aptera.us/ super efficient, or that's what they promise. I live pretty far from shops and I need to use a vehicle to get down to the town to get food, a vehicle like that would fit perfectly my needs.

Sohan Murthy

@H0W25 same 😍

I put down a reservation for one, mostly out of hope that it sees the light of day

Giles Edwards

@sohan While we're declaring our vehicular desires, I would be interested in an EV which was not "smart".

Battery, motor, and just the ('90s-era) typical doo-dads, if you please.

Peter Brett

@gilesforyou @sohan Yes, this is exactly what I want out of a car. As few electronics as possible.

The simplicity of the electric drive system (we had electric cars before gasoline cars!) provides an opportunity to build cars that are incredibly simple to repair and maintain, and will last basically forever.

DaveOfTheNui

@krans @gilesforyou @sohan
Same, the last thing I want in any vehicle is touch screens and "infotainment" unit's that need data collection policies.

Jarf

@sohan I got a bolt ev this February with the tax credit. It was about 20k given all the incentives. Sadly they are discontinuing it. It’s perfect for my use case

Badger AF (he/him)

@sohan We sell so many of these behemoths because 1) Americans are brainwashed into thinking bigger = safer, 2) gas is pretty damn cheap in America vs. other countries (due to our low taxes) so there's little incentive to drive smarter, 3) Americans also are brainwashed into thinking it's their god-given right to drive ginormous beasts, 4) margins are incredibly much higher for trucks and SUVs.

Car manufacturers are creating and feeding the market of dumb Americans.

Erik Ableson

@sohan @lisamelton Meanwhile Mini, Fiat, Renault, Dacia et al. are selling like crazy here in the EU 🤔

Hot Dog Water

@sohan

EVs are most definitely not ready for people.

The reality of EVs is just stupid. Right now. To me.

Magically, I can still be for them and hope to see something in my squirt of life left other than 6000 separate batteries to consider.

Klaudia (aka jinxx)

@sohan European car companies also went for bigger and bigger cars, ignoring the smaller roads, narrower city streets and smaller parking garages here. It's ridiculous, seeing cars that take up one and a half parking spaces. 🤦‍♀️ All I want is a normal size EV with with a long range.

Doug Bostrom

@GreenFire @sohan

The Bolt is exemplary of this problem.

"They want large cars."

"They're buying our small car."

"Cancel the small car."

Market imaginary giant EVPU.

Kevin Leecaster

@Doug_Bostrom @sohan
Yeah, but thankfully there are enough Americans willing to go with what we have available such that EVs made up almost 10% of all new small vehicle purchases in 2023. I think that will help convince manufacturers to start putting out new models for the laggards still driving fossil fueled vehicles hopefully.

Doug Bostrom

@GreenFire @sohan

Fingers crossed! GM did reverse the Bolt decision due to backlash, it's true.

There will be a gap in Bolts and the next one is slated to be larger but progress in fits in and starts. :-)

Kevin Leecaster

@Doug_Bostrom @sohan
Since Biden's electric vehicle charging station network is just starting to get built out, it might work out better that quite a few Americans have put off switching to EVs so that they didn't get buyers remorse so easily.

whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/b

Taco

@sohan I mean… maybe having a fringe right securities fraudster as a frontman for the industry wasn’t a good idea after all…

ROTOPE~1 :yell:

@sohan American car companies: okay we heard your demands, and made the frunk 20% taller. You can now fit an entire Nissan Cube in there. You can't see the road out of the windscreen at all, so driving it feels like you're 𝑓𝑙𝑦𝑖𝑛𝑔. Sticker price now starts at $76,000.

Can-crisociality 🦀〰️🥫

@sohan Unfortunately in Southern California I am seeing more than a few 6-ton electric trucks (Rivians). The worst of all possible worlds

Orion (he/him)

@sohan You know what's really great? Mass transit.

I know. I'm off-topic. But still.

Mike Harrison

@sohan My work truck is a Tacoma long bed (smallest I could buy in 2016). At the hardware store yesterday I lusted after the little tiny imported old Suzuki wrong size drive that parked next to me. No amenities. A bigger more useful bed than my truck. 4WD.. perfect for runs to hardware stores and projects. I'd sell my Tacoma for a new electric one that size an a 100 mile range. Considered building one. Pic is similar, not same truck.

Mastodon Migration

@meuon @sohan

Perfect! An EV that size would be just right.

Edit: Even looks like the bed might tip.

Mike Harrison

@mastodonmigration @sohan Some tip, some don't. Lots of variation. Trucks designed to get work done, not represent emotional issues. ;)

Que

@sohan don’t forget how dealers were playing games and adding 10s of thousands of markups to them. FAFO.

Andrew Henry

@sohan The trend to bigger and more expensive vehicles is driven by profit.

`
But thanks to its efficiency drive, the company says it now requires only 300,000 sales to break even; and by focusing on its most profitable models — Range Rover, Ranger Rover Sport and Defender comprise around three-quarters of its order book — it has been able to raise average sales prices by around half since 2019 to more than £70,000.

'
bloomberg.com/opinion/articles

@sohan The trend to bigger and more expensive vehicles is driven by profit.

`
But thanks to its efficiency drive, the company says it now requires only 300,000 sales to break even; and by focusing on its most profitable models — Range Rover, Ranger Rover Sport and Defender comprise around three-quarters of its order book — it has been able to raise average sales prices by around half since 2019 to more than £70,000.

Mathaetaes

@sohan wait - didn’t the F150 lightning sell out completely like halfway through last year?

A friend of mine was trying to buy one and he said there was like a 6-mo backlog.

But yeah - those rivian trucks are godawful looking and also probably just as dangerous as a Tesla. The cyber truck is, well, lol.

Jim Vernon

@sohan $70,000, lol. I saw a bunch of F150 Lightnings just sitting on a Ford lot with window stickers that said $95,000.

Andy

@sohan why are trucks/SUVs such a thing in America? I don't get it.

Sohan Murthy

@vespasianvs In the 90s, Ford and other companies found out they could market more profitable SUVs as family vehicles while classifying them as light trucks, which were curiously exempt from the emissions regulations of the time. Decades of marketing followed, convincing generations of American consumers that they were safer and more practical than cars or vans. Ford no longer sells any cars in the US market.

Andy

@sohan thing I find funny is a modern Ford RAV4 only scores a bit better in safety that my 2012 Mazda 2 (though obviously the rating for the Mazda 2 is a bit dated now).

Mx Amber Alex

@sohan LITERALLY THO. In Germany, Volkswagen only sends SUVs to dealerships, and since people tend to buy what's on site instead of waiting for ages for a delivery from the factory, they buy SUVs, and then Volkswagen says "see, people want SUVs!"

They also stopped producing the eUp! when it got too popular.

🌚JR🌝

@sohan I just bought a Chevy Bolt and I had to practically beg them to sell me one. (It’s a great vehicle BTW)

deutrino

@sohan really hoping to pick up one of those trucks for a song someday as a result of this

Bennolius 😷💉⁴ | ☀️💨🔋| あ-Я

@sohan I can't imagine why BYD has overtaken Tesla worldwide 🤔

Maybe they'll come to the USA soon, or a similar Chinese brand will. Imagine something like the seagull.
youtu.be/P73KmleCuBg

SouprMatt

@sohan Bought a VW e-golf in 2016, still going strong. Mini cooper EV, Nissan Leaf… wish there were more like them instead of the overpriced “luxury SUV” nonsense.

Go Up