Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
★ Amy Star ★ :verified:​

youtube, what the actual fuck does this even MEAN???

???????????????

[A modal window presented by the YouTube iOS app.]

Craving something new?

[Three choices are displayed: a red blob, a blue blob, and a green blob, all non-descript and amorphous.]

Create a feed of YouTube videos based off of color, and enjoy exploring!

Let's Go [Button]
79 comments
shift-jis art depicting a dog

@AmyZenunim do you want a red youtube? a redtube so to speak?

★ Amy Star ★ :verified:​

I want to find the Product Manager who approved this modal and violently shake them in Minecraft

ln, again sleepy

@AmyZenunim someone had to release a feature to get promoted and it shows

Kay Ohtie, Bat-Yote!

@ln @AmyZenunim after reading about this being why so little at Google gets fixed I kind of just gave up on modern software ever being good ever again

★ Amy Star ★ :verified:​

I... what???????

???????????????????????????????????

YouTube now lets you sort your home page by color, so only videos predominately featuring the chosen hue will appear. The company doesn't offer you a color wheel to choose from, either. Instead, we get three colors: red, green, and blue. They aren't promoting the feature much, either.

Sep 8, 2023
Job Bautista

@AmyZenunim This sounds like an April Fools joke that got out either too late or too early

shift-jis art depicting a dog

@AmyZenunim oh thats not at all what i thought that feature did and so much worse than anything i could have imagined

TSource Engine Query
@AmyZenunim never in my life I had an urge to do "red" only things today.

Who is this for? Lizards?
★ Amy Star ★ :verified:​

the implication is that if I select Red, I will no longer see any outdoors/camping youtubers, because there's too much Green in their videos?

do creators have access to these metrics? what if one colour dominates all the others?? does that mean that suddenly all of youtube will be shifted over to that colour to stay competitive? will all videos suddenly become bright blood red???

who fucking wants this?? who does this serve??? and why would you not explain the implications to your users in any kind of informed way????

the implication is that if I select Red, I will no longer see any outdoors/camping youtubers, because there's too much Green in their videos?

do creators have access to these metrics? what if one colour dominates all the others?? does that mean that suddenly all of youtube will be shifted over to that colour to stay competitive? will all videos suddenly become bright blood red???

Owlor

@AmyZenunim I have no idea if this is what happened, but this very much feel like a "helpful" suggestion from some executive fungus that can't tell his own head from his arse but because he's in charge, they have to do what he says so he can feel like he contributed something.

cybik :deifirev:

@AmyZenunim for the record:
lifehacker.com/youtube-lets-yo

not that it gives any reasoning as to why this is even a bloody thing. This is weird and stupid and I'm assuming something far more banally evil is afoot here and I hate it already.

Renée

@AmyZenunim remember when all movies from like 2000-2010 were orange and teal? This thing doesn't even support secondary colours soooo

lol

Claire-hime

@AmyZenunim I actually kind of like this because it is such a completely nonsensical feature

it's better than finding a new way to harvest our data anyway

Nikelui

@AmyZenunim@unstable.systems the only plausible explanation is that project managers at Google get bonuses based on "innovation". That's why they introduce all this useless crap and constantly break products that are perfectly functional (I'm looking at you, Google Maps).

Miicat_47

@AmyZenunim

That’s interesting, but prob not usable :blobcatthinkowo:

Local Catte

@AmyZenunim users: stop making drastic changes to the UI
creators: please support us, the people actually making your platform worth a look
YouTube: likes are now florps, you can sort your homepage by color, wow!

Maddy

@AmyZenunim idk what y'all are complaining about, i'm sick and tired of seeing blue on the TL. cursed. bad vibes.

now, green, that... that is the color of dreams, of life itself. i don't want to see anything more than 50nm from the sacred wavelength or else i will fly into a rage and email YouTube 100 times

Roger BW 😷

@AmyZenunim For the sort of person who chooses the contents of their bookshelves to match the colour of the room?

bapt :smug:

@AmyZenunim I mean, some features are a bit niche… but I cannot for the life of me figure out why anyone would ever want this

moh

@AmyZenunim maybe this is YouTube's first step into creating a feeling for the consumer that they are an "artist" for simply curating the content they see. Spotify, for example, leans really heavily into that. filtering by color is an arbitrary restriction that feels artistic in a way.

cybik :deifirev:

@AmyZenunim what in the name of the absolute and utter *FUCK* is this junk

Dr.Nick

@AmyZenunim He is too busy writing his promo packet as part of perf.

Once he gets the level up, 6 months later it will disappear

Internet Hedgehog

@AmyZenunim social media websites will do anything besides a chronological timeline

Karen

@AmyZenunim This is, without a doubt, the most nonsensical feature I've ever heard of.

Talen Lee

@karen @AmyZenunim I wonder if this is 'I want to stop seeing pale purple lights and therefore, poor youtubers, women, and people of colour'

Stu

@Talen_Lee @karen @AmyZenunim i'm 90% sure that the choice of red, green and blue with no other colors is just because it's very easy to code when you're in an RGB color space - this is a weekend project that becomes nontrivial as soon as you want purple

Ian Campbell

@AmyZenunim it's always telling to me when i look at something and my synesthesia does _nothing_ despite obvious openings.

DELETED

@AmyZenunim meanwhile filtering my sub feed by things like video length is still not a thing *>_>

I am Jack's Lost 404

@AmyZenunim

🤣 what the fuck?

Probably because it's super easy to implmement and :blobshrug:​ :catgooglyfingerguns:​ :blobcatgooglyshrug:​

Probably going after the trend of organizing your bookshelf by color for instagram likes... but like... how the fuck do you actually find the books then?

Who am I kidding, influencers don't read...

may

@AmyZenunim me when colourblind and doesn't care about more than half.

Steven Johnson

@AmyZenunim it means someone is realllllly scraping the bottom of the barrel for ideas that will get them promoted

Fluffviech ™️😺

@AmyZenunim the LSD fucks rather hard today... or something like that....

Atkelar

@AmyZenunim could that be one of these new "are you human" things? Or is the "content suggestion AI" drifting into sleep? Who knows... 😁

Steve Dinn

@AmyZenunim It means that you can now use YouTube as a glorified lava lamp... with ads.

Gen X-Wing

@AmyZenunim Sounds better than “do you want a bunch of hateful pricks invading your random viewing of videos”, which is what they have now.

This just sounds goofy and fun to be honest.

Garrett Latimer

@AmyZenunim Well, my stuff probably plays well for Bouba Youtube but making Kiki Youtube content would result in *thousands of dollars* worth of damage.

alas, she

@AmyZenunim Create a feed of YouTube videos based off color, and enjoy screaming!

Fanny Matrice

@AmyZenunim is that one of those premium only, experimental features ?

Biggie the Wonder Mage

@AmyZenunim me when I see a painting with more than one color:

Yummers!

Googly Eyed Peas

@AmyZenunim this must be why you have to undergo 200 interviews and answer quantum physics questions on whiteboards infront of 12 Nobel winners before you can intern at Google.

2WaterGuns

@AmyZenunim Wasn't this the first joke used in the dystopian society section of Wall-E?

Kassil

@AmyZenunim This is absolutely someone with investment control demanding Features Be Added for Number Go Up.

Marlinspike

@AmyZenunim I'm incredibly late to the party on this post, but after reading the responses I have a question. Why are so many people seemingly angry over this "feature?" On its face it does in fact seem useless, but still. Maybe some teams were having some fun, or it's a small piece from a more complex recognition engine? Who knows. There are many reason to be critical of, or even angry at Google, but for this?

★ Amy Star ★ :verified:​

@marlinspike it's because Google has absolutely lost all good faith when it comes to "fun" features like this. I have seen brilliant creators become severely hampered in their ability to do their work because of opaque, esoteric, undocumented changes to the "algo" that make it very difficult for people to find their videos.

this feels like just another arbitrary filter to add onto the mountain of arbitrary filters that can potentially have your videos hidden by the recommendation engine, all because you didn't use one of the three primary colours as the lighting in your video.

@marlinspike it's because Google has absolutely lost all good faith when it comes to "fun" features like this. I have seen brilliant creators become severely hampered in their ability to do their work because of opaque, esoteric, undocumented changes to the "algo" that make it very difficult for people to find their videos.

Marlinspike

@AmyZenunim That's an interesting point. I agree that Google is 100% untrustworthy, and as I mentioned, I too think the filters may be part of a larger project. However, many of the responses seem angry over the "stupidity" of the filters and nothing else.

Meowki

@AmyZenunim looks line they are testing your #anthroposophy aptitute. 😂

Sylvain Miermont

@AmyZenunim It means "Hi, we're A-B-testing new ways to hijack your brain for monetization purpose, please cooperate. Resistance is futile." 🤖

jvyden

@AmyZenunim i love red content but green content is kinda mid

Raptor :jewish_pride_flag:

@AmyZenunim trying to mess with content creators through forcing them to add more RGB hues to their stuff for the sake of The Algorithm?

Go Up