Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Brian Smith

@batalanto @simon @adam

I pay my bills through my bank's website or phone app.

Remote P2P can be done through the bank app or paypal or a number of other apps.

26 comments
Contradiction Finder

@BrianSmith950
We can scrap the Paypal option. It’s shit.

The “by app” options are not really by software, but rather an underlying transfer mechanism. Americans login to their bank accounts to pay their bills, but that’s just a façade for how the money moves. The user often does not even know. Typically an outsourced #billpay service checks whether a payee such as a credit card is linked electronically, then the money moves electronically by ACH. If not, a check is printed and mailed & that’s entirely invisible to the payer. The free bill pay service covers the cost of the stamp. Of course there’s a bit of dodgyness there because how does the billpay service pay their bills if they’re free to you and your bank? They must be snooping & selling your data to data brokers. So sending a paper check yourself manually is the only counter to that.

The UK has the GDPR, so perhaps you have some protection against those shenanigans.
@simon @adam

@BrianSmith950
We can scrap the Paypal option. It’s shit.

The “by app” options are not really by software, but rather an underlying transfer mechanism. Americans login to their bank accounts to pay their bills, but that’s just a façade for how the money moves. The user often does not even know. Typically an outsourced #billpay service checks whether a payee such as a credit card is linked electronically, then the money moves electronically by ACH. If not, a check is printed and mailed & that’s entirely...

Brian Smith

@batalanto @simon @adam
Not being familiar with US banking,

We tend to get a debit card directly from the bank, which can be used to draw cash from the bank ATM's (Any bank, a lot of big shops also provide them for free but smaller operators charge you to draw money. they are all linked) and can be used for purchases, the money comes straight out of your current account.
A lot of people also have a credit card, may be issued by your bank, or you can sign up with another supplier.

Simon Poole replied to Brian

@BrianSmith950 @batalanto @adam while this is all a bit OT: cheques haven't been a thing in most of western Europe for at least half a century. Essentially they died out as soon as salaries started getting paid by bank transfers/wires. I've never actually wrote out a personal cheque (and I've maybe cashed perhaps max a dozen or so, probable not even that many).

zbrando replied to Brian

@BrianSmith950 @batalanto @simon @adam Same situation in EU. For the checks, I haven't seen one in 25 years. Northern countries are almost all digital.

matzipan

@batalanto @BrianSmith950 @simon @adam just because you think it's shit doesn't mean it is. Lots of people use it and find it practical.

Most banks in Europe that I know have almost instant if not instant bank transfers. Why would I bother with checks 😂

Contradiction Finder replied to matzipan

@matzipan Not sure you read the whole thread. Anyone who is well informed & does not consider #paypal shit is likely a piece of shit themselves. By “informed”, I mean being aware of these damning facts:

git.disroot.org/cyberMonk/libe

Most people are either uninformed, or unwilling to let ethics get in their way. OSM needs to become informed about Paypal.

@BrianSmith950 @simon @adam

Simon Poole replied to Contradiction

@batalanto @matzipan @BrianSmith950 @adam the point is without paypal the OSMF would be without a payment processor, nobody has any illusions about the company as such, using them is simply a practicality.

Adam replied to Simon

@simon @batalanto @matzipan @BrianSmith950

This is false. If it weren't for PayPal, OSMF would still be able to have payments processed via their bank or bitcoin.

Here's a link to the documentation showing this: wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Do

Simon Poole replied to Adam

@adam @batalanto @matzipan @BrianSmith950 there are things like credit cards that many many people prefer to use for such payments, and not supporting that would immediately eliminate a large number of potential donors.

Contradiction Finder replied to Simon

@simon
I’m willing to pay for things by credit card iff:

* cash & crypto are not options
* the payment processor is not Paypal

I ate in a restaurant recently & in a rare circumstance cash was not an option for me. So I paid by card. Then the receipt mentioned some #Paypal subsidiary. I was so disgusted to find that paypal snagged my payment details & benefited from something I did despite being offline in a brick&mortar shop. I was tricked into going against my #boycott.

Anyway, whenever I’m paying online by credit card, I always check to see if they also accept Paypal, which then triggers me to do some deeper checks on whether my visa/mc/amex payment will traverse Paypal systems. If yes, I walk.

@adam @matzipan @BrianSmith950

@simon
I’m willing to pay for things by credit card iff:

* cash & crypto are not options
* the payment processor is not Paypal

I ate in a restaurant recently & in a rare circumstance cash was not an option for me. So I paid by card. Then the receipt mentioned some #Paypal subsidiary. I was so disgusted to find that paypal snagged my payment details & benefited from something I did despite being offline in a brick&mortar shop. I was tricked into going against my #boycott.

matzipan replied to Contradiction

@batalanto @simon @adam @BrianSmith950 it has its advantages. I prefer paying by paypal instead of card because at least my card details can't be stolen. Happened to me before and it was very inconvenient. That I have to put up with privacy invasion because of this just shows that we don't have any strong European competitors to paypal 😓

Simon Poole replied to Matija

@mnalis @batalanto @adam @matzipan @BrianSmith950 while the initial version of the support.. page had a link to the payment options it was very easy to miss.

Contradiction Finder replied to Simon

@simon @BrianSmith950 @matzipan @adam @mnalis Indeed when I made that comment it was before the donations page evolved. The cryptocurrency option was not mentioned on either of the two donation pages at that moment. It was added later.

Contradiction Finder replied to Contradiction

@matzipan I used Paypal before they locked my account & kept the money -- before I became broadly aware of Paypal’s wrongdoing.

w.r.t checks, what do you do in Europe if you want to pay someone who does not have a bank account? A check covers that situation. Cash is better, but because of the #warOnCash Belgium, France, & Spain have outlawed cash transactions above a certain amount.

@BrianSmith950 @simon @adam

Contradiction Finder replied to Contradiction

@matzipan
Homes in Europe are still bought with checks. E.g. in Belgium upon closing on a house, the buyer must appear at the notaire with proof of down payment. A screenshot of a transfer is not accepted. So a banker’s check is often used.

I agree checks are rare in Europe but there are a number of factors that drive people to be unbanked which makes checks more important.
@BrianSmith950 @simon @adam

Contradiction Finder replied to Contradiction

@matzipan
In recent years, some EU banks have closed their over-the-counter service and also shutdown their website. If you want to send money, you must buy a smartphone, register an acct with google or apple, obtain the bank’s closed-source app from Google or Apple & be willing to run the app. And you must repeat that cycle when the bank’s chronic upgrades force you to buy a new phone. I would prefer checks over that.
@BrianSmith950 @simon @adam

matzipan replied to Contradiction

@batalanto @BrianSmith950 @simon @adam that is a good point and I would see both paypal locking people out and banks not supporting web or non-googlefied smartphones as topics for another digital banking reform in the EU.

matzipan replied to Contradiction

@batalanto @BrianSmith950 @simon @adam I just don't. This problem does not for me for sums that cannot be managed by some cash.

Contradiction Finder replied to matzipan

@matzipan
Consider how utilities are paid in Europe. You pay an estimated amount monthly. After a year, the supplier calculates your exact figures and refunds you the amount you overpaid. If you have no bank account, you’re fucked because the energy supplier will not pay you cash and they will not send a check.

BTW, checks still exist in western Europe; France more so than others. Outside of France you have to pick the right bank & apply some pressure to get a checkbook.
@BrianSmith950 @simon @adam

@matzipan
Consider how utilities are paid in Europe. You pay an estimated amount monthly. After a year, the supplier calculates your exact figures and refunds you the amount you overpaid. If you have no bank account, you’re fucked because the energy supplier will not pay you cash and they will not send a check.

matzipan replied to Contradiction

@batalanto @BrianSmith950 @simon @adam I think qualifying so many people (including myself) as pieces of shit is probably not nice thing to do and maybe you need to reconsider your approach.

Sarah Dal

@batalanto @BrianSmith950 @simon @adam the transfer system in the UK is either BACS or FPS, the banks themselves pay for each transaction as a cost of business. I doubt there's any sale of personal details going on as we do have data protection laws.

Contradiction Finder replied to Sarah

@sarahdalgulls
Good to hear UK→UK transactions are fee-free.
Non-UK→UK will get you burnt. I opened an account in the UK & had to fund it. The brokerage said in their ToS that they charge no fees for transfers. So I sent money to fund my own account. Less money arrived than what I sent. My bank denied taking a fee & the broker denied taking a fee. It turned out that an intermediary working for the broker took a fee.
@BrianSmith950 @simon @adam

Contradiction Finder replied to Contradiction

@sarahdalgulls
I was upset about it because I did diligent research before sending the money. Even after I got burnt, nothing in either of my contracts with my bank or brokerage disclosed the fee that was taken. When I tracked down who the intermediary was (who i did not have a contract with), I asked them for a written statement of the fee and how much they take. They said that’s private- between us & the broker.
@BrianSmith950 @simon @adam

Sarah Dal replied to Contradiction

@batalanto that really sucks. I've never had a problem transferring internationally within europe, but there's always fees and shocking exchange rates; with the US banking system being very different to ours I imagine there's tonnes of ways for people to make a quick buck out of it

Go Up