Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Chris Trottier

With Meta entering the Fediverse, we really got to start supporting Meta alternatives that already exist on the Fediverse.

I'm talking about services like Friendica, Streams, @pixelfed, and @matrix.

So please reach out to Fediverse devs such as @dansup and @mike, and ask them how you can help.

@fediversenews

27 comments
Viss

@atomicpoet @pixelfed @matrix @dansup @mike @fediversenews my first reaction to hearing about facebook trying to join the fediverse was "hahaha nobody will federate with them", then i saw droves of folks essentially saying the same thing - so it'll be really interesting to see what happens, because the mammoth trojan horse they're wheeling up to the door sure has a lot of kind words hamfistedly slopped on the side, but you can plainly see cambrige analytica inside through the slats.

Viss

@atomicpoet when i said 'mammoth', i didnt mean 'the app', i was describing the size of this illustrative trojan horse.

admin

@Viss @atomicpoet @pixelfed @matrix @dansup @mike @fediversenews

What would be the point, anyway?

Without corporate-favourable algorithms to market/control people's online feeds.

Chris Trottier

@zhuk Meta can build relevancy algorithms for their own Fediverse services. Nothing stops them.

DELETED

@atomicpoet @zhuk This is the real threat that we need to fight. Every software has its algorithms, but in the fediverse we must not accept servers that abusively manipulate the feeds of their users.

If the relevance algorithm is kept secret – or even somehow patented – ban the software!

Shoq

@atomicpoet In a nutshell, what is the rational for Streams? Is it addressing something missing in AP?

Chris Trottier

@shoq It uses what's termed the Nomad protocol which is, @mike describes it, essentially zot/11. This includes ActivityPub built in, but is an evolution of Hubzilla as well. It's very feature rich in a macroblogging sense, though I think someone could probably add some UI/UX magic to it.

Shoq

@atomicpoet
So, what's the vision? This extends AP while remaining masto compatible? Do these features play nicely with existing masto now?

Chris Trottier

@shoq It's complicated. For example, Streams has comment control. Mastodon doesn't. Streams also has nomadic identity while Mastodon doesn't.

Personally, I see Streams as being very cutting edge in terms of features.

I'm sure you've talked to @mike before. He's the one with the vision.

Shoq

@atomicpoet @mike No, I have not had the pleasure, but I'd like to understand this better. I will do some homework and reach out.

Shoq

@atomicpoet @mike

Can the two happily coexist, or would one ultimately threaten to, or actually displace the other?

Chris Trottier

@shoq @mike I think Streams and Mastodon touch upon different needs. Mastodon is a microblogging platform whereas Streams is for macroblogging.

One is minimal while the other is maximal.

If I want a calendar or a fancy gallery, Streams is better for that use case.

In this sense, Streams is more like Facebook than Twitter.

So coexistence can definitely happen.

Jupiter Rowland
@Chris Trottier @Shoq @Fediverse News Vanilla #Streams, if installed straight from the code repository and used as-is, is more like Facebook than Twitter.

But that wasn't @mike's intention when he created (streams). Unlike Friendica, Hubzilla and all the following projects, and unlike Mastodon & Co., he did not intend (streams) to be a use-as-is #Fediverse platform. And (streams) isn't one.

Unlike Mastodon, Friendica, Hubzilla etc., (streams) is not a final product. It is a code repository.

The intention behind (streams) is to take the code, fork it and build something nice with it. You can run it as-is. It is being run as-is, see Rumbly. But Mike didn't make it for this.

Friendica is more like Facebook. (streams) is more like LEGO.
@Chris Trottier @Shoq @Fediverse News Vanilla #Streams, if installed straight from the code repository and used as-is, is more like Facebook than Twitter.

But that wasn't @mike's intention when he created (streams). Unlike Friendica, Hubzilla and all the following projects, and unlike Mastodon & Co., he did not intend (streams) to be a use-as-is #
Chris Trottier

@gzuckier Bots definitely exist but the common practice is that they self-identify as bots.

Adam

@atomicpoet Does Matrix really count as being part of the Fediverse? If yes, then so would email, right?

Chris Trottier

@adam I'm fine with email being part of the Fediverse, although it's of a different generation.

Adam

@atomicpoet It can do all the same things Matrix does though. My understanding of the Fediverse was that it was a network of public social networks. I would say Matrix is a messaging protocol. Oh well, it's not important.

Mike Macgirvin
My philosophy hasn't changed since the 1970s. A message is a message. What transport network you worship on any given day isn't relevant.
LucyWildboots πŸ³οΈβ€πŸŒˆ

@atomicpoet @adam@social.librem.one If people can solve Groups & people being able to communicate across the divide, I think you could get a lot of people to leave FB. Aside from inertia the three reasons I see most are: I can keep up with family and groups are high on why they stay. The other one is β€œI feel safe” and I don’t know how to provide them with compelling info beyond what is already out there.

Richard

@atomicpoet @pixelfed @matrix @dansup @mike @fediversenews I think Facebook will go the way of AOL when they open up, just like AOL did. It will no longer matter what your domain is--you will be able to interact with users and their content whatever the source, and Facebook will no longer have the "everyone is there" advantage. Unfortunately, I still forsee people gravitating to accounts on Google or Outlook, but the content they access can now be housed anywhere (for better or worse).

Chris Trottier

@parsa It's not enough to block Meta's instances. Meta itself needs to be replaced.

DELETED

@atomicpoet
I agree. The point of fediverse is to replace Meta and other surveillance companies and give freedom to users.
It would be nonsense if Meta join Fediverse!

Go Up