Gregory's Server
alright, after like a year of halfheartedly trying on and off, #FetchAllReplies is pretty much finished - the problem of not being able to see all replies to a post is one of the largest complaints that people have with mastodon in particular but also the fedi in general. It is an especially potent problem for smaller servers, making them feel lonely, and making the whole fedi seem quiet. It is also a large contributor to the 'reply guy' problem where a moderately popular post will get the same replies over and over again and people won't even know they're doing it.
This patch recursively fetches replies using activitypub collections. it does it respectfully, only when someone is explicitly looking at a post (rather than fetching all replies for everything all the time) with some debounce, and spaces out the recursive calls to the other servers in deep threads.
the only thing left is to make the posts get inserted into the web client as they are received, currently you need to refresh to see them.
trying it locally now and it is a game changer.
i'm not "good at ruby" so if you ever wanna see this upstream, kindly spare a code review?
https://github.com/NeuromatchAcademy/mastodon/pull/44
#FediDev #MastoDev #UnFuckTheFedi #PubSubIsCoolButPresentsPrettySeriousUsabilityProblems #JustSmallInstanceThings
alright, after like a year of halfheartedly trying on and off, #FetchAllReplies is pretty much finished - the problem of not being able to see all replies to a post is one of the largest complaints that people have with mastodon in particular but also the fedi in general. It is an especially potent problem for smaller servers, making them feel lonely, and making the whole fedi seem quiet. It is also a large contributor to the 'reply guy' problem where a moderately popular post will get the same replies...
@jonny thanks for sharing. ActivityPub is a protocol like TCP, where you have to check packet hits and misses rather than REST API over HTTPS 1.1.
@jonny sounds like something pretty essential that should be rolled into base Masto if it's good enough with resources.
I'm aware people have very different ideas of what Masto should be (and changes/projects often end up in a half-way house that please neither).
This should please everyone - it solves a long-standing moderation problem *and* makes Masto look more lively. So well done.
@jonny@neuromatch.social thank you, this will surely other platforms not just mastodon