Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
π’€­π’‚—π’† 

hot take but i think ISPs should return to giving every user a couple hundred megs of space on a public facing web server & encourage them to build little homepages. the corporatization of the web really hit overdrive when the persistent web presence of the average user stopped being a bunch of handwritten HTML and random files they wanted to share and instead became a profile template on a social media site

41 comments
mx alex tax1a - 2020 (4)

@enkiv2 not a hot take at all! the days before PHP, of cgi-bin were good actually!

Daughter of Rao

@enkiv2 or just give everyone true internet access, (No GC-NAT bull shit or similar) so they can without problems just host what every they want from any device at home.

π’€­π’‚—π’† 

@daughterofrao

I support that too, but the two ideas serve fundamentally different purposes.

Web hosting for static sites is pretty affordable, and free web hosting is available too -- for those who look. So-called "non-technical" people (who are often extremely technical in some other field) don't look, because it's not even on their radar as something possible. When I've spoken to these people, I've generally found that they think writing a web page and getting it on the public web is an extremely difficult thing that they'd need to learn a lot to do, and that might also be very expensive. It's this misconception that I'd like to counter, and the easiest way to counter it is to give everybody a public website + a tutorial.

Back when ISPs did this, even though only a fraction of users actually wrote and maintained anything substantial on their websites (and even though the whole userbase was much smaller), we got huge amounts of oral knowledge put on the internet -- lots of proto-blogs of ordinary (often eccentric) people flying their freak flags and showing off their collection of antique doorknobs or their knowledge of insect taxonomy or their collection of family pie recipes. Some of this culture survives in university faculty web spaces. Stuff like neocities is, I think, trying to recapture this, but the problem is that in order to know about neocities you need to be a nerd, and the diversity of geocities came from people who don't identify as computer nerds getting nerdy about other things.

@daughterofrao

I support that too, but the two ideas serve fundamentally different purposes.

Web hosting for static sites is pretty affordable, and free web hosting is available too -- for those who look. So-called "non-technical" people (who are often extremely technical in some other field) don't look, because it's not even on their radar as something possible. When I've spoken to these people, I've generally found that they think writing a web page and getting it on the public web is an extremely...

Mikle_Bond

@enkiv2

@daughterofrao

The great misconception I'd like to counter is the idea of "text file". In my experience, most of non-technical people can't grasp the idea of plain text files, as the only form of text they know is MS Word documents. Some people have never seen a text file, others might've thought of it as some kind of "broken" or "misbihaving" as it didn't open in their "text editor". Sometimes I was requested to send some pieces of information, and was accused in sending a "broken file" because it was a plain txt.

What MS Office have done to people is a crime, that keeps reinforcing itself. Non-technical people in power "guard this knowledge" by forcing their non-technical subordinates to only use MS Word and nothing else.

I wouldn't have guessed on my own that this would become a problem if I didn't witness it with my own eyes.

And tutorials would go like "HTML file is just a plain text file, that you can edit in your favorite text editor", but suddenly this statement is either unhelpful (at best) or misleading (at worst).

How to explain what "plain text" is to someone who have never seen one?

@enkiv2

@daughterofrao

The great misconception I'd like to counter is the idea of "text file". In my experience, most of non-technical people can't grasp the idea of plain text files, as the only form of text they know is MS Word documents. Some people have never seen a text file, others might've thought of it as some kind of "broken" or "misbihaving" as it didn't open in their "text editor". Sometimes I was requested to send some pieces of information, and was accused in sending a "broken file"...

patter

@Mikle_Bond @enkiv2 @daughterofrao some of the browsers back then had built in html editors (possibly full site builders, it was so long ago I can't remember the details of Netscape 4) so there was general availability of tools so you wouldn't have to muck about in raw plain text html

That could come back

S. John Ross

@Mikle_Bond @enkiv2 @daughterofrao In my case, I had hundreds of pages of weirdness on my old homepage but I relied on ancient WYSIWYG editing. I've never learned a lick of HTML beyond Bold and Italic and paragraph breaks, and still find the prospect intimidating. πŸ˜„ But, I killed my homepage for so many reasons.

I retreated to blog country, which felt like selling the farm and moving into a retirement village. 😁

knack

@enkiv2 @daughterofrao

I host a whole bunch of stuff at home, but anything I want to make accessible reliably I put in a cloud somewhere with a local backup. Downtime is just too frequent otherwise.

Daughter of Rao

@knack Sounds you've got a Internet DIsservice Provider...
They should just give ppl internet... relyably!

knack

@daughterofrao the lack of reliability is more to do with it running on my homelab (which I tinker with enough to make unreliable).

ISP-caused outages are rare & short here, though I had a sustained one when a truck hit the lines.

Putting static sites in AWS simplifies a whole bunch of things.

Kudra :maybe_verified:

@enkiv2 @daughterofrao I feel this so much. I will make sure my daughter learns basic html when she's old enough to tinker with it. I think it's something that needs to be addressed in school as a basic skill. I'm old enough that the web wasn't really a global public thing that you could access until I'd finished uni the first time around, though it did start ramping up not long after. Geocities might have been my first attempt at a website, but I started registering domains not long after. At a basic level, if you don't have any php or databases, you can keep a simple website up without any maintenance for decades (and that's precisely what I've done in some cases - but in others I've let people complicate them and then be left a difficult task to learn all the complexity myself when they stop maintaining them, so I can appreciate many non-nerds being horribly intimidated.)

@enkiv2 @daughterofrao I feel this so much. I will make sure my daughter learns basic html when she's old enough to tinker with it. I think it's something that needs to be addressed in school as a basic skill. I'm old enough that the web wasn't really a global public thing that you could access until I'd finished uni the first time around, though it did start ramping up not long after. Geocities might have been my first attempt at a website, but I started registering domains not long after. At a...

jamil

@enkiv2 mine still does: the national capital freenet in Ottawa - non-profit internet!

ncf.ca

Theia πŸ³οΈβ€βš§οΈ

@enkiv2 I considered doing this in my friend group: getting a funny domain and giving friends Subdomains and static Webspace

copsewood

@tea @enkiv2 It's still possible to rent a virtual server and register a domain name basd on which you can create as many upload accounts, webmail and subdomained websites as your scripts enable for a few quid a month. I do just that, but the skills needed to do this are in much shorter supply than cloud capacity. Why just static ? CGI and PHP are still scalable enough for small sites. More secure if SFTP upload sites are chrooted, which open-ssh server makes reasonably straightforward.

Brook Miles

@enkiv2 my parents' ISP (their phone company) doesn't even run their own email service anymore, they migrated to gmail hosting recently :blobdisapproval:

Fluke McHappenstance :verified:

@enkiv2 enter "Roving Gang of Grandmas": we will need your help resetting our passwords so we can send the nice gentlemen from Microsoft the gift card codes they lovingly manipulated us into purchasing. Btw they told me to avoid a "Kid Boga" or some such - I dunno.

decryption

@enkiv2 I looked into this as a little perk for my newsletter subscribers and the legal requirements in Australia at least are so onerous - metadata retention, privacy policies, CSAM & terrorism risk assessments, etc - it’s just too much for me. The regulatory moat is real :(

Jef Poskanzer :batman:

@enkiv2 Encourage blogging too. Make RSS great again!

Xenofact :jrbd:

@enkiv2 honestly as much as I enjoy some social media, this. It also helps you stay tech literate and encourages useful personal stuff.

kaitlin

@enkiv2 (fitmc voice) the coldest take on fedi

tuban_muzuru

@enkiv2

With every iteration of the Web, it comes built in larger and more useful chunks. Outfits like Squarespace can give ordinary users beautiful sites. I can't imagine life without Github now.

The Doctor

@enkiv2 Having a personal website with any kind of media on it is considered a very strange thing now.

tetra
@enkiv2 Or even supply routers that allow port forwarding, as I know that a lot of ISP routers don't allow enough config to run a webserver
760ceb3b9c0ba4872cadf3ce35a7a494

@enkiv2 i think apple icloud should offer a personal page again

Jason Lefkowitz

@enkiv2 For a long time in the β€˜90s, AOL did this. For all the flak they got for being the ISP for the clueless, they gave every user a chunk of FTP-accessible webspace they could do whatever they wanted with. My first personal homepage, now long lost, lived there.

I would love to see a revival of basic static HTML publishing again. We’ve put so many layers of simplification on top of it that normal people can’t publish anymore. But you can teach a normal person basic HTML in a couple of hours.

Andrew Cook

@jalefkowit @enkiv2 I discovered Tailscale a few months ago, and one of the things I love is that it allows you to really simply and easily host a static page using the Funnel feature: tailscale.com/kb/1223/funnel/

It only requires a running machine of some sort, but it can be a Raspberry Pi sitting in the corner. No port forwarding, web server, SSL or other configuration to worry about, the app does it all for you!

V is for...

@enkiv2 @neil I would love too see that again. There was something fun about people handcrafting a little website. Wordpress just isn’t the same.

Chloe Raccoon

@enkiv2 @dh I could see that. I could also see it, due to most users, becoming the source for most phishing sites...

Sean D

@enkiv2 I first learnt HTML because of free webspace and a sense of curiosity. I'm not a web developer (prefer back-end stuff) but I suspect that inspired many of my generation to become one.

I can't imagine if I was a young person now, that I couldn't be bothered with the hassle. Also, my simple first static HTML page felt like an achievement that I could show off to people. That wouldn't be the case now.

Ryan Mann

@enkiv2 @TheQuinbox I agree and that would probably encourage more people to learn about things such as HTML.

Maia :sicko:

@enkiv2 the last time I expressed such a take, I got told to blow it out my ass, but I stand by it and I’m glad I’m not the only one

I actually do sort of think there is a place for social media or something like it (because for better or for worse your median internet user in 2023 is probably not all that interested in the kind of self-expression that personal webpages represent) but I think it should be more ephemeral by default rather than a by-default eternal repository of all the dumb shit anyone has ever said, it absolutely should not be a corporate-owned surveillance capitalism platform, and should encourage considered, intentional communities instead of a universal firehose of bad takes. Mastodon is almost that if you squint hard enough, but it is severely hobbled by having basically β€œwhat if Twitter, but email” as a design philosophy

although I also sort of wonder if the sort of earnest dorkiness inherent in personal webpages could exist in our irony-poisoned era

@enkiv2 the last time I expressed such a take, I got told to blow it out my ass, but I stand by it and I’m glad I’m not the only one

I actually do sort of think there is a place for social media or something like it (because for better or for worse your median internet user in 2023 is probably not all that interested in the kind of self-expression that personal webpages represent) but I think it should be more ephemeral by default rather than a by-default eternal repository of all the dumb shit anyone...

apgarcia

@enkiv2 the ancient web: it was ugly, but it was ours.

snep

@enkiv2 THIS!!! I think some in the responses don't get what having a website IS, since they're used to ugly templates like squarespace. Your home page is supposed to be fun and where you can make up an idealized version of yourself to portray. Mainstream Social media doesn't allow that at all, and other places its an uphill battle to do that in 2023. Why should I show you my ID to post on this broke ass borgsite? Lol. The more corporate things get, the more boring life is.

Rich Felker

@enkiv2 Nooooooo, this was the worst - ISP lock-in thru loss of web home or email address if you switched. ISPs should have no involvement in your identity/presence on the internet.

LisPi
@dalias @enkiv2 Not really, if you have your own domain you can switch at a whim and just re-upload your site to the new endpoint.
ikanreed

@enkiv2 you hear that genie? Back in the bottle!

G (Nap God)

@enkiv2 ideally I agree but it’s already absurdly easy to set up a small personal website and people aren’t doing it so solving the problem of convincing people to do it in the first place needs to come first.

JimmyChezPants

@enkiv2

Radioactive take, and I'm sitting here glowing with gamma-level pleasure at the idea.

DavidB

@enkiv2@eldritch.cafe I'm not even joking when I say that the web should return to animated "in construction" gifs.

Go Up