Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
cuan_knaggs

@atomicpoet @gisiger the general population doesn't care though and likely never will. the option with the biggest marketing budget will get the largest user base

26 comments
cuan_knaggs

@atomicpoet @gisiger sure but having a brand and a message that will reach and resonate with the mass population will be very tricky for any decentralised, open source system

cuan_knaggs replied to Chris

@atomicpoet @gisiger no, not impossible. is there a fediverce foundation yet that could co-ordinate this part of the work?

Chris Trottier replied to cuan_knaggs

@mensrea @gisiger Mastodon is a non-profit. The W3C, which standardized ActivityPub, is also a non-profit. The Mozilla Foundation, which just announced they will be investing in the Fediverse, is also a non-profit.

There's also several ethical for-profit entities building out the Fediverse.

Michael Gisiger :mastodon: replied to Chris

@atomicpoet @mensrea But Mozilla takes money from Google, therefore it's a front for Google to take over the fediverse! (not my words, but I just read something along those lines here ...)

Steve Bannister replied to Michael Gisiger :mastodon:

@gisiger @atomicpoet @mensrea that's quite a leap to take. Google paying Firefox to be their default search engine as they do Apple. Not sure how that translates to Mozilla becoming a front for a hypothetical Google desire to take over the fediverse

sbi replied to Michael Gisiger :mastodon:

@gisiger @atomicpoet @mensrea I take money from my employer, yet I'm not just their front here.

cuan_knaggs replied to Chris

@atomicpoet @gisiger i was thinking more of a group body for the fediverce writ large that can do co-ordinated marketing, advocacy, education, lobbying, ...

Michael Gisiger :mastodon: replied to Marge

@WuMargaret @atomicpoet @mensrea I'm pretty sure, that's possible. But someone has to finance it, which in turn will be criticized by some (cf. Mozilla and Google). But, the German company by Eugen Rochko @Gargron behind Mastodon is already a non-profit LLC.

cuan_knaggs replied to Marge

@WuMargaret @atomicpoet @gisiger yup, someone with enough organization and people herding skill could get it going.

Dick Smiths Fair Go Supporters replied to Chris

@atomicpoet
Its not just the domain name of the instance itself that we need to be mindful of but also the #CDN that the server is using for images. Many instances use a seperate CDN.

The instance we are on uses what we understand to be a popular one by #BunnyCDN, namely cdn.masto.host.

As a secondary concern such CDN appears to block #Tor. We are again unable to post images again. (@witchescauldron)

1/2

#blocksTor #unethicalConduct @mensrea @gisiger

@atomicpoet
Its not just the domain name of the instance itself that we need to be mindful of but also the #CDN that the server is using for images. Many instances use a seperate CDN.

The instance we are on uses what we understand to be a popular one by #BunnyCDN, namely cdn.masto.host.

As a secondary concern such CDN appears to block #Tor. We are again unable to post images again. (@witchescauldron)

Dick Smiths Fair Go Supporters replied to Dick Smiths Fair Go Supporters

@atomicpoet @witchescauldron @mensrea @gisiger
If a CDN becomes too big the result is a just another #centralisation problem. Again, censorship and suppression at scale in the form of denial of serving content like #images and #videos is possible.

The #TooBigToExist CDN can also begin to gather data on users, for example when they are accessing the content and what content do they tend to look at etc.

The very nature of the #legacyInternet is unworkable. Alternatives like #I2P and Tor exist.

@atomicpoet @witchescauldron @mensrea @gisiger
If a CDN becomes too big the result is a just another #centralisation problem. Again, censorship and suppression at scale in the form of denial of serving content like #images and #videos is possible.

The #TooBigToExist CDN can also begin to gather data on users, for example when they are accessing the content and what content do they tend to look at etc.

Dick Smiths Fair Go Supporters replied to Dick Smiths Fair Go Supporters

@atomicpoet @witchescauldron @mensrea @gisiger
@lightone

3/3

Even worse is that some instances are using (Sc)amazon or Cloudflare to serve content.

We need to find ways to resist this.

People who operate sites dedicated to listing #fediverseInstances are welcome to contact us and ask us to do an assessment of instances they list. We are happy to volunteer to do this.

Knowledge is #power, and we need to remain as vigilant as ever to ensure the power remains #distributed.

@atomicpoet @witchescauldron @mensrea @gisiger
@lightone

3/3

Even worse is that some instances are using (Sc)amazon or Cloudflare to serve content.

We need to find ways to resist this.

People who operate sites dedicated to listing #fediverseInstances are welcome to contact us and ask us to do an assessment of instances they list. We are happy to volunteer to do this.

(gobsmacked) replied to Dick Smiths Fair Go Supporters

@dsfgs @atomicpoet @witchescauldron @mensrea @gisiger @lightone A list - spreadsheet- of instances with this kind of info - who owns, legal status (NPO, LLC, etc.), what CDN they use, etc. might be interesting. Would want to also include info on whether blocked a lot, moderation policy, what fork of any etc.

Jakob Voß replied to Chris

@atomicpoet @mensrea @gisiger No silver bullet, but Fediverse instances for specific languages, regions, topics... are more likely to be run and supported by volunteers. Call it branding on instance level. Think globally, act locally. But: soon commercial providers will offer "host an instance for your community". Not good.

Michael Gisiger :mastodon:

@mensrea @atomicpoet yes, that's why I'm happy of instances of big(ger) OS projects like Vivaldi or Mozilla. Yet many people don't like those and block them (happened already to Vivaldi) 🤷‍♀️

Josef Petrák

@gisiger @mensrea @atomicpoet That anti-corporation attitude will kill Mastodon one day.

Michael Gisiger :mastodon:

@jspetrak @mensrea @atomicpoet well, not kill per se, but sink it (back) into the muddy waters of the 'open source sectarians' ...

Tionisla replied to Michael Gisiger :mastodon:

@gisiger @jspetrak @mensrea @atomicpoet

which might not be so muddy at all on second thought *sigh*

oh well... ymmv

Go Up