Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Bonfire

Introducing the Open Science Network 🔬
We're thrilled to be part of this initiative dedicated to building open and federated digital spaces to push the boundaries of open science and scholarly communication.
🔗 Explore more on the website: openscience.network
📢 Dive into the details in our announcement blog post: bonfirenetworks.org/posts/open

@brembs @UlrikeHahn @jorge @open_science
#openscience

32 comments
Julian Fietkau

@bonfire I'm into it. 👍

Going by the website, it looks like ORCID itself isn't (yet?) officially involved with this project. I'm guessing you're using their API.

I've recently been thinking about a potential project to make ORCID records ActivityPub-followable, to keep up to date about colleagues who don't personally use the fediverse yet. Does that sound interesting? Are there ethical concerns? There used to be at least one ORCID-to-RSS service but it's been dead for a while.

Bonfire

@julian Great idea!

Our prototype enables users to create a federated ORCID account by linking it to Bonfire, so others can follow and receive their latest publications. To make any/all ORCID records AP-followable, a direct collaboration with ORCID would be ideal. This could ensure a unique canonical federated account per researcher and a way for people to "claim" it when joining the fediverse, including the migration of previous followers.

@open_science @jorge @UlrikeHahn @brembs

Björn Brembs

@bonfire @julian @open_science @jorge @UlrikeHahn

Hmm, I used to know some people at ORCID. Let me check if they are still there...

Julian Fietkau

@brembs @bonfire The reason I've been a bit reluctant to barge ahead with this idea (besides personal bandwidth) is ORCID's API structure, which limits record update notifications to premium members: info.orcid.org/membership/ So if we're talking about a service that effectively allows third parties to subscribe to ORCID record update feeds, I wonder if things would get all lawyery all of a sudden. 😬 But I'll ask them about it some time if no one gets ahead of me.

@open_science @jorge @UlrikeHahn

@brembs @bonfire The reason I've been a bit reluctant to barge ahead with this idea (besides personal bandwidth) is ORCID's API structure, which limits record update notifications to premium members: info.orcid.org/membership/ So if we're talking about a service that effectively allows third parties to subscribe to ORCID record update feeds, I wonder if things would get all lawyery all of a sudden. 😬 But I'll ask them about it some time if no one gets ahead of me.

Dr. jonny phd

@julian
@brembs @bonfire @open_science @jorge @UlrikeHahn
Oh dang we pretty much have this working with ORCID, Crossref, and openalex to RSS feeds, I just need to launch the server. I forget how much interest there is in this

Björn Brembs

@bonfire @julian @open_science @jorge @UlrikeHahn

Unfortunately, all the people formerly affiliated with ORCID that I knew personally appear to have left.

Björn Brembs

@fresseng @bonfire @julian @open_science @jorge @UlrikeHahn

I did see that, when I looked, just now.
Excellent! Would be great to hear that something may be moving in thi direction!

P.S.: This would sort of remind me of FriendFeed, where we could subscribe to the RSS feeds of friends who, in turn, assembled their feeds from their various contributions. Would be wonderful to recover some of that previous functionality we have been missing for so long.

Nicolas Fressengeas

@brembs
I have to think about it, but I could liaise with ORCID product team. I still have to understand exactly what for exactly. I have the feeling they would be interested.
@bonfire @julian @open_science @jorge @UlrikeHahn

Julian Fietkau

@fresseng If ORCID is willing to have this under their aegis, I think I could come up with an implementation to make ORCID records AP-followable, at least as a prototype. My own ActivityPub work is kind of early stage and I don't have much experience scaling things up, but we could test something with an early-adopter community, see if it makes sense, and then maybe rearchitect with @bonfire. 🙂

@brembs @open_science @jorge @UlrikeHahn

Nicolas Fressengeas

@julian
Alright! This looks good. I think I could introduce you to Tom Demeranville (head of product team) with this kind of project, so that you may chat together. Please send me an email with these details so that I can get yours and liaise with Tom (my email is on my ORCID)
@bonfire @brembs @open_science @jorge @UlrikeHahn

Bonfire

@julian

Let's schedule a call to discuss how to best collaborate on this?

@fresseng @brembs @open_science @jorge @UlrikeHahn

Julian Fietkau

@bonfire I'm super in favor of having you there for the project exploration with ORCID, since you've already done the work of converting ORCID records (via their API) to ActivityPub actors, which I'd describe as the only challenging technical part of my proposal. The rest is all about getting the right people together and in agreement that this is a worthwhile project.

Since @fresseng suggested moving to email, wanna ping me at julian@fietkau.me? I'll CC you for my opening mail.

Julian Fietkau

@jonny I think ORCID, assuming they'll agree to do an ActivityPub project in-house, will want to run something that uses only their API and no external data sources. But there is clearly a lot of overlap with what you're doing. Wanna be part of the email thread and/or potentially a future Zoom call? fietkau.social/@julian/1120047

@bonfire @fresseng @brembs

Dr. jonny phd

@julian
@bonfire @fresseng @brembs
Ya I am inclined to build offroad small web tech that scavenges, lives off the land, and slips in the open cracks :) complementary approaches

manisha

@bonfire this looks great and very promising! some of us at neuromatch.social #neuromatchstodon are definitely interested in joining as a pilot community. we'll be in touch!

Bonfire

@manisha sounds great! We have been in touch with @jonny but we didn’t yet find the time for having a proper discussion :) looking forward to make it happen!

marcelcosta
@bonfire @jorge Hey! This looks very interesting! I have joined as an opencollective supporter (not much, but stable).

I'll be waiting for some initial pilot :)
GhostOnTheHalfShell

@bonfire @brembs @UlrikeHahn @jorge @open_science

Looks like the god children of academia’s exodus from Twitter and enclosure is beginning to bear fruit.

Ashley Reynolds

@bonfire @brembs @UlrikeHahn @jorge is there a way to sign up for email or RSS updates on this project? I am not consistently active on social media

Notizie da Poliverso

@ashinonyx each Fediverse account can be followed via an RSS feed. To follow the Bonfire account from your feed reader, you can use this address

https://indieweb.social/@bonfire.rss

and, since only messages published directly are subscribed to and not those re-shared, I recommend you also follow the one at @bernini

https://social.coop/@bernini.rss

@bonfire @jorge @brembs @UlrikeHahn

Bonfire

@GunnarBlohm interesting project! seems we share a similar sense of urgency and some objectives, one of the main difference afaik is that they're developing a centralized platform while we aim to develop digital spaces that each scientific community / org / university / etc can install, govern and use to connect with the rest of the fediverse ?
@brembs @UlrikeHahn @jorge @open_science

Ulrike Hahn

@bonfire @GunnarBlohm @brembs @jorge @open_science

and the digital space we envision covers more than just 'publishing'...

qeef

@bonfire @brembs @UlrikeHahn @jorge @open_science

Oh, I almost believed you. Then I found out your source code is on GitHub. Sorry, but if you are serious about your mission of openness, you are on Codeberg or Sourcehut.

Bonfire

@qeef

That’s a fair point. We’re on Github for historical reasons (before being forked to became Bonfire the project was hosted on the open-source Gitlab before migrating away, here was our reasoning at the time: web.archive.org/web/2021012501. We’re eager to migrate to a federation-enabled forge as soon as one is available (there are several teams working of ActivityPub implementations)

@brembs @UlrikeHahn @jorge @open_science

Dan Goodman

@bonfire @brembs @UlrikeHahn @jorge @open_science very interested to see where this goes. Pushes all my (good) buttons.

Go Up