Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Derek Powazek 🐐

People who say they don’t like nazis, but turn around and take money from nazis, and give money to nazis, do in fact like nazis.
#Substack

72 comments
charvaka :mastodon:

@fraying

At a minimum you can say that their like of money outweighs any of their stated dislike of Nazis.

Derek Powazek 🐐

@charvaka When you're on the nazi's kill list, that's not much of a difference.

the cake is offline

@charvaka @fraying Nazis LIE, bro. If you say you hate Nazis, then sit down at their table, you're a fucking Nazi.

NO EXCEPTIONS.

Derek Powazek 🐐

@cell911 I do. But I'm more talking about Substack at the moment.

datarama

@fraying At the very least they've shown that disseminating and monetizing Nazi propaganda isn't a business dealbreaker.

...which, for a company, is a much more relevant piece of information than what any of its owners or employees might like or not like.

Derek Powazek 🐐

Just a quick note to anyone thinking of quibbling about the difference between a nazi and someone who merely tolerates nazi content: when you're on their kill list, that difference disappears pretty quick.

Derek Powazek 🐐

This is why I'm talking about people profiting from nazi shit today: substack.com/@hamish/note/c-45

Monica Rooney

@fraying trying to say they’re doing us a favour by helping Nazis

Derek Powazek 🐐

Substack has a policy against porn, which is also tricky to define, and yet somehow they're able to limit content when it comes to adult material, but nazi shit is fine. They're perfectly happy to limit some content but not other content, so it's telling what they think is part of free speech and what isn't.

Derek Powazek 🐐

The most frustrating part is, it's so easy to say "take that shit somewhere else" when you run a bar or a website or any other group. That's literally your job when you create a space like that. I've seen people do it. I've done it. It's so fucking easy. You just go, "get out." And then they do. They have to. It's your place!

Anyone who says it's not easy is lying, and it's usually because they don't want it taken someplace else. They like it right where it is.

#Substack

Jer Warren

@fraying What's frustrating to me is that Substack at launch was courting / paying assholes to use their platform. Most people only even heard of them because they were suddenly home to Andy Ngo, and other assholes. Yet people still signed up to publish there.

I have no sympathy for anyone who publishes on Substack who suddenly finds themselves needing to find a new provider.

Jessamyn

@fraying The most frustrating part to me, besides all the others, is how they act like what they *think* ("Oh demonetization makes it worse!") seems to be more important than what we know about extremism in social spaces (i.e. deplatforming works)

DELETED

@fraying Eles gostam mais do dinheiro do que do bom senso.

Paul Riismandel

@fraying Exactly! The right to free association includes the right to with whom to associate.

Maria Langer | πŸ“ 🎬 βš’οΈπŸ›₯️

@fraying

Its easy. I’m not lying. I ran a BBS in the 1990s and have been blogging (with comments enabled) since 2003. I don’t take shit. I toss offensive people out. I delete their crap, I ban them, I block them. Anything I have to do to get rid of them. It’s my show and my rules. Easy peasy. xkcd.com/1357/

Alastair Cooper

@fraying@xoxo.zone Nazi stuff is may be harder to detect than porn, but they should still be able to get rid of it if they were so inclined. Not 100% of it, all of the time, but they could do it. It might even constitute a proper use for LLMs alongside human moderation.

Michael Gemar

@fraying @tim β€œWe don’t like pedophiles β€” we wish no-one held those views. But…”

Falcon

@fraying WHOA, just WHOA.
I'm putting substack on my adblocker blocklist.

Scott Orchard

@falcon @fraying this is a great idea. I stopped subscribing to newsletters there, but it's time to stop reading anything there as well.

Matt Wilcox

@fraying @anildash That’s a boat load of horsehit right there. While they’re deep in their ethical well looking for Big Thoughts they might want to inspect the β€œa tolerant society can not tolerate intolerance” angle. Nazis are intolerance personified. They can not be tolerated. They’re just poison.

@990000@mstdn.social

@fraying ugh gross, just read it. I hate that I know people who are still writing on Substack :(

InkySchwartz

@fraying Oy the memo and the comments are basically what I expected for someone saying Nazis are OK to spend money here.

David Mooney

@fraying Wouldn't it be great if one of these techbros consulted with someone who studies this exact topic?

Is refusing to give someone a platform the same as censoring them? Does giving someone a platform somehow make their ideas less popular? πŸ€” Who could ever know?

Derek Powazek 🐐

@davidm it’s really high school philosophy level β€œparadox of tolerance” shit.

Tim Boucher

@fraying β€œsubjecting ideas to open discourse is the best way to strip bad ideas of their power”
Well, that’s a bunch of horseshit. Let’s have an intelligent discussion about the pros and cons of wanting to exterminate certain groups. Yea or nay?
Plus that β€œopen” β€œdiscourse” happened 80 years ago and we came to a conclusion on the topic.

Tim Boucher

@fraying it was clear where this was going with the way they minimize the problem by talking about β€œfringe voices”.

Derek Powazek 🐐

@t_i_m ha. Yeah. As if it’s a fringe position to not like having nazis in your community. I thought we had a whole war about that.

Tim Boucher

@fraying I think the so-called fringe voices are the nazis. So fringe, a whole party of a two-party system of one of the most powerful countries is running on it!

CaseyL

@fraying

Has substack made no response at all to the open letter from the writers who publish there?

CaseyL

@fraying

If the writers I support on Substack bail, then so will I.

It's a devil's bargain, but I do care about the writers I subscribe to.

bedast :diabetes:

@fraying I like to use the bad apple analogy. Not the one where someone points out a bad apple and forgets the rest. The whole thing.

The bunch is spoiled.

Joe Ryan

@fraying "Why do these Nazis keep gathering in my Nazi bar? Hold for a second, looks like Heinrich needs his drink refreshed."

Scott Orchard

@fraying this is why I cancelled all my Substack subscriptions last year. Do I want to support journalists and marginalized voices, of course. Do I want to support a platform that rakes in money from Nazis, Nazi supporters, and continues to wave their hands with something stupid about censoring Nazi views, absolutely not. If your argument is that the Nazis will go make money somewhere else unless they have your platform, you're a Nazi. #substack

Anthony Sorace

@fraying β€œI wish everyone would stop doing the thing I both profit from and financially support!”

Derek Powazek 🐐

@a It's such weak sauce it can't even be counted as sauce.

Ray Gulick πŸ’—πŸŒ› ⭐️ πŸ€

@fraying
Substack: "We don't like nazis, but when they bring us money, whaddya gonna do, eh?"

DELETED

@fraying

Can we please remind everyone using Brave Browser, that the CEO and Founder of Brave Browser, does not believe in womens rights, trans rights, and other basic rights of humans.

See the connection.

Glenn

@Linux_Is_Best @fraying Not to mention the fact that the bastard created JavaScript!

DELETED

@glennsills @fraying

True, but the royalty free programming language, javascript, is not directly making him any money, while Brave Browser most certainly is.

Glenn

@Linux_Is_Best @fraying Yeah, but I occasionally have to program in JavaScript and let me tell you, that guy is going to suffer in the afterlife.

Glenn

@Linux_Is_Best @fraying But seriously, I am always cautious when dealing with any libertarian. Many of them seem to have a "I've got my liberty and you've got yours to get" sort of attitude.

Defiance!

@fraying Not surprised. Wealthy Libertarians have always tolerated Nazis.

Defiance!

@fraying My sign would read "expressing lack of surprise does not indicate a lack of outrage"

Derek Powazek 🐐

@Defiance then say that, because nobody needs to know how unsurprised you are

Esther Payne :bisexual_flag:

@fraying and TERFs. Although the link between ear right and TERFs is documented.

Graham Lineham has had a substack for years.

A man who literally whipped up a hate email mob against a Trans kid charity.

yewtu.be/watch?v=lS1k88LzjkQ

Dr. Zalka Csenge VirΓ‘g

@fraying I found out what Substack is this morning. Well, this was a quick round trip πŸ˜†πŸ˜†

Go Up