Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Hugh Young

@ChevalierDesMots @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu

Those books seem to be mainly about mathematics. You cite Bertrand Russell. I doubt you have read him on religion.

44 comments
KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu
No it is NOT about mathematics only, mathematics is using language that is why it is included to the Philosophical Investigations = conceptual investigations.

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Tom

@TomSwirly @hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu People who declare "why I am not a Christian" never explain their "RELIGION+LAW" so that people can compare their RELIGION+LAW with the Christians' RELIGION+LAW. Why?

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@TomSwirly @hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu
If you are NOT Christian, you are Atheist, then please disclose your RELIGION+LAW that your way of life is based on, so that we know the difference between your RELIGION+LAW and the Christian RELIGION+LAW.
Do us a favor please.

Hugh Young replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@ChevalierDesMots @TomSwirly @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu

Because we don't have to. Christianity makes many claims we don't accept and that's it.

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu By the way Russell never accepted modern philosophical investigations questioning his language, that is why before he died he asked people to bury him somewhere no one knows where😅

Hugh Young replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@ChevalierDesMots @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu

There is no connection between those statements.
Bertrand Russell was cremated and his ashes were scattered over the mountains in Wales.

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu Please read them before you say "seem to be mainly mathematics".

Hugh Young replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@ChevalierDesMots @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu

I bet you $1 you have never read Russell's Principia Mathematics, let alone understood it.

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu You are free to dream that I didn't read Principia Mathematica😅

Hugh Young replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@ChevalierDesMots @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu

I did mean "read and understand" it, not just let your eyes rove along the lines. Very few people have actually read its three volumes. If you even dipped into it, you would know that it says nothing about religion.

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu It may not say anything about "religion" but when we use our concept of "religion" based on the revealed books, we can see what is described. A way of life, based on certain LAWS we identify it as "RELIGION".

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu You can't imagine how much I paid to buy Principia Mathematica😂

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu When you start reading them you will be very, very sorry that you haven't started reading them long before.....

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu and the rest of your life you will thank me to remind you the existence of those books.

Tom Ritchford replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@ChevalierDesMots @hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu

I'm sorry, but do you not have any conception of how rude and conceited you appear?

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Tom

@TomSwirly @hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu Also question your concept of "rude" and "conceited".

Tom Ritchford replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@ChevalierDesMots @hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu

You wrote.

> and the rest of your life you will thank me to remind you the existence of those books.

Tom Ritchford replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@ChevalierDesMots @hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu Any recommendation by you is a black mark that will ensure that I, and any other adult on this thread, will never read it.

Please go away now.

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Tom

@TomSwirly @hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu
I only share what I value with people. I have no plover or will to force you to read them.

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Tom

@TomSwirly @hugh @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu I am already away from you, if you stop responding I won't be replying back.

Hugh Young replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@ChevalierDesMots @TomSwirly @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu

Rude because you assume what we believe without being told. Conceited because you think you have all the answers.

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh @TomSwirly @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu
I didn't claim that I have all the answers, but I showed the resources that you can investigate your conceptual confusions..

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@hugh @TomSwirly @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu
But it looks like you don't like to question your conceptual confusions.🤔

Hugh Young replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@ChevalierDesMots @TomSwirly @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu

More wild assumptions from someone who's pretty conceptually confused yourself, if you think the only alternative to Christianity is atheism.

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh
Where did you get this idea that "I think the only alternative to Christianity is atheism."
I am NOT the one who said "Sorry, I am Atheist!". Check it out Man!

Hugh Young replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@ChevalierDesMots

Where you said "If you are NOT Christian, you are Atheist".

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh I didn't say that too, you confuse messages.

Hugh Young replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@ChevalierDesMots
Oh yes you did. Enough of you. Goodbye.

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh OK let me correct it:
If You are not Christian you are Atheist Christian, then please disclose your RELIGION+LAW that your way of life is based on, so that we know the difference between your RELIGION+LAW and the Christian RELIGION+LAW.
It looks like I mis understand you when you said "I am Atheist" You should say "I am Atheist Christian". Is that what you wanted to say?

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh Don't say just "Goodbye" clarify your concept of "Atheist".

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@hugh You can bring your RELIGION+LAW based on the Protocol like this:

chevalier-des-mots.blogspot.co

to help people to understand your RELIGION+LAW.

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh When one just say "I am Atheist" in general use of this word doesn't relate it to Christian/or other Religion+Law. If you claim that you are "Atheist Christian" then say so?!

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to KIZILELMALILAR

@hugh and don't forget to bring your Christian Atheist RELIGION+LAW to let us compare it with Christian RELIGION+LAW.

KIZILELMALILAR Ummeti replied to Hugh

@hugh @TomSwirly @Ulzana @MiriShuli @Niall @chu I have NO answers Mate!! But I know where and how you can discover all the answers to your Conceptual Confusions.

Go Up