Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
dansup

Blocking an account on @pixelfed means you will never see posts from that account, but should it also prevent that account from viewing your posts?

Enforcing this across instances would be challenging, is this something @pixelfed should explore? #askFedi

Anonymous poll

Poll

Yes, I'm all for improved blocks
242
70.6%
No, can't guarantee enforcement
56
16.3%
I'm unsure
45
13.1%
343 people voted.
Voting ended 15 Sep 2023 at 10:14.
8 comments
Flock of Cats 🐈 🐈 🐈 πŸ¦ƒ

@dansup @pixelfed

Yeah, β€œblock” should be both ways. If it is only stopping you from seeing stuff, I think it should be called β€œmute”, which would fit with standard terms and people’s expectations.

Skoop (Stefan Koopmanschap)

@dansup I said "no" mostly because in a federated context it's going to be impossible to enforce this. If I'm missing a way that would enforce this, I might change my vote to "yes"

Konstantin Weddige

@dansup @pixelfed in the end, it doesn't have to work in 100% of the cases. The blocked user can always create a new account to circumvent the block, but implementing blocks only one way keeps reminding the blocked user of the fact with every post.

loutre :verified: :verified:

@dansup @pixelfed well i'd say it would be nice if the post didn't appear in the timeline.

but ultimately, the person blocked can just sign off and see the post that way anyway

Paul

@dansup @pixelfed ideally yeah...

In the current Fediverse, no, waste of effort to attempt to implement it.

If someone wanted to view your posts they could if its a public profile, by logging out, or making another account etc, or just using RSS.

DELETED

@dansup @pixelfed Feels to me that posting public content and then wanting control over who can see it is mutually exclusive. If one would wish to communicate in a closed manner then perhaps @pixelfed, maybe the Fediverse in general, is the wrong tool for the job.

Josh Holme

@dansup @pixelfed If they were able to see your content that wouldn’t be a block, that would be more like muting them

DELETED

@dansup @pixelfed
If I just want to tune someone out, I can mute them. If I block them, they should not be able to see me either.

Go Up