Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Charlie Fish

@falcon @gracjan @nf3xn Sounds like you want the benefits of centralization in a decentralized system. However, I’d push back on the first point a bit. There is nothing stopping someone from creating r/anime and r/animeofficial. However, I question if these are truly big enough issues to stifle usage once it matures. Once you get enough federation, it feels like the real world impacts of these issues are minimal or nonexistent.

5 comments
Falcon replied to Charlie

@fishcharlie @gracjan @nf3xn

> Sounds like you want the benefits of centralization in a decentralized system

I don't. I never suggested a de-centralized alternative to Reddit. In fact, I was advocating that something decentralized would NOT be a replacement for Reddit exactly because it is decentralized.

Falcon replied to Falcon

@fishcharlie @gracjan @nf3xn

> There is nothing stopping someone from creating r/anime and r/animeofficial

There's nothing, and it happens with new TV shows - Example, From (Paramount+). But when this happens, one of the communities ends up being the bigger one, and, since it's centralized, you know easily which one is bigger or more active. Which you wouldn't know in a decentralized environment, since your instance might not know about some other instance

Charlie Fish replied to Falcon

@falcon @gracjan @nf3xn That’s what I’m saying. With enough federation that isn’t an issue. Sure, without federation it’s an issue. But with enough federation it is not an issue.

Cybarbie replied to Charlie

@fishcharlie @falcon @gracjan the devs not the admins, the people who make the software.

Falcon replied to Charlie

@fishcharlie @gracjan @nf3xn Even Mastodon doesn't have enough federation yet, so I still need to use mastodon(dot)social for doing searches once in a while.

Go Up