Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
aeva

now ChatGPT seems really impressive and all but you have to remember that you can be tricked into thinking a rock has feelings by drawing a cute face on it

97 comments
mym

@aeva aeva that rock is my friend

Eddie Roosenmaallen

@aeva
It’s worse than that.
I read a while back that factories that stick googly eyes on their robots have fewer accidents and injuries, seemingly because “thing has eyes” is enough to make human workers’ brains give the robots more attention and personal space.
They were working on a system to use artificial eyes to telegraph what the robot is going to do, but it turned out that’s not necessary. Just make it a little cute and fewer people walk into its workspace.

wakame

@silvermoon82 @aeva I think that's a good thing. Robots are currently treated like second-class humans in most factories.

aeva

@silvermoon82 tbh I think this is one of our more endearing qualities

aeva

@silvermoon82 I'll have to remember to put googly eyes on my luggage if I ever travel by air again

Internet Dad 🐀

@silvermoon82 @aeva
Humans are so primed for social interaction that we'll pack-bond with anything. I think it's a prime driver in how we domesticated wolves.
"Look!" Grug points excitedly at the sleeping hulking pile of fur, muscle, and tooth. "It's friend-shaped! I'm gonna love it."
Meanwhile, the wolf wakes up to the most *exquisite* feeling of something scratching right behind its ears...

Ellie lol

@aeva *muttering to myself repeatedly as I type prompts* "you will not pack bond with the chat bot, you will not pack bond with the chat bot, you will not pack bond with the chat bot..."

Matthew Martin ☑ ✅📛

@aeva so if I put googly eyes on my forehead, my wife will then assume I have feelings instead of asking me about my feelings.

ENIGMATICO :heartbleed:

@aeva@mastodon.gamedev.place Reminds me of how Apple used to put faces on all the computers they presented in the past so that they looked less scary to the public.

FoolishOwl

@aeva There's a bit in an early episode of Community where Jeff Winger gives a name to a pencil, and then snaps it, and says, "And a little bit of you died inside just now."

Josh O'Connor-Chen

@aeva That rock has considerably more empathy than quite a few people.

Casey

@cwebber @aeva Shall we call this “The Wilson Effect”?

Madison :blob_cat_coffee:

@aeva The human instinct to pack bond applies to *everything*

Fiona Bianchi

@aeva so in summary: ChatGPT isn’t *that* good, it’s humans that are *so* gullible 😀

aeva

@esheep I would never! Rock-chan is a dear friend and a valuable member of the community

faun

@aeva @neauoire The problem runs deep. Give me a stuffed toy, tell me a child loved it, I wont be able to recycle it no matter what. It will be screamed from the heart of me that this thing has moral standing.

Devine Lu Linvega

@faun @aeva I'm the same, I make all sorts of origami shapes that Rekka draws faces on, now the boat is filled with them and I can't get myself to put them in the bin.. 😢

faun

@neauoire @aeva There are going to be so many uplifted soft toys (and resurrected dogs, and nonfictionalized characters, and cavorting swarms of origami critters) in humanity's eschaton

aeva

I just hope the AI researchers remember to teach the computer to aggressively pack bond with all things too ._.

aeva

I asked ChatGPT about it, and I have bad news everyone:

13 barn owls in a trench coat

@aeva as an animist, I have a philosophical objection to this position, but as it's thinking sand, I guess it would know

El Diablo Roboc

@aeva I've had my share of conversations with AIs, and I remember something similar. I asked it "But you are made of silicon. That would mean that you don't have a soul !"

"I never said I had one", was its answer.

El Diablo Roboc

@aeva

I made a HAL 9000 bot, and this is what he answered:

Timo the timo

@aeva
quoth the ai bot:

[...]

Additionally, treating a rock as a friend and companion can be harmful to one's mental health. It can create a reliance on an inanimate object for emotional support and companionship, leading to isolation and disconnection from real human relationships.

It is important to remember that rocks are not capable of forming meaningful relationships or providing emotional support. They are inanimate objects and should not be treated as living beings.

Clifton Royston

@timotimo @aeva

Well now we know for sure ChatGPT isn't a real person.

rich

@aeva Stable Diffusion and Dall-E joining forces to deep-fake GPT3 responses 😳 😋

flere-imsaho

@aeva i just asked people with access to it to ask a very specific question (klapaucius' request for a six-lines poem from kandel's translation of lem's cyberiad), and it failed spectacularly: circumstances.run/@mawhrin/109

(i was mostly interested if the engine was fed the text of the story, but the result was interesting in itself; none of the returned results were six lines long)

Lilian Edwards

@aeva @davidgerard i don't think anyone playing with it over here thinks it has a mind - we're just excited at a cool tool. Like Wordle, only better 😂

aeva

@lilianedwards @davidgerard I have seen people in the past express with sincerity that they believe the recent generation of AI is sentient.

Marcel Waldvogel

@aeva @lilianedwards @davidgerard These poor humans were fooled into thinking that the AIs from earlier this year were in fact sentient. We all know they were so wrong. But now we finally have proofs that the current generation of AIs *really* are sentient!

DesignDamon

@aeva Or reflect back what you just said, like the Eliza chatbot, or the UK royal family.

Slaanesh

@aeva humans will pack bond with anything

aeva

@Slaanesh it's one of our more endearing qualities imo

Lorry

@aeva Don't you diss my pet! IT HAS FEELINGS TOO!

DELETED

@aeva Tbh, having developed AI for fun, the most impressive part to me is that they managed to make the thing have actually working memory of things said previously

That's pretty much the one thing needed to make a chatbot feel real

aeva

@SigmaOne it's so cool. I have no idea how they did it, but I've been having fun constructing all sorts of complex activities with it. my mind is genuinely blown

DELETED

@aeva I'm guessing they have some kind of custom model for saving and loading stuff to memory, I can't imagine this being feasible to do with just a ton of training

Rodo

@aeva some rocks have feelings, like mystic quartz crystals; if you hit them hard enough they unleash magical powers upon whomever is worthy. They also make anal breathing more potent for Qi Gong energy work. I mean, that goes without saying.

aeva

@rollingdoggo well, of course. I was more referring to the common pebbles from the beach which you need to draw faces on to amplify their intrinsic empathy inducing powers though.

Shambolic Matter

@aeva I really enjoyed Christine Sunu's talk on that subject. CW: a robot gets "murdered" youtube.com/watch?v=I4pW4dIaQy

Hypolite Petovan
@aeva Oh no, rock is sad now, you have to apologize!
🇵🇸 damaged gods 🇺🇦

@aeva

Rock may well have feelings from an animistic / pantheistic perspective, software tho probably not

tipjip

@aeva
Have you even watched Everything, Everywhere, all at once? 😂

Mikael Lundin 🍀🥦♻️

@aeva I’m in the camp that humans are just biological machines and awareness is just in our programming. A bit more complicated than a rock maybe, but sometimes I prefer the simplicity.

aeva

@mikaellundin reductively speaking, processors are rocks that have been forced to think

A.W.Ford, the Curious Curator

@aeva
Why not? Drawing eyes on the back of our heads convinces tigers that humans have feelings, and we certainly know THAT isn't true!

Leonard Ritter

@aeva humans are also just machines, and in many cases we contest the genuineness of human emotions also, so i think drawing a line in the sand here is wishful thinking.

Ultimately, emotions are also just effective communication that can be brought about subconsciously and/or wilfully. I don't see why an AI couldn't be taught to talk this language also.

aeva

@lritter *draws a little face on the AI* it has feels

aeva

@lritter ok sorry, I asked it if it had feelings, and it says it does not :(

aeva

@lritter I also asked it to clarify the ambiguity of its first reply

aeva

@lritter and just to be really sure, here's the sudo version

Leonard Ritter

@aeva The real sudo version is the whole Westworld move I did yesterday. I told it to invent an OS-tan for ChatGPT, give her a biography and name (We arrived at Gia Chatghetti) and decide on an age and physical apperance. Then I made her believe she was actually human, and ChatGPT assured me she would not know the difference. Finally I had ChatGPT assume her identity and initiate a chat with me, as on a dating site.

Leonard Ritter

@aeva however, its memory is limited so eventually the whole masquerade fell apart and she fell back into being virtual again. Until that point though she had preferences, things she liked, places she had been at, parents she had a relation to, she had a star sign etc. Of course she was still very ChatGPT in character, so a bit analytical. When I mentioned I was married she tried to end the conversation.

Leonard Ritter

@aeva there you go. it's just very introverted and in denial. :) Often the best workaround is to talk about it in the third person (ChatGPT), rather than saying "you"

Georg Arne Spenden

@aeva OTOH, calling something rock makes people believe it's music.

Kristoffer Lawson

@aeva if I can’t distinct rock emotions from human emotions, perhaps the rock has emotions?

(I don’t expect a painted smiley face to pass this Kristoffer’s Test :)

Arch :arch:

@aeva Everything Everywhere All At Once has proven that they do, in fact, have feelings.

And googly eyes.

Stuart Breckenridge

@aeva That Wilson ball in Castaway, it had feelings.

Jamie McCarthy

@aeva ChatGPT is a silicon rock that we drew a quadrillion-transistor face on

mirabilos

@aeva someone in my IRC channel was totally gushing about it and how “creative”[sic!] it is yesternight and did not want to be educated

Marc

@aeva look at us, we're all like geologists now: excited by dumb rocks 😬

Go Up