Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Eugen Rochko

Anyone else kind of creeped out by that trend of apps that animate faces on still photographs?

24 comments
wakest ⁂

@Gargron I had just posted one like 1 minute before I saw you post this so I thought it might have been a subpost about me

Eugen Rochko

@liaizon I looked at your profile and I still don't see it

wakest ⁂

@Gargron it was in a reply but this was the one I just made. its an image I made on Artbreeder run through MyHeritage.com's Deep Nostalgia

Eugen Rochko

@liaizon Okay, you can retroactively consider it a subpost if you wish

wakest ⁂

@Gargron Gargron officially "kind of creeped out" is gonna stick with my charactor for good now. Its a badge of honor

Григорий Клюшников

They aren't a new thing, remember seeing them several years ago

Rick

@Gargron nah, the ones on old pics are super cool!

Eugen Rochko

To elaborate, to me it's because what you see is a computer model wearing a dead person's face as a mask.

And I'm convinced that if you had an actual video of the real person to compare with, their face would not move like that.

G 🇮🇹

@Gargron I don't need an actual video because I very the dead person very well... I tried it but the animation is odd

G 🇮🇹

@Gargron I don't need an actual video because I knew the dead person very well... the animation is odd

Jay

@Gargron When I animated my late fathers face, it did not move like him, and was definitely suffering from “uncanny valley” But animating late relatives I’ve never seen seemed ok to me - presumably coz I Know no better. Next step would be AI that incorporates video footage of the person when alive to “train” it how to move

Andy Lundell 🙄

@gargron The weirdest part, besides the whole concept, is the animations themselves.

They kind of just bobble their heads, cycle through a few expressions, then blink twice.

Like they're a game character that's waiting for input.

I guess they have to do that because they don't have the context to create realistic, context-dependent movements tied to what the person is doing.

Sarah "Neila" Elkins

@Gargron Yeah, it's creepy. Hits the uncanny valley without a doubt. :s

Veronically 🦄∆V

@Gargron can't wait to see what kind of use our trusted pornographers will make of this technology.

[DATA EXPUNGED]
Gabi

@Gargron My grandma just showed me her dead sister, who I've never seen, deepfaked. It was very creepy for some reason, it didnt feel right.

John Patterson

@Gargron I am too, though in a different (but related?) way to you.

To me, it creeps me out just because it likely gives you a plausible but wrong impression of having seen them move.

And it just seems disrespectful, in a way, to do that.

Devashish Babi Chattopadhyay

@Gargron Well it is very creepy especially when you see dead loved ones face moving.

Ali Fleih

@Gargron Honestly, deepfakes are much worse. The thing about MyHeritage though is that it’s easy and accessible. Anyone can upload a photo of anybody. With deepfakes, you gotta put in a lot more hard work on a solid computer.

Go Up