Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Lina

@futurebird
@ronaldtootall @hannu_ikonen

yeah LLMs aren't at all reliable for any of the use cases he proposed. ๐Ÿ™„๐Ÿ˜ฎโ€๐Ÿ’จ literally any modern word processor is more reliable for spelling/grammar checks, and the suggestion of using them for research is always nauseating.

2 comments
Lina

@futurebird
@ronaldtootall @hannu_ikonen

by portraying LLMs as a panacea, the hypemongers have successfully kneecapped a lot of people's ability to consider alternative tools that are often well known, widely used for decades, and solve the specific problem they're targeting with a 0% fail rate.

i've had to tell project managers way too many times, "no, we don't need to pay OpenAI to fuck up at doing what regex does perfectly. all we're trying to do is extract a consistently-formatted string for fucks sake."

ะจัƒั€ะพ

There are applications where AI based tools can help though.

E.g. factchecking. Sure using them to query data directly isn't the best idea (same goes for search engines btw as these only provide potential sources not answers) however AI does a pretty good job at things like text and video summarization or audio/video transcribing. It doesn't mean one should use the resulting data directly but if you need to find some relevant research it might come in handy helping to browse through lots of materials and identify those potentially interesting so you can evaluate them yourself.

IMO "AI is God" and "AI is useless crap" are two equally radically unproductive approaches. It is just a tool which is suited for some things and not so much for others.

There are applications where AI based tools can help though.

E.g. factchecking. Sure using them to query data directly isn't the best idea (same goes for search engines btw as these only provide potential sources not answers) however AI does a pretty good job at things like text and video summarization or audio/video transcribing. It doesn't mean one should use the resulting data directly but if you need to find some relevant research it might come in handy helping to browse through lots of materials...

Go Up