Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Boo Ramsey πŸ§›πŸ»β€β™‚οΈπŸ§Ÿβ€β™‚οΈπŸ‘»πŸŽƒ

If someone blocks you, they don’t owe you a reason. They don’t owe you anything. Pursuing them in other places to find out why they blocked you or to ask them to remove the block could be considered harassment. Don’t do that. Just accept it and move on.

I’ve been blocked by people I respect, and it does feel bad, but you aren’t entitled to a reason. Respect their freedom of association.

40 comments
Steve

@ramsey
I've seen a lot of people make an argument like this. As if people are only ever supposed to ask for things they're owed.

I think what you mean is that someone doesn't have the right to *Demand* something that isn't owed to them.

It's an important distinction to make.

Boo Ramsey πŸ§›πŸ»β€β™‚οΈπŸ§Ÿβ€β™‚οΈπŸ‘»πŸŽƒ

@steve I don’t think I said anything about not having the right to *ask* for something you are or are not owed. I only said they don’t owe you a reason.

M. GrΓ©goire

@ramsey @steve
I don't think an explanation is "owed" either; but I think it shows grace to give a reason before blocking someone.

Boo Ramsey πŸ§›πŸ»β€β™‚οΈπŸ§Ÿβ€β™‚οΈπŸ‘»πŸŽƒ

@mpjgregoire @steve I completely disagree. Often, I want to block someone without them knowing I blocked them. How is it graceful to tell someone I’m going to block them, especially if they’re causing me any distress (whether knowing or unknowingly)?

Steve

@ramsey @mpjgregoire
You're right, sometimes it's understandable, even reasonable to be disgraceful. But I'm not sure that makes it right.

Honestly I don't think I understand the blocking people mindset. It doesn't matter how wrong someone is, or how hurtful their words may be, I can't see myself ever blocking anyone.

I have blocked spam bots now and again. But their just bots, not people. I really don't like myself when I'm disrespectful to people; Even when they're far worse to me.

@ramsey @mpjgregoire
You're right, sometimes it's understandable, even reasonable to be disgraceful. But I'm not sure that makes it right.

Honestly I don't think I understand the blocking people mindset. It doesn't matter how wrong someone is, or how hurtful their words may be, I can't see myself ever blocking anyone.

Boo Ramsey πŸ§›πŸ»β€β™‚οΈπŸ§Ÿβ€β™‚οΈπŸ‘»πŸŽƒ

@steve @mpjgregoire How is it disrespectful to block someone? If someone causes you any form of distress, block them. Life’s too short, and not everyone deserves your attention.

M. GrΓ©goire

@ramsey
"Leave people alone when they tell you to quit it. Blocked."
"Your political opinions are appalling. Blocked."
"Stop talking about subjects you know nothing about. Blocked."

Wouldn't you rather receive such a message than a silent block? If you'd prefer such a message from another person, then wouldn't it be gracious of you to send a similar message in the appropriate circumstances?

@steve

@ramsey
"Leave people alone when they tell you to quit it. Blocked."
"Your political opinions are appalling. Blocked."
"Stop talking about subjects you know nothing about. Blocked."

Wouldn't you rather receive such a message than a silent block? If you'd prefer such a message from another person, then wouldn't it be gracious of you to send a similar message in the appropriate circumstances?

Boo Ramsey πŸ§›πŸ»β€β™‚οΈπŸ§Ÿβ€β™‚οΈπŸ‘»πŸŽƒ

@mpjgregoire @steve It does not matter to me if someone chooses to block me for any reason. Most of the time, I would probably never notice.

M. GrΓ©goire

@ramsey @steve
I just had someone block me and tell his 2000 followers to block me as well (it was regarding #uspol, mastodon.world/@tomiahonen/112 ).

It doesn't bother me that I was blocked and I appreciate his telling me why β€” though I don't think I wrote anything unreasonable or impolite in this case.

Steve

@ramsey @mpjgregoire

Ghosting someone is disrespectful.
Breaking up with them is not.

It's not the blocking.
It's the leaving them wondering, confused; That's disrespectful.

It very literally adds insult, to injury.

Sometimes there may be reasons to insult.
But they're almost always petty.

I think we should try to avoid pettiness.

Boo Ramsey πŸ§›πŸ»β€β™‚οΈπŸ§Ÿβ€β™‚οΈπŸ‘»πŸŽƒ

@steve @mpjgregoire I’m not talking about people who are in a relationship. I’m talking about strangers online.

Steve

@ramsey @mpjgregoire

Whatever the relationship, the behavior is the same.
I don't think being strangers excuses behavior.

And I didn't mean to imply the reason I don't block is out of respect. I can see how you thought that, and apologize for the mid understanding. The reason I don't block, is my belief that nothing was ever fixed with less information.

M. GrΓ©goire

@steve
No, there are definitely times it's right to block. May you be lucky enough not to experience them.

@ramsey

Eric S. Pumpkins

@ramsey I made that mistake once, and regret it. It was the only time I’d been blocked that I knew of, and it was from someone I highly respected. I should have left it alone, but didn’t.

assertchris

@ramsey I don’t see any problem with taking the approach of β€œI don’t know why this happened, but if it’s because of something I did then I’d like to make things right with you. Are you open to that?”

Boo Ramsey πŸ§›πŸ»β€β™‚οΈπŸ§Ÿβ€β™‚οΈπŸ‘»πŸŽƒ

@assertchris I don’t see anything wrong with asking that once, but if I don’t respond, then the person I blocked shouldn’t keep asking.

bob.php :veritrek_gold:

@ramsey this makes me want to make one of those motivational posters but with the text "be the reason they block you"

π‚π«π’π¦πžπƒπšπ

@ramsey Yes, but it would be nice if there was a prompt to optionally provide a reason when blocking someone, or maybe add a duration for a temporary block. #MastodonFeatureRequest

Boo Ramsey πŸ§›πŸ»β€β™‚οΈπŸ§Ÿβ€β™‚οΈπŸ‘»πŸŽƒ

@fathermcgruder Temporary block would be nice, but you’re able to leave private notes on any profile right now, so you can note your own reason for blocking someone.

A screenshot of @fathermcgruder@jorts.horse’s profile with a red arrow pointing to the β€œClick to add note” prompt (which also has a red underline drawn under it to draw attention to it).
π‚π«π’π¦πžπƒπšπ

@ramsey I meant a note for the account being blocked to read, similar to how forum mods might include a message when issuing a ban.

Boo Ramsey πŸ§›πŸ»β€β™‚οΈπŸ§Ÿβ€β™‚οΈπŸ‘»πŸŽƒ

@fathermcgruder I don’t think the account being blocked should have access to any of my notes about why they were blocked.

Boo Ramsey πŸ§›πŸ»β€β™‚οΈπŸ§Ÿβ€β™‚οΈπŸ‘»πŸŽƒ

@fathermcgruder If you want to escalate any issues with the person in question, be my guest. I’m not doing that.

Ariaflame

@ramsey @fathermcgruder Sometimes I just put them on the muted forever. I don't wish them ill, I just have no interest in seeing their posts on my feed ever again.

Jon Tan

@ramsey I agree with you. It was worrying to me when my sons told me that blocking people was perceived as either aggressive, or an L (lose) and admission of defeat in their teenage world.

They thought they had to take the abuse they should be blocking, or block and be harassed for an explanation elsewhere, and ultimately abused elsewhere, too.

It took some effort to convince them that blocking people is a self-empowering move that requires no explanation if they so decide.

Larry Garfield

@jontan @ramsey "If you can't stand the bullying, it means the bully wins" is what bullies tell their victims. It's gaslighting, pure and simple.

πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡¦ Anna Filina

@ramsey I probably blocked thousands of people by now. People have the right to feel offended by it. I don't care. My mental health is more important. I have been harassed by people I blocked before. One time, it escalated to my fearing for my physical safety and getting a lawyer involved. Don't be that person. If you get blocked, just move on. Don't dwell on it. Maybe the person was wrong in blocking you, maybe they weren't, but it's not up to you. You can survive without them in your feed.

πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡¦ Anna Filina

@ramsey For anyone who hasn't experienced anything even close to it: good for you; that doesn't change what happened to me. You can continue not blockig prople, or providing them with polite explanations as to why you block them, and you can continue thinking that to do otherwise is rude. Just don't harass people for an explanation. You aren't entitled to it.

πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡¦ Anna Filina

@ramsey Oh there was also another guy who didn't like the manner in which I shared my knowledge, so he went to harass me on every social media as he got blocked, then actually attended an event I was speaking at abroad and tried to approach me. Luckily I let my friends know in advance that the asshole lived in Berlin. They got up from the couch and he ran off. It's insane to me when someone tells me I need to be more polite to such people. This is not an isolated incident.

πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡¦ Anna Filina

@ramsey I also have friends who got contacted via social media by drunk perverts with colorful advances and other scary sh*t. I seriously envy people who had the kind of safe life where they feel like they can talk to people before blocking them, and not fear escalation or retaliation in real life.

Claudio Zizza 🦜

@afilina @ramsey Because real life has no block button it's pretty disappointing that one has to stop visiting events while those are accepted.

πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡¦ Anna Filina

@SenseException @ramsey I'm happy that it didn't close any doors for me. All these people seem to have disappeared shortly after. Even the speaker whose wife was harassing me on all social media (and who defended her actions) hasn't been seen in public for ages.

will talk for elePHPants!

@afilina @ramsey Social media to me is "screaming into the void". Expecting that everyone is actually listening to that is pretty cocky...

Expecting an explanation WHY one doesn't want to listen to my ramblings is ... a sign of delusion of grandeur?

Alex Rock

@ramsey I've been blocked by many Symfony Core contributors, this lead to me being totally expelled from the SymfonyConnect website, so it all depends on the blocking contexts, I guess.

Blocks on social networks or email is no big deal, we all do it, I do it very often too.

On websites and applications that are used for work, however, I don't agree at all, and I think it should be forbidden somehow, unless court trial says so.

Larry Garfield

@pierstoval @ramsey Private companies and organizations have right of free association to pick and choose who they do business with, except for certain explicitly legally disallowed reasons (race, sex, etc.)

Alex Rock

@Crell @ramsey I guess they do have the "right" to not do business with people that disclosed some infamous behavior of their marketing teams, indeed πŸ™ƒ

Larry Garfield

@pierstoval @ramsey If you're talking about whistleblowers, that's employment law. A completely different topic.

Dave Snowden

@ramsey if they continue to talk about after they have blocked, that’s wrong

Go Up