Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Andreas

@rysiek There's an answer on that website and it's very wish-y-wash-y unfortuantely.

The example is someone in Belgium owning 1.25M€ in addition to a house being considered "ultra-rich".

That's an interesting data point but I suspect that is *way* too low a barrier for many people.
Exceeding 1.25M€ is easily done by inheriting a house that was worth 50.000€ when it was built 60 years ago.

And people who are looking at potentially receiving at such an inheritance are going to go "hmmm, that might hit me too. Better not sign!". And I can totally understand that because in general everybody is always looking out for themselves first.

I do not understand why these initiatives are not putting out a statement such as "we consider people having liquidity of more than 5M€ to be ultra-rich and are interested in taxing these!".
That's a clear statement and the cut-off is far enough removed from the possibly-rich-enough-after-inheriting to not alienate that big part of the population.

Instead we get these non-answers covered in relative terms resulting in a lot of people going "yeah, thank. not signing...".

2 comments
viq

@ixs
So you're saying it's a pretty strong incentive to not keep the inherited house, but to somewhat quickly sell it, at not too inflated a price? 🤔
@rysiek

Andreas

@viq @rysiek Unclear. It really depends on the other laws on the books.

Some countries have laws that result in a house being inherited tax-free if one is living there or moving in within 6 months after the inheritance.
That would only incentivise you to move in there but keep it.
Does seems like a sensible rule to me.

Then there are countries where inheritance is expensive but gifting the house to a registered legal entity is free.
So you write the house over to the family trust and done. Taxfree inheritance.

What you are suggesting, being incentivised to sell the place in order to pay the inheritance taxes, that's what poor people do (or are forced to do).
Rich people do not pay inheritance tax. And the excess wealth tax is something along the same lines.

@viq @rysiek Unclear. It really depends on the other laws on the books.

Some countries have laws that result in a house being inherited tax-free if one is living there or moving in within 6 months after the inheritance.
That would only incentivise you to move in there but keep it.
Does seems like a sensible rule to me.

Go Up