Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
HyperSoop :spinny_cat_aroace: :spinny_fox_agender:

@sponsorblock

YouTube is currently experimenting with server-side ad injection

wow when/if this reaches me it might be time to break my youtube addiction and say goodbye to google

16 comments
HyperSoop :spinny_cat_aroace: :spinny_fox_agender:

@sponsorblock according to this pinned thread on uBO's subreddit, youtube devs and adblock devs are in a pretty heated fight, like, right now

HyperSoop :spinny_cat_aroace: :spinny_fox_agender:

that thread gives you an idea of the kind of overengineered obfuscated overdone mess the youtube website is

google is going way too far to temporarily inconvenience adblock users

Matthew

@soop
They stopped putting email ads in "Promotions" and are now part of normal main inbox.

Kay Ohtie

@mrblissett @soop I wonder if they're a/b testing that; email is still categorized there as well as their injected fake-email ads for me but it would not shock me for them to put the latter in main too, ugh.

HyperSoop :spinny_cat_aroace: :spinny_fox_agender:

@KayOhtie @mrblissett i feel like when it comes to potentially controversial changes corpos use a/b testing to reduce any backlash

Kay Ohtie

@soop @mrblissett they should actually listen to the backlash then cause it seems like half the time they don't

Niko :neofox_flag_nb_256: :neofox_flag_trans_256:

@KayOhtie @soop @mrblissett sadly if the testing makes a big corp more money they'll ignore all backlash and go ahead with it it seems

Kay Ohtie

@soop @sponsorblock YouTube devs or YouTube managers/execs? Wild to think they've fired any dev who thinks it's scummy but does the work anyway and finally found the pool of devs who like ads

drawnto

@KayOhtie
I am curious how this scummy. Youtube provides a service under the condition that users watch ads. They stop delivering ads seperatly and include them in the main content stream just as TV does.

I know ads can be accessibility issue. But being able to block them never was intended functionality. So where is the scum.

Alexander Sosedkin
@drawnto @KayOhtie If your Internet Service Provider bans some of the Internet resources, it stops being an Internet Service Provider becomes a subset-of-the-Internet-provider and should be liable for false advertising because it's scummy. By the same logic, if a video hosting starts serving back videos that differ from what uploaded, it stops being a video hosting.
drawnto

@hazelnot

@KayOhtie

That we can agree on. It's less scum than monarchy & feudalism right now but that's hardly a good thing.

Lana Sarah Aurelia

@drawnto @KayOhtie

Accessibility features should be a default.

Furthermore, browsing without adblockers is like sex with strangers without condoms, but for your computer.

Arik

@soop @sponsorblock

That means that there's a critical mass of people using ad-blocking to trigger YouTube into fighting them.

Ergo, there are a lot of people unhappy with watching ads on YouTube. Honestly, when I watch YouTube without an ad blocker, the experience is horrible.

Ergo, when (and if) YouTube somehow wins that fight, a large number of people will be generally unhappy with YouTube. A certain percentage of them will quit YouTube.

Apparently the math works out (or at least YouTube think that the math works out) that the number of people quitting YouTube will be lower than the number of people who keep watching ads.

I hope they're wrong.

@soop @sponsorblock

That means that there's a critical mass of people using ad-blocking to trigger YouTube into fighting them.

Ergo, there are a lot of people unhappy with watching ads on YouTube. Honestly, when I watch YouTube without an ad blocker, the experience is horrible.

Ergo, when (and if) YouTube somehow wins that fight, a large number of people will be generally unhappy with YouTube. A certain percentage of them will quit YouTube.

Nikhil 🐧

@soop @sponsorblock I got my first Serverside injected ads today 😕

HyperSoop :spinny_cat_aroace: :spinny_fox_agender:

@realestninja @sponsorblock you should try adding the filters from the pinned comment on the reddit thread i've mentioned

Go Up