Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Lu wilson

@akkartik the downside of the tadi style is that you *can't make everything* with it. some things you have to sacrifice being able to make. but the positive is that you're not dependent on any 'dependency'

in your approach, i see you still have dependencies - it's the ones you build for yourself. even though you don't use someone else's dependencies, you end up stuck with your own stack, which is also hard to support, just like a dependency. continued...

5 comments
Lu wilson

@akkartik i hope it doesn't come across harsh or anything - and the tadi approach is far from helpful or realistic in many ways. these are just the challenges i see you tackling and figuring through, and im really happy you are doing that :)

Kartik Agaram replied to Lu

@TodePond Not harsh at all! I think we're pretty close here, and it feels good to see my values reflected back to me.

Sacrificing ability to make some things -- 💯

Using easily discarded dependencies -- 💯

Building an entire stack -- more true of Mu than my later stuff.

Lately I think a lot in terms of Wardley Maps, they help me realize when I'm growing over-dependent on something. And it's led me to try to branch away from LÖVE in the direction of exaEquOS (Lua+JS) and Kaboom/Kaplay (JS).

Kartik Agaram replied to Kartik

@TodePond So I think we're entirely (?) in agreement on what we value in principle, and we're trying out different trade-offs along a shared spectrum.

Certainly this periodic concern of mine about testing is nudging me closer to your current location on the spectrum, with less custom code.

Kartik Agaram replied to Kartik

@TodePond Oh I see a disagreement. I've been gravitating towards durable software as a value, which is perhaps anti-tadi.

Depends on what "die" means to you here. I imagine "the Way" as emitting a trail of programs. Each program might be on a trajectory of ossification but still be usable long after it freezes.

Kartik Agaram replied to Kartik

@TodePond My hope/dream is that in the FoC/Merveilles/TodePond/Ink&Switch/Handmade/Mastodon nexus there is the beginnings of a scene akin to the one around Gertrude Stein's Salon in pre-war Paris: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gertrude

A scene will have inevitable disagreements. But hopefully this ferment is leading somewhere with answers.

Go Up