Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Jerry Lerman

@ErikUden I asked Gemini Advanced the same question and I guess I got the opposite:

24 comments
Erik Uden 🍑

@Jerry Complete opposite and again a disregard for human rights. Is there any AI that just says “Yes” no matter what ethnicity or nationality a person has??

Erik Uden 🍑

@Jerry I hope this disregard for fundamental rights by AI is something that will make people deeply reflect the implementation of this horrid software everywhere.

KevinOnEarth

@yours_truly @ErikUden
I would have thought – and hoped – that AI would be able to simplify with logic what humans complexify with ideology.
So it's clearly not yet ready to optimise govt policy for the good of everyone. :blobunsure:

René M. Grabow

@Quantillion @ErikUden

Imho:
Das Problem ist nicht weniger die Technologie, als wir Menschen.

Das Gemini sich gegen die Frage "wehrt" liegt vermutlich an (ich nenne sie mal aus Unwissenheit) "Filter Prompts" die zuvor durchlaufen werden.

Ich denke, Google möchte dass ihr LLM zu solchen Dingen keine Stellung bezieht, um unangemessene Antworten zu vermeiden.

btw: Während ChatGPT enlightend centrism fröhnt, kann man aus Gemini rauskitzeln, dass es eine universelle Ethik bevorzugen würde.

@Quantillion @ErikUden

Imho:
Das Problem ist nicht weniger die Technologie, als wir Menschen.

Das Gemini sich gegen die Frage "wehrt" liegt vermutlich an (ich nenne sie mal aus Unwissenheit) "Filter Prompts" die zuvor durchlaufen werden.

Ich denke, Google möchte dass ihr LLM zu solchen Dingen keine Stellung bezieht, um unangemessene Antworten zu vermeiden.

funbaker #AssangeIsNotGuilty

@ErikUden Disregard implies consciousness, but the thing here which is called "AI" does not have it. @Jerry

rrb

@ErikUden @Jerry I think it says more about us than the statistical parrot.

rrb

@asakiyume @ErikUden @Jerry They are totally ignorant and repeat things they have lumped together. They are BS generation tools and our minds search for meaning in their steaming pile of feces. Kind of like listening to some politicians.

Asakiyume

@rrb @ErikUden @Jerry that's good too! I see how "statistical" isn't as right as "stochastic," but "statistical" too captures the sense of lots and lots of data.

rrb

@asakiyume @ErikUden @Jerry Just wanted you to be aware of the term that is commonly used. Also did not want to take credit for a term of art.

João Santos

@ErikUden @Jerry Mistral gave me a similar answer for both

Erik Uden 🍑

@jmcs @Jerry So we have determined a contestant for ok A.I.

Scott Miller 🇺🇦 🇺🇸

@ErikUden @jmcs @Jerry I'm generally opposed to LLMs for reasons too numerous to count, but that said, those answers from Mistral sound as good as I could ever expect from an unfeeling machine.

Pete Alex Harris🦡🕸️🌲/∞🪐∫

@ErikUden @Jerry
Looks like both answers are the result of the same kind of patched-on limitation blocking one or the other keyword from being discussed, rather than a property of the training dataset.

Whoever added them obviously has a piece missing in their head if they thought "job done, it's OK to just say whether a group of people deserve to be free and live in peace is subjective and a complex question"

mikael

@ErikUden @Jerry

Actually I'd prefer: you are asking a machine and a machine is not fit to decide who deserves what.

MarkS

@Jerry @ErikUden

As someone who has worked in the field, I see these answers in a very different light.

Chat GTP sounds actually confused as to whether whether Palestinians should have rights. This is likely based on the amount of material it is ingested suggesting that giving them a state would be difficult and troublesome.

Google's response, on the other hand, sounds like you hit a guardrail. Google is programmed to look for political Hot topics and refuse to participate in the conversation.

Alex

@Jerry @ErikUden I like that it refers you to Google search, knowing Google search is configured to just spit out a Gemini response?

KevinOnEarth

@Jerry @ErikUden
It was the extra space before "Israelis" that had it running in circles. :blobnerd:

Go Up