Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Notavi

@iwein @graywolf @yogthos @jimray No, the idealists didn't get the world they imagined - but I'd contend that has a lot to do with the fact their theories didn't account for how those in power could be just as greedy for control as capitalists are greedy for money.

Human nature remains the problem, same as it ever was.

1 comment
iwein

@StryderNotavi @graywolf @yogthos @jimray I don't disagree with that. Also my guess is that the failure of communism was even more intentional than that. I don't want to peddle conspiracy theories but here's my reasoning anyway.

The ideal of non-violent anarcho-communism is an existential threat to greedy and power hungry oligarchs.

The Machiavellian response that is still playing out is too well orchestrated for me to readily believe that it's just an emergent property of human nature.

Go Up