@dansup I think I like text?

@dansup Icones.

@dansup icons, they are generally more universal.

@dansup Text is easier to figure out — new-to-online people might not know what the icons mean

@dansup the reply button seems weird. English is left justified, so you want replies to the left, forwards to the right

@dansup I think both are awful! Put a goddamn border and some depth on those buttons, for fuck's sake!

@dansup
Icons, please

@dansup No, I'd rather the text

@dansup Why not offer an option? That way the user can decide. 😉

@dansup From an accessibility perspective, both? Icons are not always recognizable

@dansup personally I like the text. The text option seems like it has bigger touch targets.

The icons don't seem to be from the same design language which is definitely part of why I'm not looking the icon option as much

@dansup text

@dansup I think the text looks better, although if you go with icons, the reply button should be pointing to the left.

@dansup I use text + icon for the main actions. Icons can be used elsewhere in the UI, to go next to number of shares for example. I design for schools and find that icons alone are often misunderstood (and ignored as a result) 🤪

@dansup I agree, the icons look better and they are intuitive.

@dansup https://2015-2020.mattwilcox.net/musing/the-ineffectiveness-of-icons.html

@dansup Maybe you could make it adjustable in the profile what the user wants to see. And the initial decision would be made during onboarding.😅

@dansup Both, but also please right align them so they’re consistently positioned on each comment