Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
5 posts total
William Pietri

Back on my theme of trying to understand why LLMs have taken off:

Puzzle piece 1: LLMs are, in Frankfurt's sense of the term, bullshit machines. To him, a core component of bullshit is "indifference to how things really are".

Puzzle piece 2: Managerialism, a dominant business philosophy, holds that managers are universal. They can manage anything without regard to the topic. Without truly learning "how things really are".

Puzzle piece 3: On average, the larger the company the higher the density of bullshit. CEO statements, managerial presentations up and down, customer comms, etc. Related is the density of office politics, careerism, etc.

So putting this together, it seems like our corporate hierarchies have a hard time understanding the weak point of LLMs because standard corporate culture has the same weak point: valuing many other things over the truth.

Back on my theme of trying to understand why LLMs have taken off:

Puzzle piece 1: LLMs are, in Frankfurt's sense of the term, bullshit machines. To him, a core component of bullshit is "indifference to how things really are".

Puzzle piece 2: Managerialism, a dominant business philosophy, holds that managers are universal. They can manage anything without regard to the topic. Without truly learning "how things really are".

Show previous comments
Richard W. Woodley NO THREADS πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦πŸŒΉπŸš΄β€β™‚οΈπŸ“· πŸ—ΊοΈ

@williampietri

And yet people still worship #capitalism and believe it leads to rational decisions because everyone acts in their own self interest.

Eli the Bearded

@williampietri

Two other things:

Technology that reduces need for specialized knowledge or skills tends to get widely embraced.

The bullshit LLM AI produces is bad at details but good at "executive summary" and high-level hand-wavy spew of the c-suite.

William Pietri

This is glorious.The best time to burn a bridge is when you never, ever want to cross it again. #genai (Edit: This is a notice explaining why somebody is shutting down a long-running project to measure word frequencies.) github.com/rspeer/wordfreq/blo

Show previous comments
Aaron

@williampietri That was a great, but honestly heartbreaking, read.

If there's anything I like it's the fact that "slop" seems to be sticking as the name for what GenAI produces.

William Pietri

@marcan Thanks! Sounds like this was painful to learn, so I especially appreciate the cogent summary.

William Pietri

This, via @davidgerard, is a #bluesky gobsmacker.

First there's the breathtaking confidence that this this exciting AI thing will solve the problem. As if Twitter didn't have literally hundreds of ML engineers working on this for years. YEARS.

Then there's the notion that you could possibly create AI magic without doing enough of the manual work to really understand it. Nope!

Third, there's apparently a belief that a magic technical solution exists to social problems that are so complex that they're demoralizing and hard to deal with.

Fourth, I see no recognition that they should have had at least some starter solutions before letting users on at all.

Lastly, there's the lack of recognition that anti-abuse work, hard though it is, is not nearly as hard as dealing with the abuse.

This, via @davidgerard, is a #bluesky gobsmacker.

First there's the breathtaking confidence that this this exciting AI thing will solve the problem. As if Twitter didn't have literally hundreds of ML engineers working on this for years. YEARS.

Then there's the notion that you could possibly create AI magic without doing enough of the manual work to really understand it. Nope!

William Pietri

As an aside, I'm clearly going to have to write something up about Mastodon's handling of abuse, which I need to investigate properly. Does anybody have resources they like? People to talk to? Incidents to examine?

Tired Bunny :bunhdcomfysleep:

@williampietri @davidgerard

Image shows post from Jay @jay.bsky.team which says:

building long-terms solutions to moderation like better community tooling and customized Al models = energizing and fun work

jumping in to individually investigate and adjudicate cases of bad behavior in contexts we don’t fully understand = demoralizing and stressful work

Go Up