Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Garrit 🏡🛠️

Let's try something: #RoastMySite!

I want to hear your honest feedback, (not so) constructive criticism, funny bug reports and savage burns. 🔥

Got your own site? I'll roast it!

garrit.xyz/posts/2023-12-12-ro

This is post 093 of #100DaysToOffload.

9 comments
shellsharks

@garritfra Not sure if this is an appropriate roast format but here’s some thoughts after perusing your site…

—“Roasts”—
- You don’t need “(ActivityPub)” next to Mastodon, it kinda goes without saying =).
- Your footer is aggressive - “Links of Interest” and “Elsewhere” could either be condensed or have their own dedicated page.
- Remove Twitter from your social icons, it’s dead.
- Your digital /resume is… hard to parse. Also, just call it a “resume” - not a “CV” (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curricul)

—Likes—
- I like the /todo page with aspirational projects (bonus points for having a “roadmap” list)
- Dark theme is nice
- Haven’t done the flag hunt yet but I love that idea. Have been considering it for a while myself. I have a “CTF” of sorts built into my site main logo.
- +10 for having an RSS feed
- I too want to build a Blogroll. Nice!
- Random post feature is fun
- Snow on the home page is whimsical. I like whimsy.

—Needs—
A list of things I think you could add to your site to level up…

- Dedicated /about page
- Humans.txt page (humanstxt.org)
- Search functionality
- /uses page (example: shellsharks.com/uses)
- Webfinger config (if you haven’t already done this - blog.netnerds.net/2022/11/alia)

Roast mine if you want too! infosec.exchange/@shellsharks/

@garritfra Not sure if this is an appropriate roast format but here’s some thoughts after perusing your site…

—“Roasts”—
- You don’t need “(ActivityPub)” next to Mastodon, it kinda goes without saying =).
- Your footer is aggressive - “Links of Interest” and “Elsewhere” could either be condensed or have their own dedicated page.
- Remove Twitter from your social icons, it’s dead.
- Your digital /resume is… hard to parse. Also, just call it a “resume” - not a “CV” (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curricul

Garrit 🏡🛠️

@shellsharks wow, that's detailed! Thanks for all your amazing feedback! I'll leave a roast in your original post. Seems like you already had the same idea! ;)

Paweł Grzybek

@garritfra

1. A skip link would be a nice addition and a massive improvement for accessibility.
2. I'm not sure if I like the "✨ Random Post ✨" title of a blog page—it may imply that the posts below are randomized, but they are not.
3. I'm not a big fan of these social icons under every article. I am a big fan of the Web Share API for things like this.

Other than that, I can find millions of things I love about your website!

Your round!
pawelgrzybek.com

@garritfra

1. A skip link would be a nice addition and a massive improvement for accessibility.
2. I'm not sure if I like the "✨ Random Post ✨" title of a blog page—it may imply that the posts below are randomized, but they are not.
3. I'm not a big fan of these social icons under every article. I am a big fan of the Web Share API for things like this.

Garrit 🏡🛠️

@pawelgrzybek oh wow, I never thought about the web share API!

What do you mean by "Skip link"?

Regarding your site: the redundant whitespace in "... Netlify ." is about the only flaw I can find. Your site is perfect!!

Paweł Grzybek

@garritfra I think Web Share API is so great! A single button to rule them all :)

Speaking of skip links, look at this: webaim.org/techniques/skipnav/

Good spot with extra space on my website! Thanks a ton!

Daniel, pined-lizard edition

@garritfra Imagine bothering to post to your own website 93 times 🔥🔥🔥

/s

Congrats: 93 is 93 more than I have done! I really should bother myself.... 😅

Konstantin Tutsch

@garritfra Your site is pretty good, but …

- you should underline your links! thoughts.jatan.space/p/colored
- it feels a bit monotonous. You could add a few emojis, but this is of course a matter of taste

Would also appreciate a roast of my site 😄

Garrit 🏡🛠️

@konstantin thanks for the feedback! I really should start underlining my links...

Regarding your site:

* Looks very consistent. Nice work!
* The "More..." page is neatly organized. I might have to steal that layout. :)
* The favicon is awesome.
* No dark theme!! (darktheme.club/)
* A bit too many emojis for my taste. But as you said, that's a matter of preference.

Konstantin Tutsch

@garritfra Thank you, but I have a dark theme with a `@media` query (konstantintutsch.com/assets/cs).

I'll look into why it isn't working anymore 🤔

Go Up