Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Graham Cluley

I'm thinking of blocking access to content on my site to anyone not running an ad blocker.

Thoughts?

We noticed you still haven't installed an ad blocker. By turning one on your internet browsing will be a heck lot safer, and it can help stop advertisers tracking you online.
32 comments
Ain Tohvri

@gcluley considering that most Ad and Malware detectors are a malware themselves, probably not a good idea.

BrianKrebs

@gcluley My problem with ad blockers is they are all or nothing. None of them consider whether ads are third-party or in-house, or indicate that to users. As a result, very, very few users who rely on ad blockers ever allow ads on any sites, even those that strictly observe same-origin policies about ads.

Charlie Stross

@briankrebs But almost nobody does in-house ads any more—advertisers go via the big ad exchanges because that's how to get placed of lots of sites.

masukomi

@cstross @briankrebs to build on what Charlie said, for the handful of remaining sites that are in-house ads AND don't assault you with 50,000 ads per page you can just disable the blocker on that site.

I did that for daringfireball.net/ because he's not a jerk about it and he wasn't using one of the major ad networks (at least in the past dunno about now).

BrianKrebs

@masukomi @cstross KrebsOnSecurity hasn't run third-party ads in over a decade, but a huge percentage of my regular readers block any in-house ads on my site.

waldi

@briankrebs

Do you have an example of such a page? And how can you be sure they don't just act as proxy?

@gcluley

André Koot

@gcluley the incentive would be clear if you add a lot of (blockable) ads to your site.

Matt Hardy

@gcluley Much as I like it, it's technically an ad. Luckily as I run an ad blocker I wouldn't see it.

Tor Vigesdal

@gcluley would you detect if they have dns and firewall filters in place to identify and block badness rather than an add on that can see and modify everything? #pihole

Ian Bradbury

@gcluley - personally I don’t mind a few ads. If only I could be served an Ad without the tracking. 🤷‍♂️

ghostly nano :nanoBlobOwO:
@gcluley would suck for most mobile users, but otherwise awesome
Emily C Taylor

@gcluley funny and helpful too 😃​ And also, minor typo, you're missing a couple words in there I think ("heck of a lot safer") 😉​

Ridley Kemp

@gcluley I just use the reminder plugin on Wordpress. I can't speak to the effectiveness as I have no traffic, but I think it's a good idea.

VessOnSecurity

@gcluley Great idea for the cyber security awareness month.

Éibhear 🔭

@gcluley As adblockers get better and better at avoiding detection, your site will encounter more and more false positives, turning away many who want to draw inspiration from your thoughts.

Oh! the readers you will lose. Oh! the loss of such a muse!

Quixoticgeek

@gcluley only thought is some people will be using company machines which restricts the installation of such tools.

Ben Sizer

@gcluley I block 3rd party cookies and anything known to be tracking, but I don’t want to blanket-block all ads. Things have to be paid for and I want sites to see that locally-served and privacy-respecting ads are an option.

Matt Round

@gcluley The snag is, the only robust way to detect an adblocker is by trying to load an actual ad
(I did have a sloth on the home page of my site that congratulated adblocker users, but it became increasingly difficult to detect)

Efi (nap pet) 🦊💤

@gcluley not every device -can- run an ad blocker, mind you

Pax Ahimsa Gethen

@gcluley

I don't use ad blockers, but I use Firefox with its default security settings. This apparently causes many sites to *think* I'm running an ad blocker, based on the alerts I've been getting from them.

Go Up