Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
8 comments
Zeeshan Ali Khan :rust:

@jele @mattcen not the same thing. git is distributed at its core. Moving your projects away from GH is not only possible, it's trivial (unless you move issues, labels and PRs too but that's also very much possible through scripts)

Jele

@zeenix
Same level of importance regarding open-everything
@mattcen

Zeeshan Ali Khan :rust:

@jele @mattcen Not sure that was the main message. I understood the main message was not to get your community chat locked in with a company.

Jele

@zeenix
Ah.
I think it is allowed to widen the conversation with an answer 🫢😄
@mattcen

Jele

@zeenix
Don't get your project locked in with MS (that is a bad company)....
No?
I do not get your point 🤷
@mattcen

Zeeshan Ali Khan :rust:

@jele @mattcen As I explained, it's not at all "locked". You can exit anytime and the main part of that exit is super trivial.

Matt Cengia

@zeenix @jele OK, so GitHub has its issues too (proprietary tool, owned by Microsoft), but I'm *less* focussed on that in this particular instance; at least with GitHub, I can see discussion in GitHub issues and obtain code without needing an account. That's not the case with Discord.
As mentioned, there are also plenty of platforms (e.g. Gitea, Forgejo, GitLab etc) that make it trivial to use GitHub's API to import your repo *and* its Issues and PRs. It's not perfect, but at least it's not *quite* as closed as Discord is.

But also, yes, if you can use an open-source software forge, that's great too. The downside of that though, is that people need to currently create accounts on each individual forge to contribute, whereas (for better or worse) GitHub accounts are relatively ubiquitous). Once forges like @forgejo make more progress on federation (forgejo.org/faq/#is-there-a-ro), hopefully this will reduce friction there.

@zeenix @jele OK, so GitHub has its issues too (proprietary tool, owned by Microsoft), but I'm *less* focussed on that in this particular instance; at least with GitHub, I can see discussion in GitHub issues and obtain code without needing an account. That's not the case with Discord.
As mentioned, there are also plenty of platforms (e.g. Gitea, Forgejo, GitLab etc) that make it trivial to use GitHub's API to import your repo *and* its Issues and PRs. It's not perfect, but at least it's not *quite*...

Jele

@mattcen @zeenix @forgejo
Seems like there is always a reason why WhatWeUse ist less bad.
And maybe "open" ist not the same here and there... :-)

Go Up