Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Oliphant

"It's not as polished, though"

Of course it's not.

Kbin and Mastodon are spit and bubble gum, MacGuyver in a closet hacking out a working solution whereas the big names have development budgets counted in millions of dollars.

This has been the hardest thing to explain to people. Yes, there's the case where a lot of features probably should have been prioritized (in retrospect) but it's not a failing of the platform that it wasn't available with full feature parity to a company that spends millions of dollars a year developing and enhancing their website and spreading the load across a large server infrastructure, with hundreds (literally hundreds) of employees who do nothing but write code. For a living. Full time.

The 'in our spare time, after our day job' volunteer DIY army has done amazing shit here in the Fediverse, but (in my opinion) you come off like a bit of a dick when you ask why the volunteer-led hobby software doesn't have the hot shit features of a bigger platform.

It's fine to recognize the shortcomings of the software, but just realize it comes with certain tradeoffs.

For instance, you know something else we don't have here?

The rights to sell all your data or charge you for API access.

5 comments
Oliphant

Also, I don't think anyone predicted all the big social media platforms would fall the fuck apart this quickly.

Fediverse platforms weren't entirely "ready" because there was no big warning sign before the tree trunk made a loud 'crack' sound and the beast started falling.

Oliphant

I just find this space fundamentally optimistic.

A network of people willingly federating--and importantly setting firm boundaries of what is acceptable behavior--which reflects the real world better than anything else ever has.

And unlike every other place we didn't start out in a deficit to the tune of millions of dollars that has to be repaid to someone who owns us--forcing us to build monetization into the platform.

We run on donations, kids.

MHowell

@oliphant
And here is how the Fediverse standardizes:

Matt

@MHowell @oliphant Right, but the Fediverse platforms are not competing with each other, they're standards that can actually co-exist and everyone still communicates with each other, and each additional platform is more options for peoples' use cases in a different way than that comic refers to.

Kevin Hughes 🐝

@oliphant some of this reminds me of years of using FOSS software. The majority of people, even the "tech savvy" still use MS and Apple systems every day because of the polish and convenience... but the amount of people coming over to the FOSS side is more than enough to make a good enough place to live, we don't need everyone over here.

Go Up