Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Charlie Stross

Implicit corollary: "work makes you free".

Tell me that's not saying the quiet part loud.

3 comments
Robert Rothenburg

@cstross

“That's libertarians for you — anarchists who want police protection from their slaves.”

-Kim Stanley Robinson

Tom Ritchford

@rrwo @cstross I laughed, but an anarchist should be completely against slavery in every form.

The huge difference between anarchists and libertarians is that a libertarian believes that the desires of the individual always take priority over the needs of society, so for example my desire to own a gun would always trump society's need not to have their children shot to death.

Charlie Stross

@TomSwirly @rrwo There's a whole thread of US conservative thought (I won't dignify it with the label "philosophy") that starts by asking "if I am a sovereign individual, do I have the right to sell my kidney? Okay, how about the right to sell myself?" And does a deep dive into concluding that yes, slavery *is* compatible with libertarianism (because property rights are the ONLY rights). Then they throw away the diving board of logic and out themselves as slavery stans. It gets very ugly, fast.

Go Up