Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Johannes Ernst

"The Three-Legged Stool: A Manifesto for a Smaller, Denser Internet". By @ethanz et al.
publicinfrastructure.org/2023/

I very much agree, except that I don't believe it should be a "loyal client" -- a client is a client of somebody else, like somebody else's server, and that's a road we know doesn't lead to something very good. I want my own loyal server instead.

3 comments
Ethan Zuckerman

@J12t I understand, and the idea of the loyal server is very much at the heart of most fediverse theories. I just don't think it works for most users. I think control over clients is something most users understand, which is why we're focused there.

Johannes Ernst

@ethanz You think "loyal server [doesn't] work for most users" because ...?

E.g. I'm writing this from social.coop, where I'm a voting member like everybody else, I don't have to own or maintain the server, but there is no incentive for anybody to make it non-loyal.

Ethan Zuckerman

@J12t But that’s not the problem we are trying to solve. I love social.coop and would love to see more experiments. But we are trying to let people read from Twitter, Mastodon and Reddit using the same tool and sorting results based on their personal criteria. That’s better done at the edge of the network, aka a client.

Go Up