Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Sheril Kirshenbaum

Stressed #plants ‘cry’ — and some animals can probably hear them

Fascinating new research using microphones captured ultrasonic crackles from plants that are water-deprived or injured. nature.com/articles/d41586-023 #nature #science

12 comments
Loukas Christodoulou

@Sheril This seems like a misleading title. The article says these are just the noises produced by plant stems drying out.

bearhugger

@Sheril So sad 😞 I wish there was an app which translates what my plant says.

Jason Nickel

@bearhugger @Sheril My plants usually say "Please stop! I'm drowning!"

bearhugger

@JasonNickel @Sheril Mine gotta be telling me to stop talking to them. At least for 30 minutes… Everyday! 🤡

Spiricom

@Sheril an updated version of the co-hearer.

René M. Grabow

@Sheril

> "Stressed plants ‘cry’ — and some animals can probably hear them"

I think this headline or "narrative" is misleading.

I am very sure that stones would also cry out if they were watered and then left to die of thirst. Especially the more porous ones. The coarser the pores, the deeper the sound will be.

Because of such "Walt Disney" attributions superstition and a wrong world view could form.

btw: the foam on top of my coffee is crying right now

Seb

@Sheril Animals strike curious poses.
This is what it sounds like #whenplantscry

LaurelEH

@Sheril When I had my house and a greenhouse I used to play Beethoven and Bach to the plants in the gh to keep them happy. Pretty sure it worked. It kept the gardener happy anyway.

Paul

@Sheril Sounds like an episode of Tales of the Unexpected from the early 80s. imdb.com/title/tt0717507/

Jayarava

@Sheril You know what else makes the same sounds? Rivers, rain, and waves: literally anywhere that air bubbles form in water and collapse.

If you want more clickbait, however, then you may rightly claim that stressing a river by trying to divert the water, causes it to make *more* sounds. Which must be significant, right? 🙄

Leigh Silvester

@Sheril
I was very sceptical about the interpretation of this report.

This is a physical response to dehydration manifesting as popping air bubbles.

A 'cry' can only be considered as such if other plants have a mechanism to receive it and act on it. AFAIK plants do not have any audio receptors.

My knees crack when I stand up. Is that a cry?

Go Up