Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Jonas Wisser

@mcc You know, I already knew Roko's Basilisk was stupid, but for some reason it never occurred to me before now that it's just self-proclaimed rationalists reinventing God and Hell the hard way.

7 comments
mcc

@jwisser The way I first learned about Bayesian reasoning was in the evolution-vs-intelligent-design-arguments Usenet group. Most of the laziest proofs of the existence of God by internet theists leveraged Bayes' theorem, and could be most easily punctured with the sentence "you selected bad priors". Now a couple decades pass and people who know about Bayes' theorem but not theology are re-inventing "God" from first principles for different reasons, but with very similar bad priors

Luci for dyeing

@mcc @jwisser apparently elon musk and grimes met because they both made roko’s basilisk jokes on twitter

kinda feelin like there’s a roko’s basilisk joke in that somewhere

Rob Hafner :verified_flashing:

@jwisser @mcc oh oh this also applies to the "we're a simulation" people too!

A higher power (literally from a higher dimension) created us in their image, as above so below, and all the other religious fun but with math!

mcc

@tedivm @jwisser right. You can make a probabilistic argument we are almost certainly in a simulation by simply defining a sufficiently arbitrary ensemble

The Banished Dragon Alephwyr

@jwisser @mcc The two concepts don't even make rational sense to conjoin.

Jesse Morris

@jwisser @mcc It’s dumber than that though because instead of an implausible threat of actually going to hell the threat is that an implausible AI will think about you going to hell

Go Up