Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
jwz

Apple Has Begun Scanning Your Local Image Files Without Consent.

Jeffrey Paul: Imagine my surprise when browsing these images in the Finder, Little Snitch told me that macOS is now connecting to Apple APIs via a program named mediaanalysisd (Media...
jwz.org/b/yj9E

15 comments
Jason Petersen (he)

@jwz just reposting disproven theories days after other users have done the work to disprove them?

jwz

@jason You know, it's possible that you know something that I don't, but I guess I'll never know, because you sound like a prick and I'm blocking you now. *plonk*

acb

@jwz It looks like mediaanalysisd is an on-device image classifier used with local search, and the Apple API calls are empty and were a bug, which has now been fixed.

jwz

@acb I witnessed this process phoning home on me yesterday (fully updated system) so "has now been fixed" is very much [citation needed]

Elliot Shank

@jwz These folks have had a look at it: defcon.social/@mysk/1097353190

Supposedly, the behavior does not exist in the new macOS version released yesterday.

NotHelpfulUntilIAm🥤 🌛 🗄️

@jwz Well without what else? Consent is for people with power. We are not such.

Endareth

@jwz @daedalus Nope, that was a bug (and never actually did anything other than make an empty connection request): defcon.social/@mysk/1097409189

Ale Muñoz

@jwz you probably want to read this article, if you haven’t already eclecticlight.co/2023/01/18/is

I think it does a good job of explaining what is happening (and why) under the hood, and ways to disable the behavior if you are not convinced anyway.

Hope it helps!

Orestis Markou

@jwz @tartley TLDR; it was an empty call. A bug, now fixed.

jwz

@orestis @tartley You people are just *shockingly* credulous about Apple. You'd have to see Tim Cook actually holding a bloody chainsaw before you wouldn't say "nothing to see here".

Orestis Markou

@jwz @tartley I don’t appreciate the tone. Having said that, you might be right. There’s not much choice in the consumer space, so you have to choose the lesser evil. Given you found the original behavior, perhaps worth validating if the behavior persists after the upgrade?

jwz

@orestis @tartley Well if you don't appreciate the tone, I'd recommend unfollowing me. But just because a black box that phoned home yesterday doesn't phone home tomorrow.... Let's say that does little to increase my level of trust. (And I didn't find the original behavior. I did however also observe it.)

Orestis Markou

@jwz @tartley it was the “you people” bit, sorry if I was harsh. Anyway, I didn’t want to get into this debate, just wanted to point out something. Have a nice day.

Go Up