Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Antoine-Frédéric Raquin

I’ve started a French-speaking blog on https://afr.pm, using #WriteAs (which I highly recommend), but for now it’s empty.

I’m currently working on the way people use social media. How can social media bring happiness to people, how can they bring depression, compulsive behaviours, normalization of harmful relationships?

It also federates via ActivityPub, as @blog@afr.pm. Because https://write.as is awesome I guess?

I kinda love #Smithereens at the moment. I think I ~may~ push some of my friends to use it, not because of principles, but because it’s so peaceful and pleasant.

There are two ways to approach #SocialMedia: the first one is that of rational actions in finality, and the second one is one that of rational actions in values. According to #Boudon (building his theory atop of Max #Weber), an action rational in values is how people avoid unwanted aggregation effects: for example, we vote because if nobody votes, there’s no State at all [1].

Calling out social media in terms of #BigData, advertising, and dystopian futures boils down to principles: individual actions to avoid harmful collective aggregation effects; and people using social media to cope with social isolation are probably in a bad position to lecture others about principles. Calling out social media from the point of view of a rational action in values kinda misses the point, IMO, of user manipulation, and of the side-effects of treating a microblog (which is, like any blog, an iteration of the concept of marketplace of ideas) as a space to maintain deep long-term relationships and not, conversely, a place where one would consume files and database entries abstracted from the identities of their authors. The list of hamful side effects of microblog could go on, and for now I’d rather focus on saving people from what I’ve lived on #Twitter: holes in my brain, literally.

[1] And unlike what some anarchists seem to think, merely erasing the State without replacing it by another principle of deciding and enforcing collective rules isn’t anarchy, it’s chaos. You don’t catch up on 5 years spent slacking off by abstaining from voting (and also you don’t become an anarchist if you haven’t read them, but that’s derailing from the current topic).

5 comments
Григорий Клюшников

The idea with Smithereen is to basically let people who already know each other IRL communicate with each other. Without a loud TV in the background and without merchants constantly pulling them aside to sell something. That's the atmosphere of the old VKontakte.

Btw you can use a subset of HTML for text formatting. And hashtags aren't supported because there's no global search and I don't want a half-baked thing like Mastodon has.

Antoine-Frédéric Raquin

Hi, indeed, I wasn’t sure hashtags would work, so it was worth testing. Thanks again for developing Smithereens; I’d like to help you but I’m not a developer… (I may help to translate the UI in French though, I’ll have plenty of time in the next weeks.)

Did you read this thread from @pluralistic@mamot.fr? It talks about Facebook, "natural monopolies", and switching costs: https://mamot.fr/@pluralistic/106291052294150351

Григорий Клюшников

Antoine-Frédéric, now I did, and he's right, as usual. Adversarial interoperability is a beautiful thing. I'm thinking about allowing people to import their data from VK and Facebook in here. That would already go a long way. The unsolved problem, however, is the interoperability part itself. As in, how could we make it such that you could be using Smithereen, while still communicating with your friends on Facebook? They absolutely won't let that happen, even if I reverse engineer the app API or mimic a browser. They'll say that this puts people's accounts in danger or some other bullshit like that.

Antoine-Frédéric, now I did, and he's right, as usual. Adversarial interoperability is a beautiful thing. I'm thinking about allowing people to import their data from VK and Facebook in here. That would already go a long way. The unsolved problem, however, is the interoperability part itself. As in, how could we make it such that you could be using Smithereen, while still communicating with your friends on Facebook? They absolutely won't let that happen, even if I reverse engineer the app API or...

Antoine-Frédéric Raquin

Григорий, I’m sorry I haven’t replied earlier, because I was drowning in finals.

I don’t know if the new European #DSA law answers to your question? I’ve told @sl007@mastodon.social I’d document myself about it, but I still haven’t had the time yet.

Sebastian Lasse, redaktor.me

@af @grishka

Yes. It would.
Facebook is blackmailing the EU again like they did before, theguardian.com/technology/202
but that doesn't matter.
At the moment Facebook has “secret” talks with WTO in Geneva, anyway:
My mission is to build a good lobby for ActivityPub and again I want to emphasize that EU Tech Lea and Head of Unit “wants to learn about ActivityPub” which makes me happy.
En route via Fribourg to Strasbourg.

Go Up