Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Darius Kazemi

Whoa, cool blog post summarizing a bunch of available studies on quote tweeting behavior -- research that I was unaware existed!

absolutelymaybe.plos.org/2023/

No silver bullets that will end any debates here but, you know, here's some data at least

7 comments
Darius Kazemi

(saw this via @rauchway who I did not want to tag in the original post because I expect it might get boosted a bunch and then he would get CC'ed into a bunch of conversation he did not sign up for)

Mark Bessey

@darius it's been very interesting to me, as someone who's in the safest possible online demographic, to see how different marginalized/vulnerable groups feel about quote-tweets.

There's a real spectrum of responses, from "quote-retweets are how we add important context to all the shit we're subjected to every day" to "quote-retweets are how harassers target their victims".

I do wonder whether opt-in quote-posts will address some of the concerns.

L P

@darius This is good stuff. I miss QTs since leaving Twitter. I feel that replies are a conversation with the OP, while QTs are a conversation with one’s followers.

J. Nathan Matias 🦣

@darius Grateful to Hilda for this! Could you ever see instances using data and experiments to inform design decisions?

Drew Harry

@darius @natematias be careful what you wish for.

One foundational issue: the basic assumption is “the product launch is the treatment and the effects represent the term effect of the product.”

In fact, you are measuring the entire launch condition, product adoption, enrollment method, marketing plan, and product infra for experiment duration.

As a result, hard to draw conclusions without a lot of care.

dawnfry

@darius
This post itself is a workaround of the quote-toot, Mastodon style. What real difference is there between giving an opinion and dropping a link inside the toot, and quote tooting? I personally don’t think creating one less step will make a significant difference.

I do, on other platforms, use this form for quoting in order to summarize the main points (or quote them) and to add any criticism of the article. Especially criticism when it comes to logic failures, irresponsible reporting, or to point out biases in news articles.

Any message can be delivered with this change in the media capability, and it’s the message - not the media form, that can be problematic. If this form is harder to moderate, then we need better moderation tools produced (and perhaps a pause for this to be developed), but not restrictions on the method of expression. Especially as this particular form is heavily used by minority communities.

@darius
This post itself is a workaround of the quote-toot, Mastodon style. What real difference is there between giving an opinion and dropping a link inside the toot, and quote tooting? I personally don’t think creating one less step will make a significant difference.

I do, on other platforms, use this form for quoting in order to summarize the main points (or quote them) and to add any criticism of the article. Especially criticism when it comes to logic failures, irresponsible reporting, or...

Go Up