Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Johanna Janiszewski

@Natasha_Jay I studied landscape architecture and was taught that if a desire path is necessary, the architectural design was bad to begin with.

5 comments
Gilbert Pilz

@JohannaMakesGames @Natasha_Jay That assumes that the architects had perfect knowledge of where everyone was coming from and going to before they started their design. Even if such a thing were possible, it doesn't account for future changes in where people are coming from and going to. A better model is to admit that your knowledge is imperfect and plan to iteratively accommodate new desire paths as they appear.

EQ

@gpilz @JohannaMakesGames @Natasha_Jay

Or you could do like Umeå and just ignore them even after they become two-lane desirepaths. They even remade the park and grass. The desirepath ofcourse reformed immediately.

Love the comic, always thought this was how it worked :)

Autumn photo of a grass field. Straight ahead a path forms where people have taken the shorter route over the grass. Over the years the path has turned two-way since a lot of people walk and bike in both directions.
An overview satelite image of the park showing the alternative path as prominent as the real bicycle paths around it.
Melissa

@JohannaMakesGames @Natasha_Jay That sounds like you’re expected to be superhuman? I prefer the approach of waiting for them to develop and then formalizing them.

Nyolc

@Foodecology @JohannaMakesGames @Natasha_Jay The best of both … but a clear and open mind to start the design with is needed.

Johanna Janiszewski

@Foodecology @Natasha_Jay We were expected to go and analyze the place in person and with a map of the surroundings. I have never worked as a landscape architect though, so I can't share more information on how well that turns out.

Go Up