Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Jurarigo

@Konfettispaghetti @monnier @RonSupportsYou @gleick Anyone who isn't a male cishet, really. I remember some years ago NB voice actor Casey Monguillo had their page remove for "irrelevance" despite voicing the main lead in several high profile animes and videogames, just because some fan of Spike Spencer (another VA) was butthurt about Casey's Shinji Ikari and filed the article for irrelevance repeteadly until it got deleted.
Wikipedia certainly have problems.

2 comments
RonSupportsYou

@Jurarigo_ @Konfettispaghetti @monnier @gleick I understand and sympathize with the Wikipedia decision that Monguillo has not yet reached the level of fame that would justify a Wikipedia entry. These decisions are debatable but I side with Wikipedia on this one.

Jurarigo

@RonSupportsYou @Konfettispaghetti @monnier @gleick You kidding, right? First of all, the decision was revoked merely days later, because it was exclusively requested and taken on the basis that Casey as Shinji wasn't as notorious as Spike Spencer. Second, not only Casey have quite the impressive body of work, they're being at it since 2006 and the article cite 57 external sources proving it.
You can read the discussion page, is quite absurd:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Cas

An excerpt from the linked discussion page, to be precise "Contested deletion per CSD G4 on 3 November 2019"
An excerpt from the linked discussion page, to be precise "Contested deletion per CSD G4 on 3 November 2019"
Go Up