@eniko okay, a lot of thoughts.

1. Yes, AI art is wrong.
2. "it has fundamental flaws" was the argument made against Flash and I still think "let's make everything ever made with it inaccessible to future generations" was a leap too far, so I am very wary of that kind of arguments.
3. Though you can theoretically hardwire that "don't draw the 6th finger", frustratingly no one does that! The big guys who say they've fixed it, do it in post!
4. 'are you making this up' really IS a hard problem. "There is no algorithm for the truth" as Tom Scott says
5. "remember the environment" is actually pretty easy to solve, but all the solutions require much more computing power and I'd argue they're already using too much. Let's not give them ideas