Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Kartik Agaram

@neauoire @bouncepaw My definition of wiki is a set of named pages with crosslinks, some way to easily jump between pages.

In contrast with chronological notes, which are not named.

By this definition I think Wayne's wiki qualifies.

The foundational yin and yang of the knowledge-management universe are (b)logs and wikis. (And tags help convert between them, but that's a separate story.)

What's your definition? 🙂

5 comments
Devine Lu Linvega

@akkartik @bouncepaw history and editability I think, I never really thought about this until now I suppose.

I guess a text file could be a wiki, but if the suggestion is "Using Emacs/vim-style file system navigation is just moving the complexity of a wiki engine into an IDE", I'd feel a bit duped.

Kartik Agaram

@neauoire @bouncepaw "search for word at cursor" is a pretty simple thing. I wouldn't call editors that provide it IDEs.

But yes, that's what I meant by "foundational" above. Wikis are so simple that every computer is a wiki engine.

Your point about version control is a good one. OP is outsourcing that to git. Which is reasonable, but I still consider version control quite complex. So I'm overstating how foundational wikis are..

[DATA EXPUNGED]
Devine Lu Linvega

@bouncepaw @akkartik I think it has. It's a good name for that stuff. I think memex is a bit out-dated.

[DATA EXPUNGED]
Captain Jason

@neauoire @bouncepaw @akkartik

I think it’s just a writable web page (or more generically, a writable hypertext):

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/WikiWi

…which is what TBL had in mind in the first place, but it (the WWW) wound-up read-only for a handful of boring reasons.

Go Up