Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Simon Willison

What’s weird about this is that in the past I’ve tried it with LLM text summaries of my drafts and found very little value in the result - for some reason I find the NotebookLM audio conversation format much more interesting in helping me think critically about what I’ve written

8 comments
Simon Willison

Similar to how if I get ChatGPT to write me a rousing speech arguing for the installation of cozy boxes for pelicans at the harbor it feels pretty flat, but the exact same speech delivered by ChatGPT voice mode somehow hits much harder

Leaping Woman

@simon (looks lovingly into your eyes) Simon, the pelicans do not need cozy boxes.

Harro van der Klauw

@simon how about reading a transcript from the audio speech 🤔

Simon Willison

@hvdklauw the transcripts are pretty unpleasant to read in comparison to the audio - here’s a transcript I generated from one using Whisper gist.github.com/simonw/c55b9a7

Harro van der Klauw

@simon oh yeah alright then, I like, get that speech and reading are two different things, like, weird stop words that in speech are normal, or pauses that don't translate to written text.

Martijn Faassen

@simon
Yeah, it makes sense that having it presented differently helps think it through better.

It will make up a point if there isn't one, though. I played with it pointing it to two blog entries of mine and the podcasters struggled hard to connect them even though that connection wasn't really there. And caused them to miss some real points.

Go Up