Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
AdeptVeritatis

@nex @young_ullrich

They are states. 16 states with a constitution (Länderverfassung) and a parliament each.
Germany doesn't have a constitution because it would be in conflict with the 16 other ones. That's why the Grundgesetz is not a constitution and Germany is a federal state.

Some of these states just have different ways of defining themselves and their role within the federation.

2 comments
nex

@AdeptVeritatis @young_ullrich Makes sense, thanks! I said it sounds like a mistranslation because I was reminded of some misconceptions about Bundesland vs. US state. So I prefer “land”, but it's easy to confirm that you're right and I need to be more careful with the terminology.

Btw. Switzerland has Kantonsverfassungen and Austria has Landesverfassungungen and there doesn't seem to be a conflict. I don't see why the Grundgesetz wouldn't or couldn't be a constitution: bmi.bund.de/EN/topics/constitu

@AdeptVeritatis @young_ullrich Makes sense, thanks! I said it sounds like a mistranslation because I was reminded of some misconceptions about Bundesland vs. US state. So I prefer “land”, but it's easy to confirm that you're right and I need to be more careful with the terminology.

Btw. Switzerland has Kantonsverfassungen and Austria has Landesverfassungungen and there doesn't seem to be a conflict. I don't see why the Grundgesetz wouldn't or couldn't be a constitution: bmi.bund.de/EN/topics/constitu

StreetDogg

@AdeptVeritatis @nex @young_ullrich The Grundgesetz absolutely is a constitution.

It's only called Grundgesetz, because it was supposed to be a temporary constitution for West Germany only, until a united Germany could replace it with a constitution made by all germans. The name was supposed to reflect that preliminary nature.

That replacement never happened, so that name stuck around, but it is and always was a constitution.

Go Up