Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
sam henri gold

Is it a law that Android cannot have a single decent podcast client? I have like six of the top podcast apps on my phone and none of them look nice or feel good to use.

The least bad is Pocket Casts because it's not absolutely horrendous.

Podcast Addict's discover page. There are ads at the bottom, top, and interspersed in the navigation buttons. Contrast is abysmal, margins and paddings are an afterthought. There's a bright red banner at the bottom bitching about some Google app regulation that I cannot even pretend to give a shit about. Something something optimized app list.
An app called "Podcast Player". Ripped straight outta 2014 with proto-Material components, arbitrary use of type scales, an odd carousel of blurry cards with way-too-thin typography. Oh and there's a big ass Temu ad in the middle.
Pocket Casts. It's fine, I guess. There's a carousel at the top of the screen with solid colored billboards, promoting various podcasts. Directly underneath. There's a trending section that looks like an endless list but is actually another carousel? The tab bar at the bottom doesn't look at home on Android and the iconography is both custom and uninspired. There's a mini player right above the tab bar, which is green, despite the rest of the app having a blue accent color.
19 comments
sam henri gold

That first app screenshot, by the way, that's not its landing screen. The landing screen is this weird list of demands. Change my power management settings, add your Google account, restore from a backup. Buddy I just wanna browse. I don't know you like that

A blinding white screen with thin, gray body text:

You don't have any subscription yet. You can press on the toolbar + button to add new podcasts.

Don't forget to check the settings to customize the app (Mobile Data usage, automatic backup, storage folder, ...).

Orange buttons labeled: Podcasts, Restore, Settings, Help. 

Big red button: Fix app battery settings 

Full with green button: Google drive sign in
Wilhelm

@samhenrigold the only good one was Google Podcasts. Recently added to the graveyard, RIP.

BenRiceM

@samhenrigold showing ads during onboarding is absolutely wild

nigel
Agreed. Antennapod just works for me. No extra demands... How is that least bad!

CC: @samhenrigold@hachyderm.io
nigel
Ah sweet. Yeah I don't use it for discovery, I just add feeds. I have more than enough to listen to currently 😆

CC: @CosmicTraveler@mastodon.social
Matt Birchler

@samhenrigold Yes! This is my favorite example of the difference in software quality between the platforms. PC was the third or fourth best iOS podcast app, but it was easily the best Android one.

sam henri gold

@matt i’ve been giving it the benefit of the doubt, maybe my taste is different. but it seems like it’s not even a matter of taste at this point, it’s just objective quality is lower across the board on android.

it’s really disappointing since it feels like, if i ever switch to android full time, all of my apps will take a quality hit. podcasts will be worse, i don’t think i can find a good RSS reader, the spotify app is a bit worse…

Fran González

@samhenrigold @matt this is sadly true. I switched from iOS to Android last year and, even though I'm pretty happy overall with the switch, I did have to accept that I'd have to use some pretty bad apps. I have the feeling that since Material You this is slowly changing (or at least it feels like there's more nicely designed apps), but iOS is still in a whole different universe. Podcasts is just one of the many app categories where you feel it, my close second is ebook readers.

Yury Molodtsov

@samhenrigold Yep. PocketCast is #1 on Android, maybe #3-4 on iOS.

QuarterSwede

@samhenrigold I find Pocketcasts to be a good balance of iOS like & feature full. About the only thing missing is a playlists function. It also has a really good/solid CarPlay function. Couldn’t say that about Overcast (sorry Marco but it was consistently too buggy to use). It’s my personal favorite on iOS so I think saying it’s not horrendous to use is a bit hyperbolic. I do get your point though. This is why I won’t move to Android. The bar is like Windows UI low. Functional but a pain to use.

quadrivial

@samhenrigold I use Podcast Republic, paid version, and it's been perfectly fine. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Craig Reynolds

@samhenrigold I use PocketCasts on iOS and it seems like it looks a bit nice there, not sure. Regardless, check out Castamatic if you haven’t? Pretty sure that’s available cross platform and it doesn’t look horrible. It’s a bit Podcast 2.0 oriented, but seems like it has decent features and appearance from the cursory look I gave it.

Rob

@samhenrigold
What's wrong with Pocket Casts and what are you comparing it to? I use the Android, Apple and Web clients and they all work great - except that my list always has to be refreshed from an app (never the web).

Damien

@samhenrigold I understand. Few many years ago, it was impossible to find a good third party client for twitter on Android. None of them could do what tweetbot or twitterific were doing.

Go Up