Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
mav :happy_blob:

So that's that: Firefox is now the only useful browser in the world.

Meanwhile, Google controls nearly the entire web browser market, far more than Microsoft ever did at the height of the original browser wars.

Using Chromium based products makes you less safe.

windowscentral.com/software-ap

edit: to flesh this out a bit more, here is gorhill's FAQ for UBOL github.com/uBlockOrigin/uBOL-h

#chrome #chromium #manifestv3 #firefox

47 comments
lachlan but spooky

@mav I really hope Ladybird gets to the point it's prod ready

NormanDunbar

@johnglass @mav Correct. Although I do use it on Firefox. I also have PiHole running. So far Google hasn't managed to bollox that one!

SΛDIΣL :verified_multi:

@mav Iam now trying to change my workflow to text based browsers, at least on PC.

Andrew Douglass

@mav other Chromium browsers like Vivaldi still support it (for now at least).

Simon Jaeger

@mav @Fruan I actually don't hate Edge. Its aggressive marketing is a problem, but the browser itself works and seems more performant than Chrome. I acknowledge that Google owns Chromium but they seem not to have a say about whether Edge keeps the old extension framework around, which is telling. I'm mostly a Firefox person but my backup browser was Chrome. Now I guess it'll have to be Edge.

Sparky 💡

@simon @mav @Fruan Microsoft also makes money from ads though, so I would not be shocked if they make the switcheroo in Edge as well.
Heck, if anyone, then I suspect that Vivaldi would be the last Chromium-based bastion of functional adblockers, aside from maybe some "specialty-distributions" of Chromium that center on privacy, something comparable to Librewolf and Mull.

Alexia :neocat_flag_trans:

@simon

Google does have a say unless Microsoft wants to continue the MV2 implementation themselves.

There is a build flag in Chromium to include support now, but once thats gone any downstream browser will have to fend for themselves.

mav :happy_blob:

@simon
The general wisdom is that when Google finally deprecates Manifest v2, either browser makers will have to recreate/patch it back in or let it die.

Microsoft in particular has zero incentive to put it back
@Fruan

Ian

@mav Worth noting, relying an a browser extension to block ads is only partially effective at best.

A pihole will block ALL ad traffic and tracker traffic at the DNS, so every device you own is protected. This includes very chatty devices like Alexa, smart TVs, and non-browser apps on your computer that all like to phone home.

The majority of what my pihole is blocking is telemetry, not ads.

pi-hole.net/

Not trying to "um actually", just spreading the word.

noodle

@soviut @mav

Yes and, #pfBlockerNG does all that plus supports IP block lists.

Tariq

@soviut @mav

running an extra bit of hardware is not ideal.

it would be nice if the combined modem-wifi-routers that we already have at home could run pi-hole or similar filters

years ago didn't people run custom OSes on some netgear modem-routers?

EaterOfSnacks

@rzeta0 @soviut @mav Can't speak for Netgear but you can on Asus and some other makes: OpenWRT and a couple of others. I don't know how resource intensive pihole is but some consumer routers were/are woefully underspecced. Took a different tack here and turned a mini pc into an OpnSense router and added a blacklist that cuts the majority of ads. Might not be everyone's cup of tea though.

Davey

@soviut @mav

This is true but I've been planning to set up a pihole for about a decade and still haven't gotten around to it.

Ublock et al take minutes and no money.

Robin

@mav Imagine being an Android and Chromebook user, who uses GMail, Chrome, Youtube, etc. Google basically owns your digital life. There's no getting out of that situation gracefully.

DELETED

@Robin_Van_Ee @mav

Took me 24 hours and a new cell phone provider

Daniel Reeders

@mav and Google pays Mozilla how much per year?

TerrorBite :veripawed3:

@engagedpractx @mav About $510 million. Soon to be zero, if the Google Search antitrust lawsuit forbids those payments. Which will likely kill Mozilla, and Firefox along with it.

sef

@mav @engagedpractx but it’s their antitrust insurance policy

Milosz

@mav what about Safari? At least it’s not Google.

kaelef

@mav @trending_bot I honestly don’t understand why so many people have continued to insist on using Chrome despite years of Google’s anti-consumer behavior. And, at this point, we need some government(s) to step up and help fund Mozilla for the good of the internet. It was obvious we were headed back to the bad old days of Internet Explorer ages ago, but, as with climate change, but just won’t be inconvenienced even mildly.

Torge Rosendahl

@mav Arc has at least promised to support Manifest v2 until 2025 and is supposedly working on a built-in ad- and tracker-blocker in the mean time.

resources.arc.net/hc/en-us/art

DELETED

@torgeros That’s only because Google is keeping the MV2 code - for organizations that haven’t migrated their in-house extensions, yet - in the browser. All of the Chromium reskins that claim to still support MV2 extensions aren’t really doing any extra work or being less dependent on Google.

@mav

mav :happy_blob:

@apollon
This. All the Chromium skins are on borrowed time.
@torgeros

Morten Juhl-Johansen

@mav If a business model can not survive ad or spam blocking, it does taste a bit like a scam

C.S.Strowbridge

@mav

It's not intrusive ads I'm worried about. It's malicious ads.

mav :happy_blob:

@firecat
Safari is a proprietary closed source browser that implemented these changes already.

The difference between a Mac and a Chromebook is that Chromebooks are cheap.

mori_au 🇦🇺

@mav I’m always surprised that people actually use #chrome. I know I shouldn’t but I am.

Toran Shaw - M7TOR

@mav it's not useful to me, considering Firefox doesn't respect my language choice, plus several key extensions don't exist.

Daniel

@mav and they always manage to spin it as something good for us ❤️

Yeah it's dangerous to execute externally hosted JS...then why the fuck are you trying to force me to execute the injected JS of a thousand fucking trackers and ads?? 🤬

Oh that's right, cause you're an ad delivery company that happened to also build a web browser

Ruarí Ødegaard

@mav You are making the assumption here that no other browser has a built in blocker and that is a false assumption.

mav :happy_blob:

@ruario
I actually quite like Vivaldi (and use it for work stuff), but their built-in ad blocker has about one-tenth of the functionality of tools like uBO or Privacy Badger.

Moreover, I am still unconvinced that a for profit entity will ever do this well.

waldi

@mav Yes, Firefox is one of the remaining browsers, where an extension can slurp up any secret and post them to a remote location without anyone noticing.

And ublock origin could have with pretty small reduction in usefulness converted to the new api years ago.

mav :happy_blob:

@waldi
That is indeed the risk you take for having additional control of what the software does on the computer you ostensibly own.

You could also just get malware.

Solution: Chromebooks for everyone! 🤮

Rob

@mav
Without Google, Mozilla is dead I the water. Google controls Mozilla, too.

If I were a Firefox user, I’d be paying close attention to the antitrust news right now. Because Mozilla’s spigot of money is at risk.

bloomberg.com/news/newsletters

MugsysRapSheet 🔩🐑🐘

@mav
The only reason "#Chrome" dominates the browser market is b/c it comes preinstalled on every #Android phone & Chromebook.

Exclude those, and only count browsers that people take the time to install & use, and their market dominance would be a fraction of what the numbers claim.

Before #Firefox, I used Netscape. So I guess I've been a #Mozilla user since the beginning.

jamespthomas

@mav i no longer use a browser on my phone,have not for a while,thanks google

Steven Sandoval

@mav Welcome, Google Chrome users. Mozilla Firefox is straight ahead. Firefox Nightly is to your right. Make sure to leave a donation so you close your causal loops. mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/

mozilla.org/firefox/channel/de

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causalit

Go Up