@Crell @jerry I think the idea that an otherwise terrible person had like 20 years ago holds up pretty well: paying for initial access results in you having an investment in a service that encourages you to follow the rules to protect that investment. You can see this with how Something Awful has turned into a stable and mature forum with varied subforums and at least one thread for anything you can think of.
Of course the downside to that is that if the person setting the rules is terrible then the culture will be terrible and require a coup to fix, but... that seems to be a universal part of the human condition.
@teknogrot @jerry "The culture of an organization is defined as the worst behavior its leadership is willing to tolerate."
No amount of federation will change that dynamic.