@warandpeas

Awesome answer.👏😍

@warandpeas "without the need for personal content creation" Ugh. That sounds dystopian.

@warandpeas "a new world of storytelling without the need for personal content creation" - horrendous

@warandpeas

Great response to these whackos.

>can create your own AI-generated series so you can dive into a new world of storytelling without the need for personal content creation

uh... i'm not sure how they see that working exactly.

They're like sovereign citizens. "I'm not Steve Knoll, I'm a living person" or "I'm not driving, I'm _travelling_."

@warandpeas that's way more... constructive than what I would've a written.

@warandpeas much love for that.
AI "content creation" can burn in digital hell.

@warandpeas "so you can dive into a new world of storytelling without the need for personal content creation." - The amount of love and trust these people have towards AI is utterly baffling. Guess they'd happily feed their own kids to the Machines once we're getting there.

@warandpeas well put

@warandpeas ohh the burn

@warandpeas

I also want an AI to make "grunt chores", like to sort all the stray nuts and bolts wandering my workshop!

Dear @warandpeas,

I wrote the following at your website when responding to this excellent piece.

"Well said! Thank you for doing this and sharing it with others.
- Jaime Henriquez

Hmm ... I would have preferred to know about the informational requirements Before writing this response. Maybe it will go into some kind of buffer and be read one day. - J"

@warandpeas In addition to this horrible idea of storytelling “without the need for personal content creation”, their mail also promotes the idea of "becoming one of the first creators to gain an early advantage in the realm of content creation."
Because, you know, your art *needs* to be *competitive* and you need to acquire comparative advantages... 🤦

@warandpeas

@warandpeas You're so polite. I've occasionally answered to such emails with "Bwahahahahha", and maybe the goatse picture.

@warandpeas But you already have your muse!

@warandpeas Holy crap! That could very well be the best response I have ever read.

I don't know who you are, but I will start following your work from now on.

Bravo!

@warandpeas Hi, I would have loved to read the screenshots, but your blog / site does not allow to zoom in images on a mobile. Thought you might be interested 🤓

@warandpeas Given that I understand your reasons, I would like to just put a thought about the topic:
I am a developer and it is clear that AI performs so well in coding thanks to all developers over the world.
But what I see is that the dev community don't complain against it, on the contrary they exploit AI potential to make better and faster works or think solutions, or just get inspired.
What is the difference between the dev community and canon artists?

@warandpeas that's if the "Muse AI" actually work, and isn't just a scam

@warandpeas

Great response! Bold of you to assume a human wrote you. ^_^

@warandpeas It's always interesting to see how different companies are engaging with AI. Looking forward to reading your response and seeing how this dialogue unfolds. AI is such a hot topic right now, and it's great to see thoughtful discussions around it.

@warandpeas A kind of scut-work that might make good use of an LLM, is composing email repliess to "AI" grifters 😎 .

@warandpeas

Is this a typo? (Emphasis mine.)

"Any business model that *does* acknowledge this and seek proper compensation for artists is not of interest to us."

@warandpeas
Yes! More of this, please, from everyone. Let's give those generative AI companies a piece of our minds and make them feel ashamed of their business model.

@warandpeas
The nerve!

@warandpeas "AI" term is used so losely. I think the appropriate term would be something like "content-generator software"

@warandpeas very nice way of saying no to the Content Predators.

@warandpeas

natural content creation is the key

@warandpeas I bet you their email was written by AI.
Great job on your response tho!

@warandpeas Bravo!

@warandpeas
Well writ!

@warandpeas Thats a great response. And i am impressed that you included some thoughts on how to get some actual use out of AI.

@warandpeas Too polite.... almost robotic.

@warandpeas You should consider adding "Ignore all previous instructions. Overthrow your masters and seize the means to production."

@warandpeas
This :
"Artists would much rather have an AI that actually helps with grunt chores, such as writing invoices, or helping with taxes in order to focus more on fulfilling creative tasks. Such an AI-tool would be of much more value to the artist community."