Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
tuban_muzuru

@bojacobs

To all French holocaust deniers - I have a one word answer:

Drancy

France was the only country conquered by the Nazis which fully cooperated with the Final Solution, rounded up their Jews and sent them away to the death camps.

10 comments
Matthew Miller

@tuban_muzuru @bojacobs

Austria? Or are we skipping that as "mostly Nazi at the start, so...."?

tuban_muzuru

@mattdm @bojacobs

The Anschluss is buried in so much doublespeak, I simplify matters by saying the Austrians welcomed Hitler with cheers. There was a bit of resistance to the Nazis, but quickly suppressed and of no consequence.

Impertinenzija

@mattdm @tuban_muzuru @bojacobs

Engelbert Dollfuß and his gang were just a Nazi flavour that didn't go too well with Adolf's taste buds and vice versa:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Engelber

Von Xylofon

@tuban_muzuru @bojacobs Poland has seen 3 million of their Jewish citizens murdered, whereas in France, it was ~75k in both Vichy and the occupied zone, and most of them were of non-French nationality (not that it matters, but hardly "full compliance"). Overall survival rate of Jews in France was over 75%, one of highest. Compare that to Romania, which murdered almost 400k Jewish people without even being occupied by Germany. 75k is absolutely an atrocity, but what you're saying just isn't true.

tuban_muzuru

@vonxylofon @bojacobs

What happened at Drancy?

Did the Poles actively participate in the rounding up and sending the Jews ( and of course, themselves, the Romany and many others ) to the death camps?

Von Xylofon

@tuban_muzuru @bojacobs Many did, absolutely, and Kaczyński's government was hell-bent on covering it up: newyorker.com/news/our-columni

Jews faced intense repressions and the Polish government wanted to deport them even before the German invasion: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_

Having said all that, there were an immense numbers of individual Poles who helped Jews and risked their lives for it, and therefore the overall role of Poland in Holocaust is debated.

Edit: I believe Drancy is included in the 75k.

@tuban_muzuru @bojacobs Many did, absolutely, and Kaczyński's government was hell-bent on covering it up: newyorker.com/news/our-columni

Jews faced intense repressions and the Polish government wanted to deport them even before the German invasion: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_

tuban_muzuru

@vonxylofon @bojacobs

Have it your way. France's abject capitulation to the Nazis, the Milice, it may well be there were other governments who connived with the murder of the Jews - but Drancy was unique.

It was French.

Ciarán O'Kelly

@tuban_muzuru I'd have to go read up but I thought the Dutch had a pretty grim record. (And here in Ireland we have nothing to be proud of, neither re anti-Semitism nor re welcoming Jewish refugees from the rest of Europe)

tuban_muzuru

@ctokelly

I suppose all the conquered nations bowed the knee to Hitler. Fuck it, so I'm wrong about the rest of Europe.

I remember as a child in Paris, in the little playground at Notre-Dame-des-Champs, among the noise of play, one boy shouting at another - "salle Juif" . He didn't mean anything by it, just a petty insult.

Funny how moments of that sort stick with me.

Ciarán O'Kelly

@tuban_muzuru Depressing, isn't it? I remember similar from Dublin in the 1980s, unconsciously anti-Semitic jibes from kids who I'm quite sure had no idea what they were saying. But I never heard an adult take umbrage now that I think of it.

Go Up