Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Carolyn

@mnalis @lio @internetarchive You sound like a tech bro justifying sucking in work of others for AI. Authors depend on sales of their books. If some random person decides to buy one book, scan it, then make it avail be for many others, that is theft, however you want to do mental gymnastics to justify it.

4 comments
Matija Nalis

@CStamp @lio @internetarchive You keep using that word "theft". I don't think it means what you think it means. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theft

If you think something is copyright infringement, then please say that instead (and if possible provide references why you think so). For example, in my little part of the world (#Croatia in #EU), the right of public libraries is enshrined in #Copyright law and does not require any consent of the copyright holders (much less authors). 1/n

Carolyn

@mnalis @lio @internetarchive It is stealing someone's livelihood to take a book, scan it, then make it available to masses of people.

Matija Nalis

@CStamp @lio @internetarchive
Are you aware of the concept of Public Libraries? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_l ? It would seem to me that you either are not aware, or are totally opposed to their existence for some reason? Are you aware that they are part of authors incomes?

Matija Nalis

@CStamp @lio @internetarchive

Any yes, we are taxed for that privilege, and those taxes are supposedly being used to support the said artists. I don't know the situation in Internet Archives jurisdiction, but would like to learn -- without being called names. (and if possible, by someone knowledgeable providing links to back up their claims. If you're interested in my references for #Croatia it's at zakon.hr/z/106/Zakon-o-autorsk Ĩlanak 34.) 2/2

Go Up