Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Graham Lea

@jonw @jan @davidho Imagine if everyone was already driving cars they could fill up slowly at home cheaply or even for free, and someone tried to convince them to switch to expensive petrol only available at select locations that change the price every day based on events on the other side of the world, just because it’s really quick. They’d be a laughing stock.

15 comments
Krupo

@evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho exactly.

Having whatever version you want of a 100% charge always available at the start of your commuting day is a huge mindshift that people used to filling up with gas every few days don't appreciate.

"Will I have enough gas before I need to refill" is the gas version of range anxiety.

draeath

@evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho the difference, I think, is that you can carry a can of fuel to your car, fill it, and move it immediately.

An EV doesn't have any such means of moving the thing *right now* in an emergency sense. (besides towing, or course)

Maggie Maybe

@draeath @evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho OK but when was the last time you ran out of gas by accident and had to utilize a can of gas you were carrying around with you?

I have ADHD and MECFS so when I remember to plan ahead I don’t always have the energy to actually do it. And even I have never had this problem.

draeath

@maggiejk @evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho I see some poor sap doing that on the commute to/fro work at least once a month. I don't let it get that empty, though.

I have been in the "reserve" once or twice, where I had "0" gallons left, but I have a fuel flow monitor and know how much tank space I actually have. Habits from learning to fly.

Sturmkrähe

@draeath @maggiejk @evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho This is so wild to me. I have never in my whole life seen something like this (outside of a TV ad) nor heard of it happening to anyone.

draeath

@avradi @maggiejk @evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho I see it (relatively) frequently, where I live, at least once every few months. But people are idiots here.

We even have small utility trucks patrol the highways who carry some, plus tire patch kits and the like. I think one of our major insurance companies runs them. In another state, I've seen similar run by the department of transportation: dot.ga.gov/GDOT/Pages/HERO.asp - they carry fuel cans as well if I remember right.

We drive a *lot* here.

@avradi @maggiejk @evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho I see it (relatively) frequently, where I live, at least once every few months. But people are idiots here.

We even have small utility trucks patrol the highways who carry some, plus tire patch kits and the like. I think one of our major insurance companies runs them. In another state, I've seen similar run by the department of transportation: dot.ga.gov/GDOT/Pages/HERO.asp - they carry fuel cans as well if I remember right.

Leeloo

@draeath @evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho
Not only that, I can carry a booster battery to my car and jump start it when the battery has discharged itself after a winter of not driving, or carry the battery inside to charge it.

Lithium batteries may take slightly longer to self discharge, but as far as I know they rarely survive when it does happen.

Martin Vermeer FCD

@draeath @evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho Actually the equivalent is charging from any ordinary grid socket. There is a standard cable for that coming with every EV. It is not recommended except in an emergency and only gives 3.7 kW. Yes, you should *never* go to zero charge, or close to it. That means towing. The thinking with an EV is really different... much more forward looking. A bit like flying.

Mike

@draeath @evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho
I've not had a can of petrol in the car for the last 30+ years. I don't know anyone who still does this.

draeath

@MikeFromLFE @evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho I didn't say you kept it in the car, but that you could obtain one quickly if you had a problem.

drukac

@evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho

However, for street lighting, as opposed to slow charging from one's residential installation, there are costly complications:

1. Street lighting circuits are usually un-metered. Adding meters is a costly investment with under-powered results. When you charge from home this is already taken care of, since your private installations are billed.

1/4

drukac

@evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho

2. Street lighting was already efficient before LEDs. Most street lamps are/were one of the discharge gas variants. They are slow to start but in the same range as LEDs for efficiency. It's not really the case that there is untapped capacity in these circuits.

2/4

drukac

@evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho

3. Slow charge at home may be OK, but if all the cars along a busy row-house street attempt it at the same time, it becomes unfeasible. Again, the circuits feeding homes are larger and can usually cope with night-time simultaneous charging, but street lighting circuits would struggle in most areas where the spatial need makes the idea attractive.

3/4

drukac

@evolvable @jonw @jan @davidho

4. There are safety issues regarding the earthing (grounding) and protection offered by street lighting circuits. In the UK they cap individual loads on these circuits to 2KW (9Amsp) to get around that cheaply. If you want to connect bigger loads, then you'll need to invest in compliant earthing, which may make the concept unfeasible.

Once all of those issues are addressed, the whole concept withers on the vine due to costs.

4/4

Go Up